Without naming the game how would you describe the best and worst CYOA games you've played.?

Best: No romance

Worst: Romance

8 Likes

Wouldnā€™t polarizing mean thereā€™d be SOME naming it as best?

2 Likes

Best: Sexy vampires help detective mc solve a murder in a small town

Other Best: Survivor group fights off zombies in a church

Worst: Game had an interesting premise but ultimately the lack of multiple ā€œrightā€ choices makes it a bit of a chore to play more than one way

4 Likes

:fearful::astonished::fearful::astonished::fearful:
Butā€¦ Romance is Everything :cry::cry:

3 Likes

:man_shrugging:
Perhaps not for everyone, myself included.

1 Like

Bestļ¼šItā€™s a western,and itā€™s long.Duh
Worst:We canā€™t be together because Iā€™m a maid and you are ambitious

2 Likes

Best: Beating a rebellion into Rebellion
Worst: Vamps being Vague

@Theguyfive

ā€œYou feel my pain!ā€

Given the vagueness of half the posts upthread, if youā€™re actually confident that none of the ā€œbestsā€ had a Sergi game in mind, Iā€™d suggest that reflects the extent of your antipathy rather than anything about popular opinion.

But when I said we knew it was polarizingā€¦I mean, havenā€™t we been down this road a thousand times already? Sergi is one of CoGā€™s most popular and successful authorsā€“probably the most successful of anyone whoā€™s not a partner. Heā€™s always had an intense anti-fandom on the forums, too, and as his work has leaned hard into politics itā€™s found new detractors. But you donā€™t have to dig deep to find people who love his work.

17 Likes

/shrug
I could name other things that are lacking in quality (and could be so much better) yet are popular, but ehā€¦

So, back to topic.

Best, well one of the best: I actually felt a bit of what the character was feeling in certain moments.
Worst:I canā€™t pinpoint what was so bad about the writing, just that it was a struggle to keep reading. My mc was also forced into a relationship with a woman just for being nice even when he said in a previous choice that he was gay.

Worst: Published game. Bad English.

Best: Iā€™m very nostalgic about a few games before the forum change so Iā€™ll pick out of them. Charon.

Best: Action-packed Japanese soap opera.

Other best: Rotting corpses that can surprisingly run very fast roam the earth.

Worst: Was somehow able to make one of my favorite periods of history seem boring and unappealing.

1 Like

Can you pm me your worst? I canā€™t for the life of me figure it out.

Tallyho?
Maybe not, maybe so?

Switch these around and you get mine.

1 Like

Best: Iā€™m broke and donā€™t mind everything burning to flames. Also use plastic for everything.

Other best: I heard you like Revolution, Treason and the occasional converting?

Otherer Best: Lots of flirting and repressed sexual tension.

Worst: Stat Hell and micro managing. At some point I was so focused on those check points that the whole plot flew over my head.

1 Like

Best: I can indulge all my terrible urges.

Worst: I didnā€™t even make it to the end of the demo (this is so many games).

4 Likes

Let us kneel to the mighty Lord Malin!

ā€œKneelsā€

Bests: Superheroes in the present
Worsts: Superheroes in the future

3 Likes

Best: thereā€™s a Ronin everyone wants to f***.

Worst: Thought this was a good game? Ha! Everything was in the demo!

2 Likes