Without naming the game how would you describe the best and worst CYOA games you've played.?


#1

Worst: Whoever wrote it was in a windowless room with ten hours of yakety sax playing.

Best: Medievil lesbian adventure


#2

Worst : There’s definitely potential, but the spelling and grammar mistake ruins the immersion.

Best : Be thankful for what you have, don’t busy yourself with 'what if’s, because, even if you have a time machine to do those 'what if’s, you can’t be certain how it’ll actually play out.

Or, alternatively, Steins;Gate Lite.


#3

Okay, c’mon people, put the titles in spoiler tags.

Also, should this be merged with thf funny thread, or something?


#4

Hummm…

I kinda don’t have a worst . Cose , when I play the demo…I usually know if I’m gonna like the story or not . So most of choiceofgames I brough , even if some were too short for my taste…the writing wasn’t as good as that other mind blowing story…I still have no regret . I still play them from time to time . The best ones of course , like Fallen Hero , drive me bonker and I play them so much…I end up dreaming about them lol .

But the one story , like I said…it isn’t the worst…there is no hate . Just maybe regret . Cose I wasn’t going to play it after testing the demo . I knew that story isn’t my cup of tea .

Homewhever , what happen is that when I finally got the bucks to buy some…I kinda made a mistake . I wanted X story and end up buying one I didn’t like . I mixed the titles .

And that story , just as I though…wasn’t my cup of tea . I don’t like asking for refund . So just went trough it just in case I was wrong but…yeah , I wasn’t wrong . I was bored and the story theme…was so not what I like .


#5

I’d rather titles weren’t shared because if someone reads “written in a windowless rolm while listening to Yakety sax for ten hours” they might be really offended if it’s their game.


#6

Only if you can’t reason why you think that.
If you can it’s possibly valid criticism.


#7

Have you played any games that fit the description of Written in a windowless room listening to ten hours of Yakety Sax?

I feel that’s such a specific visual image that like the game guess who it’s like saying a Character has a pink moustache. It narrows things down.


#8

The worst would be one in which there truly was no choices to make.
The best would be a game filled with a great story and was outstanding in the stats part of the game.


#9

There’s the entire HR pentalogy, but knowing you that can not be what you mean.


#10

Just for you i pmed it to you


#11

The best: You feel awful about yourself and everyone is going to be disappointed in you and you’re gonna love it.

I haven’t played one I’d call ‘the worst.’ I know what I like and am pretty good at judging from a description if something is for me or not, so far no stinkers.


#12

The worst: Somehow feels like bad fanfiction despite being an original universe

The best: The best parts of war are when you’re not shooting people


#13

Best: Romance
Worst: No Romance
Am easily pleased and a sucker for love :heart_eyes::heart_eyes::upside_down_face::upside_down_face:


#14

Best: Regret and Self identification issues
Worse: Brooding Boi-toys being vague

P. S am I the only one looking at choice games trying to guess?


#15

Best: I’ve been playing since the open beta and there are still things I haven’t done yet.

Worst: Either the author doesn’t know much about the civil rights era or I learned more about their politics than I wanted to.


#16

The Best: Magic using assassin who is trying to learn who his real father is while dealing with a world that’s changing around him.

The Worst: An author self insert where you’re literally playing as him and knowing what I knew of the guy on a forum, he was nobody you’d want to be playing as.


#17

Best: I have a sneaky worry that my love interest is basically me if I was more medieval and good with swords and politics.

Other Best: Proof you can do something original with Vampires.

Other Other Best: Like I’m reading Skyrim. :drooling_face:

I don’t have a worst. Maybe i’m too nice… :face_with_raised_eyebrow:


#18

Worst: A chaos. It was all over the place and the most confusing story I’ve ever read. Also, the characters might as well have been cardboard cutouts. No personality whatsoever.

Best: A story with a world which seems to be alive together with all its characters. Fleshed out but not overwelmingly so. Never tried to guilt me into something, just a fine and relaxing game.


#19

My best has got to be where you create life in mechanical form. That game had so many routes and a great story.


#20

Best : A poignant and grand trek through the life of a self made god, their techbological creation, and the fate of their own planet/humanity.

Worst: A grammatical travesty that never fails to elicit a cascade of tears from any editor.