Well what can I say, You do a good job of writing her in a way that’s easy to go “nah, forget this” and having at least two alternative options helps But nah obviously completely unintentional.
I do get the strain of having outside events monopolize your free time, So I’ll keep checking in from time to time but hope to see it keep going from strength to strength.
Jones’ gender is player preference (only male and female though), of course the twins are male/female, Beverly non-binary, and with out haven’t it right in front of me the two “nameable” NPCs are player preference (male, female, or non-binary) of course there’s not.mucj interaction at the moment as far as romancing goes at the moment. I’ve said it before but I don’t recall how far up, most of the characters’ personalities are developing as I write them, the two NPCs you can name will be fairly reader discretion, I wanted to kind of incorporate an option where people can have people in their real life in their story if they wanted to do that. But that is also hard to do if I tried to get too detailed with them. I definitely post on here when I update.
Glad you enjoyed it so far. Throwing the MC birthday party in there was pretty tricky since it was an after thought (why it will be improved as well) more interactions will be put in for the next update. Trying to work on a ton of different things interactive fiction and regular fiction all at the same time until I can get my mind to focus on one project.
Good chance. I planned on up to 15 years in the pro league. There of course will be four years for high school, up to four in college (you Cana decide to draft early), and with figuring up to15 years at the pro level I may have to split it into a couple of games. I’ve always liked sports manager games, so there is a possibility.
@spoano Hi, I have a suggestion, it seems UNFAIR that I randomly have a neck injury and the mc becomes invalid. I would like an option to be added to avoid that using the statistics and that it is not random, this makes the game a headache for me opinion edit 1 I was playing the game for a while longer and I don’t really like the options that are “script” I like that everything depends on the statistics, not the script
That is the only injury that would be script related, it’s more of a choice of take care of yourself or try to push forward. I’ll probably add a stat check as well (if there isn’t one already) the only way to avoid the neck injury is to sit out the rest of that game. More or less it’s just to show you can have career ending injuries.
I’ve been working on my normal writing projects lately, but I plan on getting back on to both my WIPs with demos ASAP. After losing my mother last year I had a hard time focusing on one project and jumping around quite a bit, but I’ve regained some focus and my interactive fictions have been pushed back slightly in the order I want to work on things.
Great game, but she/her turned into he/him at this scene at the dance.
He seemed like he was really into you. You leaned in, lips puckered up, eyes closed. A brief second passed before you felt his lips pressed against yours. After your lips released each other from the electric current pulling them together, you looked deep into Sherry’s eyes and the question popped out before you had a choice. “So you want to be my date… I mean like dating,” you asked.
Also found an error at this scene.
Sherry called to congratulate you on the win and asked if you would like to go on a date Sunday.
Agreeing will result in this.
high line 3600: Invalid expression, couldn’t extract another token: 'm"))
Coach Dibbs and Singleton gave you the week off of practice and the day before the next game asked if you wanted to sit out or start.
Selecting to sit out will loop back to this.
You didn’t want to risk further injury. With your concussion, you didn’t want to have a big party, so everyone just sent you their best wishes and birthday cards. With your head still dazed you also decided socializing was out of the question, outside of everyone contacting you asking how you were doing. Did you have any crushes other than the relationships you already have?
@spoano This is my first post, and for me, it couldn’t be for a more interesting game.
As a pretty substantial sports fan (hockey, football, soccer, rugby), I was excited from the game’s premise alone. It just so happens to be a fictional but unique blend of my top three favorite sports, and the execution overall makes sense, is exciting, and is reasonably easy to understand and get right into. This series’ potential has not yet fully been stated by anyone I’ve seen thus far. With some simple polish and expansion, this could easily be a standout piece of IF. The market is untapped yet there, and as a few others have stated, this sport being entirely fictional brings in so much freedom and freshness to invite in non-sports fans, as well as just being a cool concept. Mixing sports is such a new idea, and I don’t think anyone has really tried it on this level before in entertainment or in real life. Originality is so hard and rare these days but here we have some!
With my starting, excited blurb out of the way, let’s get down to specifics. I’ve never really written feedback before, so I’ll go ahead and just break my thoughts down bit by bit and try to get them out as simply but clearly as I can, starting with the positives:
The EB games themselves are pretty well-written, specifically the first one and the State championship. I do feel like they could have been longer, but none felt rushed and I personally was satisfied and thought I could contribute a good amount each time. I ended the game with 33 EZs and felt good. Almost every game had an event happen or some type of general drama, and this was nice and made sure not a single one felt repetitive. Athletes in real life like myself (formerly) know that they never really do. You’re always supposed to be completely absorbed by the moment and each tackle, score, block, juke, and throw in any activity should feel new. Not like you’ve never done it before, but simply always exciting. You captured this greatly with your enthusiastic descriptions as well as some of the beef real athletes can and do sometimes get into.
The Coach’s attitude was actually pretty grounded. I’ve had coaches like that before and a lot are serious hard asses, but only in the same way as military drill instructors, where they’re not trying to actually offend or bring down anyone, it’s simply to build that no bullshit mentality and help harden character, both integral things when talking about high-physicality sports, as not everyone can do it, again, similar to the military. Agree with it or not, these means are proven, although sometimes coaches can obviously cross the line, as I felt this one did a couple times. Not a problem, as, again, it does happen, so intentional or not it should be acceptable at least in my opinion. However, I felt she rode this line too hard; she is an extremely one dimensional character and never really encourages the team or hypes us up. Simply put, I feel you instead relied on the trope a little too much and made her a little too negative and easily disappointed. Real, good coaches, know when to switch. She never does, so that is not only an inaccuracy, but a real fatal flaw, as well. I found myself not really caring for my coach because of it. Only when I got the concussion did she show any empathy, and that just added to it. So, you nailed her character, as I’ve never seen a parental-style coach that other games try to do for whatever reason, but basically focused too much on her occupation and ignored fleshing her out as a human being.
The dates, parties, and summer activities. Even in a sports game, stepping away from the competition can be essential to the overall enjoyment of the title. You managed to supply the player with a good handful of scenes away from the field, and getting to know the other characters and the opportunity to see them interact in class or out of school entirely kept them and the world feeling alive, with a surprising amount of depth in the romance and hangout scenes specifically. I enjoyed these, and the role relationships with your teammates have, especially, like when Ramirez saved me during the scrimmage. Good stuff, juicy stuff. But also the effect it can have on the actual field, too, if a little too limited. I didn’t see too many scenes change depending on my relationship with someone, and I feel that should be expanded upon in an update or sequel. Trust is everything in team-based sports. That’s why teams in real life have mandatory hangouts.
The stats. Wide variety, all made sense, and even allowed for a little customization on exactly what kind of player I wanted to be. I found myself becoming a star running back, focusing on sprinting and catching, and then eventually evasion and durability in order to make those long EZs. Next playthrough, I tried being a linebacker of sorts, and also found some success. The coding and foundation is there, yet the one major flaw I felt was the difficulty can spike a little too much in my opinion. A couple times I found myself getting punished for diversifying my stats mid to late-game, and think the stat checks in the first two games at least should be lowered a bit to help this. The State championship felt honestly perfect, but it could probably be lowered just a tad, too. This will let specialists and Jack-of-All-Trades to be viable. As of right now, it feels like being a running back is the only way to have a truly great and satisfying playthrough. The game shouldn’t reflect the high demands of sports too much.
The team choices. You have the custom input option there, but Beaumont High Bulldogs in my favorite color scheme of red and black? Too catchy, too classic. Chose it every time. Great variation and real life inspiration, here. Might even make some art for these if the game gets published (fingers crossed!).
Now for the negative. Wil try my best to also be constructive, of course.
Derrick Derrickson. Derrick…Derrickson. And Mike Michaels. These names…were a little funny at first, but it is so offputting once you actually get into the story, especially the first time reading. Obviously intentional humor is fine, but this was kinda immersion-breaking. I am of the opinion it needs to be changed. Reed Derrickson, Toby Michaels, boom, easy fix. Pretty much anything else will do. I just think this game is good enough to take itself seriously. If these names are here just for the humor, well, then the negative effects far outweigh the hilarity, in my opinion.
The revenge scene during the State championship. I see what you were going for, here, and I have no problems with dark scenes in a sports game, especially set during highschool. The angst is high, and so is the adrenaline. Things like this unfortunately could and have happened in reality, even in pro settings. Look at hockey’s infamously-enforced fisticuffs. Disagree with it or not, violence can and does happen on the field or wherever else. However, I personally and respectfully feel the throat-stomping option was a bit much and dramatically needs to be replaced. The consequences to that action didn’t feel realistic anyways, and it just feels so out of place. I think it should be a sharp kick to the ribs or something instead, which would be easier to hide. The move you chose is just too much, even given the stakes and motivation. There should be something way less lethal, there. And this is coming from a player who punched him earlier in the game. It should be changed or taken out entirely. The second option is a little humorous and even classic, its just this one that goes a little too far. Again, I get what you were going for, it could just be better and make more sense. Also, if you’re gonna get that serious, why have those funny names? Game needs some tone work.
The description of Extreme Ball, specifically the types of plays, could be expanded on, too. I could honestly probably help with this, if you’d be interested. Shoot me a DM if you are. I have some ideas for this and feel like I understand your sport enough to aid in that.
The length. Honestly, I feel like the first game should be your first two years of highscool, not merely one. I get why you don’t want to do all of high school in one book, but doing one book for each year seems redundant. I think the game would be a more complete package with at least the first two years, then the second contains your last two years and the setup for college if you’re still writing the series at that point. I feel like this plan makes more sense, all due respect. This would put book one at around 60,000 words if at a similar length as Freshman Year, and that would help combat the “game too short” reviews you will get spammed with if you publish as is, unfair as they are. But it would also simply deliver a better and more complete package in my opinion.
Edit: It appears as though I have made a mistake. I could have sworn you mentioned somewhere wanting to publish Freshman Year as its own game. If this is inaccurate, please ignore my last point.
That is all for now. If you couldn’t tell, I love this game for what it could be, and I see a lot of potential in it. All the luck, bud!
Thanks for the feedback. I plan on circling back to editing the freshman (the birthday party was an after thought and was a bit of a coding nightmare to add after the story) this is just a demo, it will either end up being just highschool or go all the way up to college. Not sure where I’ve mentioned it before, but I plan on the full game(s) leading up to 15 years in the pro-league, whether I split it up is still in the air.
I intentionally made each played game different so it wouldn’t be repetitive, there’s a couple of scenes that will probably be pushed back later until junior or senior year. The names are sort of for comical reasons, in life there’s a mix of comedy and tragedy. Mostly they are just place holders. This was actually my second demo I felt comfortable enough to release and I’m hoping to get the freshman and sophomore years ready as soon as possible.
Social interactions will be one of the main focuses once I get back on it. Some of the characters personalities didn’t really come to me until after writing a lot of the story and some interactions I want to change up or at least hold off until the player’s are a little older. Derrick’s story is from over also.
I just noticed I accidentally said the first two games should be made easier. I meant the last two before State, including Divisional. My bad if you were confused on that suggestion. The first two games are definitely easy enough lol!
Just did another combover and I agree some of the interactions, particularly romantic, would be more appropriate and fitting for the later years. Something I do appreciate is how putting in extra practice doesn’t automatically make people hate you or destroy your relationships. Many games, even non-sports ones, sometimes think that to balance statbuilding, roleplay or relationships must suffer a cost, and I honestly never understood this mentality, especially in RPGs.
Glad to hear that about Derrick. I still am of the opinion that choice feels out of touch, though.
Tomorrow I will try building a a defender and other different things to test the other choices.