Thank you for the response! While I do think that I decided on making them NB in part because of the fact that I just felt it fit, there is a larger reason for it as well and I want to be able to explore gender without having to write too many variations on important scenes for Cyril. I don’t want to give too much away, but I am stubborn about it for an in character reason. I just don’t think it would as well work if Cyril was made into a female or male character. Since the other two are gender selectable, I think it’s probably fine, though personally if I was romancing characters and I wasn’t attracted to NB people I know I would be abit frustrated (since Cyril is by far the closest to the type I like to romance.)
Regarding the personality thing, I am thinking it is more subtle, it’s about how you present yourself to the romantic interest more than all your decisions in the game. Basically, you can have a reserved character who is brash and a bit cruel, but lets say hypothetically Cyril finds that kind of personality very abrasive. Cyril will not be attracted to the MC if they see them acting that way, particularly toward them. I’m planning for a kind of point system based off of the behavior the MC uses around the Love Interests. However, there is specific actions the player takes that if a LI finds out about, they will confront and potentially cut off romance for. (Let’s say, hypothetically, attempting to poison their sibling or lying about something very important.)
A large part of my inspiration for this game is the fact that a lot of romance games don’t feel like there is any impact at all based off gender. In a historical fantasy game… It feels very… Shallow? For there to be no difference, particularly in queer relationships, and there isn’t enough exploration of how that might be different. (I’m really inspired by I, the Forgotten One, though I don’t think my story will have as much graphic material.)
Edit: Also, now that I think about this, and tell me what you think, but having a LI have a response depending on if you are going out of your way to treat them a bit differently might be very interesting. (Let’s say, for example, that Marcy will be confused if they know you are generally a warm person, and you suddenly give them the cold shoulder). So much to think on!
Edit 2: I just got a very cute idea for a Nonbinary MC scene with Cyril, and now I’m more stubborn about it than ever.
To summarize:
Cyril will be NB for plot and character reasons (to explore the dynamics of that kind of relationship)
Romantic Interests will become attracted to some types of people more than others (I will include a guide in game for people wondering generally what they need to do to attract their love interest.)
