Hmmm⌠I was looking for a Wild West journey wips like cowboys, and I found your story. Itâs sounds intriguing. Iâll check this out right away, and Iâll pm you about my feedback/review. So far itâs good.
Edit: I sent you already my pm and I know you know it haha. This story is cool and Iâll look forward to it. donât give up!
Haha thank you, I did check out "The Evil Hound, nice work You are good a imagining futuristic stuffs, will def leave you some suggestions later today.
I wanted to ask you how do you decide to go with âIâ or âYouâ when narrating the MC, is it an author preference?
Definitely a lot of grammar corrections to do, but a very good story so far.
Iâd recommend changing how the gangs gender is determined. I know basing it on players romantic preference has been done on multiple other stories, but Iâve never been a fan of that. If you can make it so that each characters gender is determined by the reader individually, Iâve always preferred that style. The lost heir does it this way if you want an example. I like this way better, because it allows the MC to have a romantic relationship with the character of their choice, and a brotherly or sisterly relationship with another character of their choice. If that makes sense.
Example: I choose that my MC is attracted to women, and I romance Willow. All good so far, but then I only want to be friends with the others. Dang, Willows got 2 sisters to go hang out with for a girlâs night, but I donât have any Bros to hang with.
haha yes grammar is my weakness, thanks for the suggestion, I will give it a try, the league is four members (with the MC joining being the fourth since Tao is now out)
The romance stats are hidden until you make a romance-able choice toward a character.
So you can romance all 3 or romance 2 or 1 and be friends with whomever you are not romancing
Iâm very interested in this wip! I usually donât like westerns, but this one seems a lot more inclusive and interesting than others I have seen. I also really like the character customization and things at the beginning.
Small spoiler
I was kinda stumped on the Dutch hamster riddle, and then when I found out what the answer was, I nearly broke down. I hate puns but I also love them.
Typos and Issues
Just wanted to point out a few examples of sentences where the word that started the quote was not capitalized. And also, here are a few places where the sentence seems to run on. I will edit more as I replay and as you update.
I think trying to include the player characterâs background is good, but will be odd to read unless you make it a lot more granular; right now itâs in very broad strokes. Most people donât call themselves European, for example, and certainly at the time would have defaulted to âGermanâ or âWelshâ or another specific nationality (if not something even more specific, e.g. âSwabianâ instead of âGermanâ). The same applies to the other identities- being Japanese vs. Indian would mean very different things for the character, as would being an ex-slave vs. an Ethiopian or Cree vs. Inuit, even if those ethnicities are very broadly under the same category.
Thank you for reading, yes it is intended to be used broadly. The terms European and Native and African are used in this story to refer to the MC roots from his/her motherâs side.
I did not want to limit the MC ancestry to only a country or a nationality. The only ancestry that is defined is the Native because the mother side of the MC is Apache.
I agree that most of the âold immigrantsâ at that time were German or Welsh, but there were also from Ireland, Scandinavia, and more. For me, it was easier to fit them in the European category instead of specifying German or Welsh.
Thank you for readingâŚso you went the dangerous path haha thatâs good, You should try the path of the league tooâŚitâs completely different ROs.
Currently working on something else but will update soon