Keeper of Day and Night (Update Post 1932)

  • In the demo, my character was very close to Leon, but they were just friends. She did have the subplot with his sister, though, and the game sometimes referred to him as her “boyfriend”… but then she had the opportunity to flirt with this exchange student, and Leon has a thing with Astrid, so that was a little odd.

  • I’m curious about the break up mechanic. In the demo, it seems like it just makes your ex think that you guys were never together. My MC was very close to Cyrus and was dating him, but had a “messy break up” with him (made sense because she’d been through a lot and Cyrus is kind of bad with feelings) and then there weren’t really any opportunities to acknowledge that he was her ex. :frowning: It would be nice if the break up mechanic was not just hitting the reset button on your relationship with someone but there was at least a little nod here and there to what you guys had in the past.

  • Speaking of Cyrus, his characterization as your boyfriend is a little…lacking. He doesn’t seem to put in much effort into the relationship and he’s always kind of grumpy. Like he invited MC on vacation for break, and then he said “it was Leon and Cressida who wanted you to come” and when MC was like “did you want me to come too, cuz you’re my boyfriend and invited me?” he just didn’t give an answer… Romance plotlines with him in the future might give the MC the ability to challenge that because while I understand that that’s his character, it’s not the most healthy relationship dynamic and it would be nice if MC could challenge him to grow and improve on that.

  • The pacing in the first book is a little rushed. There is a lot of exposition and little time, and it was easy to miss a lot of background info.

  • The MC has personality stats but I don’t see any obvious effects on gameplay. So more obvious impacts that let you characterize MC more would be good, I think.

  • I hope you can grow close to Renatus because he seems really sweet and even if he turns out to be involved with his sister’s activities, I would still like to get to know him. But that’s just me.

  • Edit: I also like the addition of Roxana being kind of a horrible person. Usually deceased parents are seen through rose colored lenses. So it’s interesting for MC to realize that their mom was really that awful.

13 Likes

Yeah, I think personality is just there to make MC feel more “personal”. The game heavily depends on your ability stats instead like telekinesis, elemental manipulation, combat, etc. There are some things that does change the story, like if your chaotic stat is high enough, you’ll have the option to break free from the suitemates and wander off, meeting hunters in the process. You can either become one or get killed. Learned the latter the hard way And then there’s the kindness stats which helps you during the Solanceae test if it’s high enough and you chose to wander off to the lake. There’s also dialogue changes and unlocked options which can depend on the personality stat. For example, MC will react differently to situations depending on their logical and emotional stats as noted in the therapy scenes. There’s probably a few others that I missed, other than that I think personality just adds some flavor text to the game which livens up the game experience.

You’re in for a treat then because iirc the author said Ren was a good guy and I have hugh hopes we can befriend him cause he might date Kol.. You’re not alone, MC needs more friends!! Also very interested in the “Well your sister tried to kill me but I wanna be your friend”-dynamic.

4 Likes

Thanks for the feedback, everyone!!

Also, a quick note: using an old save can lead to bugs if anything is edited in old chapters. I’m trying to add extra code to new chapters to keep this from happening, but just be warned!


Thanks for the catches!

Yes, but it’s easy to get around if someone is skilled enough, like with telepathy and truth potions, and is thus not admissible in court.

Hi! This scene shouldn’t be appearing at all for adopted parents route—do you know what chapter this is in?

@Nyahaha101
Thank you very much for all the catches, and the suggestions!!! :smile:

I’m simplifying the human/hunter/magician route to just be centered around finding out your family friend is a magician

Yep!

Nope

Nope! I’ll have to change it haha

@Tuunetoon
Hi! Thank you for the feedback!

I’ve added some more breakup-related narration for the next update. I also found one instance of Leon being improperly called MC’s boyfriend in Chapter 4 and a couple in Chapter 5. Thanks for the catch! Do you happen to recall any other instances of this?

MC has no idea one way or the other!

4 Likes

MC needs more friends that aren’t going to end up betraying him lol. My MC’s not really sure how trustworthy Renatus is, which isn’t his fault at all, but my MC wouldn’t touch anyone related to Reyna with a ten foot pole.

Yeah me too. I’m thinking that he may actually be the one that’s been selling MC out behind the scenes. Especially after the whole “bear getting through the wards” incident. It would take someone with special knowledge of how warding works to be able to do that, which means that it probably wasn’t a student, or it was a student who got help from someone.
I hope we’ll have an opportunity to ask Seraphina what the whole conversation with Tremblay was about. I’m betting that she read his mind when he was acting confused to see if he was being genuine or not.

I’m actually going to disagree with you on this one. I think that not having the personality stats affect the gameplay for the most part is a good call. This allows for MCs to grow more organically, rather than having to focus on making choices that align with their stats. For example, an MC that was previously more emotional, may become more logical after realizing all their responsibilities as a keeper. That’s something that would be seen thorugh changes in the personality stats. You wouldn’t be able to play your MC that way if you had to focus on making sure their personality is “consistent”. This allows for more growth for MC.

TL;DR: In my opinion stat checks based on personality stats lead to less organic character growth/change because they make the player have to focus on raising the personality stats they started out with, rather than allowing them to explore how their character would have changed as a result of events throughout the story.

4 Likes

@daydreamsincolor It stood out to me when my character first found out about Celeste. It said she was the older sister to my “boyfriend”.

edit: another question about the series, but will there be more opportunities for a darker path for MC? Like going into more morally dubious territory a la helping Reyna and all.

2 Likes

I really, really, really love that Ebner and Lucas are dating–something about it is just perfect.

I did find a bug–I played a magician, but was still allowed to compete after being told I couldn’t. A *goto command at the end of the choice block right above *label compete would fix the problem.

I also enjoyed the interactive storybooks, but they felt kind of rushed and I struggled to follow them. That might just be my problem though : )

3 Likes


I think the choices concerning magic shouldn’t be there for the human playthrough

5 Likes

Love Leon’s grandmother. She’s a hoot!

@daydreamsincolor

Summary


Should be bolded


The book was found in the previous page


Line is out of place


Darzi is referring to the SAVIOR Act right? Wasn’t that introduced by Nephilim leadership?


Should be ‘parent’ or ‘father’ since I have Lucas as father this time.


No bug, but I feel like an intelligence and/or cunning check would be more suitable

Also, is ‘Ivan’ Yakov’s real name??

1 Like

Same here. Safiya and Mirabelle deserve to be protected. Safiya is the grandma Castella never was to us.

3 Likes

Makes me wonder if MC has any chance of having a healthy relationship with Castella at some point. Possibly as part of the epilogue for the last book?

3 Likes

She’s great!

1 Like

I agree, but your personality stats do affect gameplay in the sense that it affects conversations the MC has and how people perceive them. I think the acceptance/resistance changes are pretty obvious (you get choices to vocalize your dissent, snark back in conversations, become a hunter, have more “human” options and choices), but there are changes for MCs who are more logical, sarcastic, kind. I think people don’t notice because a lot of the time they subconsciously create characters with the same base personality (smart, sarcastic, etc.) so it seems like there isn’t much going on. But just looking at Book One alone, there’s a lot of scenes and conversations between the characters that plays out different depending on your personality. I encourage people to try and play radically different characters sometimes or let their MC be a little more this, a little less that. It’s fun seeing all the changes that are made.

On another note, Tremblay gives huge Lockhart vibes from Harry Potter, which is probably why I feel so distrusting of him lol.

9 Likes

He is similar to Lockhart, I would agree with that. But that would make Ebner Snape. And Snape pined after Lily, while Ebner’s dating our dad. So that would make our dad Lily. Our mom, meanwhile, fits neatly as James during his Hogwarts year. That would make our MC…

HARRY JAMES POTTER!! cue drum roll

Or, I’m reading too much into this​:joy::sweat_smile:


@Kamer, I was just joking about that​:joy::sweat_smile:

From what we have seen from Roxanna up until now, she was a pure Regina George, at least to me😂 On the other hand, James kind of redeemed himself when he jumped in front of Voldy to save his son.

So yeah, not a good comparison overall. Sorry about that😅

4 Likes

Man I really resent the comparison between James and Roxanna. James made mistakes but grew to become a better person. Roxanna, from what we’ve seen, was only ever out for herself.

6 Likes

And just like that Seraphina became Hermione. But who’s Ron?

3 Likes

Yeah, and honestly I don’t want Roxana to turn out to have been a misunderstood wonderful mother and woman. Sometimes, people who should not have kids have kids. It’s a fact of life.

8 Likes

Astrid? I’m going with Astrid.

2 Likes

The boy who survived a gorgon attack

Gosh darn it, I always imagined Leon as Regina George. He just has that Mean Boy vibe to him. I’m kind of scared to ask who Karen and Gretchen is.

Just kidding, it’s Lysander and Brant

1 Like

Quick question, but I’m a little confused as to how old Astrid is supposed to be? We’re assuming that your whole suite are first-semester freshmen, but Astrid transferred from another university. This made me think that she was just a slightly older transfer who was set back a semester (because credits and bureaucracy and all). But Altair is a sophomore and her older brother… So is she supposed to be our age or not?

1 Like