Well, since book two released I have been fully back on my Wayhaven bullshit, lol. Wow. Just, wow. It’s been a looong time since I’ve posted on these forums but I have so many thoughts that I need to share.
Everything is under the cut because it is A LOT. Also, major spoilers, obviously.
Summary
To start, the overarching plot was a really nice shift from the (great) plot of book one. While book one was you learning about and coming to grips with the fact that the supernatural exist, book two really showed the detective coming into their own and potentially thriving as a liason for the Agency. If they aren’t made a full agent soon it would be absolutely bonkers. I know it’s kind of hinted at after you bring the sick supernatural to the facility, but still. lol.
The maa-alused were a really cool antagonistic force. In contrast to Murphy, who is almost mustache twirling levels of villany in comparison, they are a bit more complicated. While they clearly do not think what they are doing is wrong, they also start to recognize that maybe their way of living and enacting justice is a bit outdated for the world they live in. It really gives you a chance to establish how your player feels about grey areas like this, and allows you to kind of see into the mind of another race of creatures and decide how you feel about them. It also lets you really test out your diplomatic chops. Or, you know, punch things, which is also a valid option. The fact that there are several different outcomes in terms of the illness/treaty is very cool and a good opportunity to show everyone how your detective operates.
The trappers and the rogue supernaturals are OBVIOUSLY going to be major future antagonists, lol. Especially considering the maa-alused aren’t even true antagonists. I will always love kicking trapper ass though. It never gets old. As for the rogue supernaturals and their mysterious leader, I’m really excited to see if my theory about her identity is accurate.
“You have his eyes”
“There’s something in the eyes”
COME ON. IT’S GOTTA BE YOUR “DEAD” AUNT!!
She is definitely a supernatural of some sort, because why would the rogues allow a human to lead them? This also got me thinking about your father’s fate and her potential motivations. Maybe she blames the Agency for your father’s death? Maybe the reason your father died is because of her, and that’s why they wouldn’t tell Rebecca? Also, if you don’t do the tests in book one, there’s a line in book two relating to your father, from the trapper that recognizes you in the sewers. He says something like “I should have recognized you. You love those supernaturals just like your father.” And that had me SHOOK. This was basically my crack playthrough and getting a bomb dropped on me like that was not what I was expecting. Was he talking about your aunt? Did trappers kill your father? They’re basically a gang, right? And your mother always told you he was killed by a gang protecting innocents. Were those innocents supernaturals getting abducted by trappers? I NEED ANSWERS!!
EDIT: I took a break from the game to write this post and when I picked it back up I got some of my answers, lol. I got to the part where you talk to Rebecca about the trappers recognizing you as your father’s child and we had That Talk so. Now I have even MORE questions, lol.
Now, on to the juicy stuff.
Mason. This man. THIS MAN. shakes fist at my screen I did not expect to be able to sleep with him THAT quickly (though it was a VERY welcome surprise, don’t get me wrong) and get frisky THAT MANY TIMES. WHEW. Those scenes were so amazingly written. I actually had to take a break after the first sex scene because I was so overwhelmed. When he says “Stunning. Every inch of you.” I almost died. I ALMOST DIED, DO YOU HEAR ME? Aside from the obviously very good and very very hot NSFW stuff, the soft, sweet moments were almost even MORE intense. When you’re on the roof with him and he realizes the detective keeps his hypersenses in check. And when you’re in the hospital and… that kiss… “Woah, no one’s ever kissed me like that before.” And just the casual way he throws his arm around you in chapter nineteen, like being close to you like that is the most natural thing in the world. I just. I was a bit overwhelmed by his whole route because it was NOT what I was expecting in the BEST way. The hot and cold nature of it was really great to read and experience and he is now my favorite RO, whereas in book one he was my second favorite. His friend path is also amazing. The little moments of support from him are everything I was hoping for when I was min/maxing his friendship in book one, lmao. Pulled back branch when looking for the thralls? I raise you one “Hey, you’re doing good.” Special shoutout to the romance scene where you give him a BJ in the woods and he is just completely flustered 
Adam. ADAM. ADAAAAAM. The longing. The hesitant touches. The demolishing of all of the Ageny’s property. Every angsty rush out of the room or instance of him shutting down emotionally is worth it to get a small smile or chuckle from him. Every time he protectively hovers around the detective or is worried when they’re out of his sight my heart tugs because he cares. so. much. But his big stupid emotionally constipated ass won’t let me love him. But I will not stop trying, Adam, do you hear me? The moment at the end of book two, where your hands are barely even touching, and he’s just looking at you even though fireworks are going off above you guys. It had as much impact and intensity as some of Mason’s scenes and WE WERE BARELY TOUCHING EACH OTHER. That is crazy. But it’s also a reflection of how well his route is written. He is sadly not my favorite any more, but I still adore him and his route made me feel so many emotions. PLEASE let me smooch him in book 3, I beg you. Also, tu omnia. 'Nuff said.
Nate. His route was everything I expected. He is so open with his emotions and affections, it was a really interesting change from Mason’s sexualtiy and Adam’s complete denial lol. He had his own brand of emotional intensity that gave me butterflies. I usually do the shy flirts with Mason/Adam, but the bold flirts were really rewarding with Nate. That kiss in the hallway outside of your apartment. swoons I am so glad we are able to start a relationship with him at the end, and that kiss on the ferris wheel. Just. Wow. It was so powerful. I love his friendship scenes the second best in this game. He is just so caring about you and the whole team. I adore this man. Special mention goes to him covering his boner in the library. I was like
I see you Nate.
Felix. I will be honest, he is not my favorite romance. I love him as a character, and I really appreciate the insights we get into him if we pursue a romance, but it’s not really for me. That said, he really is such a sweetheart! And that scene in the sewers when he is like, “choose me.” That one was a no-brainer for me, whereas with my first run-through I agonised over the decision for like, fifteen minutes. Also, at the carnival, when you give him the necklace and he is just so happy! Ahhh! I must protect this sweet angel. Favorite scene was when Unit Alpha was like ‘is that a thing?’ and he’s just like, yes bitch. I love him, lol.
The Love Triangle. I played through it, kissed Nate at the end, read the line about Adam shutting his eyes in pain upon seeing you two, and vowed Never Again. Then I did Adam’s solo route for the third time, lol. It’s too painful for me. I don’t wanna hurt either of them 
Bobby. Yuck. I wish I could have used a combat check to knee him in the balls when he tried to kiss my detective. That being said, the jealousy scenes in the warehouse are absolutely delicious. I need more of that good, good drama. And mom being like
at seeing him. I love Rebecca so much lol.
Douglas. Poor baby. I’m petitioning the city for custody of this boy. Or I’ll kill the mayor. Just, please don’t sniff my detective’s hair, Douglas, I beg you.
Falk. Okay. You knew exactly what you were doing with this one, didn’t you Sera? How dare you make him and not let me romance him. I love Unit Bravo but. COME ON. How can you make him say the things he says and expect me to not wanna smooch him? I didn’t allow him to touch my face in only one run-through because I am low-key (see: high-key) in love with this man. Please tell me this is another opportunity for jealous!Unit Bravo. I don’t want my babies to suffer but, I need them to suffer. For the drama.
Unit Alpha. They are all amazing and I hope, despite what the leader said, we get to see more of them. I have a conspiracy theory that they are the leak, however, due to a little blurb of dialogue when the MC gets jumped by the trappers. Something like “Unit Alpha was supposed to sweep for any trappers in the area, but some are clearly hidden all over the place.” I mean, I know it’s hard to account for every trapper but 1.) Aren’t they supposed to be like, THE MOST ELITE UNIT? and 2.) You get jumped REALLY close to the facility. I don’t know why they would be working with the trappers but if my other theory-- that the trappers are working with the rogue supernaturals-- is true. Well. I hope I’m wrong, lol. Because they are great.
Honestly, there’s a lot more that I could talk about but this is getting too long as it is. I just haven’t been able to stop thinking about/playing this game since release and it reminded me how much I adore Wayhaven. I remember when the demo was first posted on the forums and I fell in love with it. Seeing how it has grown over the past few years has filled me with so much joy. I can’t wait to follow this series as it continues to progress. Book two was more than worth waiting for, and I know the case will be the same for book three.
tldr; I love this series. Sera, you have created a work of art.