I agree, I was very disappointed with Choice of Alexandria (I thought it would be Choice of Robots in Alexandria) and Hero Project: Redemption Season.
I learnes that even if the autor has already made a good game, it doesn’t mean the next one will be good.
…actually,that’s about it.Everything else was either mediocre or flat out shit.
Hell,here’s a list of the games that I found to be disappointing,cuz why not?
Empyrean.
The Hero Project:Redemption Season.
Choice Of Alexandria.
Machinations.
Versus:The Elite Trials (this is technically an exception.I wouldn’t consider it poor in quality or anything like that.However,it just didn’t…click with me,unlike the first one)
I thought Alexandria was decent, obviously nowhere near the heights of CoR, but I could still name worse games this year. It had a decent amount of choice, setting was good, and I like the way the author does stats. I just wish it was longer. What were your problems with it?
The problem with Alexandria is that I had high hopes for it. Choice of Robots is one of the best games CoG has ever released, so I was expecting more than a “decent game”, I was expecting a memorable game like Choice of Robots.
This year was very weak for CoG in my opnion (I only really liked Versus), meanwhile It was a strong year for HoG (GoI, LH2, ZE:SH, SoH2 and others).
Thankfully the next year Cog will release good games like Cryptkeepers of Hallowford and Choice of Rebel.
I’d say my favorites were A Midsummer Night’s Choice and Zombie Exodus: Safe Haven, though in rather different ways. Well, one’s more comic and the other’s apocalyptic. They’re both good on interesting characters and immersion, however, and generally enjoyability.
My runner-up would be The Sea Eternal. Beautiful descriptions, interesting philosophy, deeply compelling. I just didn’t find it quite as grabbing from a story perspective. It does, however, feature squids, and that’s really all you need to tempt me.
There’s a lot of big names that I just haven’t read, though
I haven’t played that many games this year since the plot often didn’t wake my interest, and many of those I do have played were certainly enjoyable, but didn’t really click with me - or just didn’t leave a lasting impression.
(Then again, I’m kinda struggling to figure out which games have been released this year and which ones are from 2015. Time is such a pesky thing.)