Thank you. I thought we could because Bailey can 
1 Like
Is it possible for Kelly to be taken hostage by the Silverthornes and Benton taken hostage by us in the same play through? I didn’t think it was possible considering the amount of times I’ve played Part 2 and never stumbling upon it, but it was an option while beta testing Part 3. I think the game also acknowledged this, as one of the motivations for visiting the camp was “trading our captives.” I could be wrong though
Huh.
I could be wrong but whilst it is a completely coded-for option with scene variants and, as you mention, a choice to prisoner swap, I do not think it is actually possible for Kelly to be taken whilst Benton is a hostage (I could be wrong/misreading this, though)
Requirements for Kelly to be captured:
Not hiding in woods,
Not in a “neutral stance”
To achieve this, just intimidate/persuade/overpower (not attack!) Keith and fail, does not set neutral stance true, upon Silvers leaving Kelly is captured and you’re left to kick rocks. (You can only chase after them if hidden in woods or neutral stance (not being held by Keith))
Given that this has occurred, there is no way to capture Benton before/after this.
In general, to capture Benton you just fight the Silverthornes, pick to shoot/kill anyone (not Benton, obviously), then search for Benton, then stealth/creep up to Benton, then subdue him
Or if you let the Silverthornes go (again, whilst in a neutral stance and so Kelly will still be with you)
I could be wrong or missing something, though, as there are a few different variation/labels as Benton can be captured in different ways, but if true could be rectified by allowing people to chase after Silverthornes even if they have Kelly, or adding another opportunity to allow Kelly to be captured (e.g. during fighting if you have low group defense)
7 Likes
Do all the ROs have challenges like the ones the player gets to choose at the start?
I was doing a playthrough with Jillian as my RO and noticed that she was a kleptomaniac and maybe addicted to nicotine. Reilly has a short fuse, Woody’s a deep sleeper… any other examples?
9 Likes
Parker has diabetes, Dante is vegetarian, Rosie’s starts showing in part 3 its Delusions, after Driver dies when someone opens the gates for dinner, Madison might aslo have short fuse challenge. That’s from the top of my head. Might be nitpicking about Mads’
6 Likes
Rachel and Billie both have pets, and if we’re not just talking about ROs and potential ROs, the nephew wears glasses. 
8 Likes
Lopez seems to have the Deep Sleeper challenge, based on what happens if you take him to meet the museum group.
6 Likes
First off: I love this game.
Don’t know if anyone’s mentioned it before, but I found a bug that occurs when you romance Jaime while he’s the leader. As I get to the junkyard I choose a place to sleep, then invite Jaime to share the living space, so he instead invites me to join him in the garage apartment, and the text says I move my belongings there. However, the game still thinks I sleep in the place I chose first (trailer, RV, etc) instead of the garage apartment. Haven’t tested this with Rachel as leader yet.
Also, what are my odds of romancing Jude in the future? He’s surprisingly nice, considering his body count. He desperately needs a hug.
10 Likes
OooOooOh, I can’t wait!! I really like it when “good”/soft characters are pushed to their limits and become a mess. Not necessarily bad/amoral, but messy is often gray-ish xd But no, for real, if Jaime backstabs me we are going to have a PrObLEM. And from what I’ve gathered (Woody’s contribution was VERY valuable, ty Woody), the day he snaps… Oh boy Jaime himself feels like if he gets angry he won’t be able to stop himself!!! And he’s currently going through a lot of stress… deff sus. This is the 
vibe I’m getting from him:
I like how you think. He’s… questionable at best (lots of issues and even more blood on his hands), but I like him as a character (as much as you can like a minor NPC xd I hope he gets more screen time). To me, his personality makes him stand out a lot, I like how he’s really pragmatic but at the same time he wants to be idealistic and even feels bad for what he’s done. He reminds me of a feral rat lmao Not really the most charming quality, but he’s such a mess, and as I said, I like messy characters 
5 Likes
I noticed it too. Jaime used to be soft but now seems it he becoming like the bandit leader he killed at the school and told off for the bad things they done. It’s only happens once in a while in main plot but it is noticeable
2 Likes
Can you romance Ray? Maybe, possibly, please?
Also i keep consistently finding this weird bug where lopez and jaime are dancing in the prom thing, but that shouldn’t be possible because i shot lopez in part 1
3 Likes
eh, i wouldn’t say he’s “becoming” like Dillan
1 Like
@JimD
Error in chapter 8, when talking to the River Dogs.
“I’m Alex,” you say and then introduce the other members of your group.
“It’s really nice to meet you all,” Emily says. “It’s great to meet other people who are surviving. We haven’t had a lot of luck with strangers so far., except for meeting you all”
Move the full stop in the bolded word to the end of the sentence.
Kevin means against the hood of an old Buick at the edge of the garage and stares at the dance floor with a look of annoyance.
Leans
4 Likes
As much as I like Jude and would love it if MC/Jude was a thing, I would like him to have an arc that isn’t romance focused as well.
4 Likes
Guys can anyone tell me whether eli is a scripted death or not , if not how to save him?
1 Like
Scripted
2 Likes
Wow, really? Does anything happen or maybe in part 4?
1 Like
Hey guys i haven’t asked this yet, but how can i make rachel the leader? Jaime is really bad at it so i wanted a change of leadership
1 Like
kill him
Just finished the book and man i am worried about Rachel’s sickness she is a very reliable deputy and i dont want her to go bye bye tbh.
No chance for any real progress on cure even in part 3 , man i wonder how this route will go down.
Silverthrone sullivan actually almost conivinced me to be an ally until he indirectly asked for someone as a hostage , naa to hell you ask I’ll annex them if i can.
Black mamba might be an explosive barrel but they seem to be the most reliable allies if you can get them on your side.
No idea about river folks so far but looking forward to meet stoke family again.
I wonder how whole thing with deter and surfnet will turn out.
I knew jacob was shady and never gave him food , glad i didnt do that after convo with our 2 new survivors.
I took the three from silverthrone as well , i have doubts about the lady soilder but the father daughter duo seems fine , i hope we have some scenes with mc taking care of kids in later parts .
Jaime is trying to step on my authority as a leader a lot in the last few chps i wonder whatsup with that?
I wonder if in part 4 we will be able to either ally or annex or a combo of both our surrounding forces and open up a decent area for civilisation and make a true safe haven of our own.
Last but not the least screw colonel goodman(in respect to current content dont know if it’ll remain that way in future releases).
These were just my thoughts after finishing not review or anything , i really enjoyed the game and please feel free to make predictions about the points i mentioned.
5 Likes