🌈 Dear Diary, We Created a Plot Hole! (A Slice-of-Life Fantasy Adventure set in the Philippines) ~ [UPDATED Aug 31 | 608,000 words]

i was actually focused on the “successful” part, hence the assumption that JM and B used to engage in some friendly competition before some kind of incident that caused B to be exiled from the group. i do believe their claim that they are not jealous of JM and his achievements (even if my MC does think that B is somewhat jealous).

Based from some of B’s dialogue and some hints from Franzinyte, the group (or maybe just someone in the group Lily,maybe?) betrayed them and/or lied about them hence why they wanted to warn the MC about it (which is kinda shows that they care in some way).


As for the pandemic reference, i already accepted that everyone lives in a reality where the pandemic doesn't exist (so they won't suffer the same shit we're going through) but i don't mind having it as a reference so it can be an inside joke for the reader.
1 Like

i picked the action where my MC gets to hug B and i didn’t expect them to go soft on me. i admit i was expecting barbs and insults and man, i didn’t expect to get this soft from this …fudge. Will there be another opportunity to hug B in the further chapters?


Other facts about my Twins:
  • When it comes to grades, Remy would be 12th in the roster while Ryan would be in 26th.
  • Ryan takes taekwondo lessons and piano lessons. He has plans to stop both lessons when once he reached high school though.
  • Remy is well-aware of tvtropes and draws inspiration from there. Though in reality, they go there for the spoilers.
  • They both have a love-hate relationship with crab and shrimp. (Peeling the shell is hard, people)
  • Remy likes Cardcaptor Sakura and Madoka Magica. Ryan is very concerned about Madoka (and for a good reason).
  • Meanwhile, Ryan likes Avatar the Last Airbender (and no, he hasn’t watched Korra especially Book 3 because Patrick won’t let him.)
  • By college, they added another nickname to their long list of nicknames. AJ (short for Adrian Joseph) for Ryan and RJ (short for Rebecca Joyce) for Remy. i finally found a second name for them!
3 Likes

I know what you mean but it’s pretty normal, just a little different compared to others

1 Like

is this an error or…

also this line repeated

1 Like

I liked your writing style, it has a very good feel to it.

1 Like

AAAAAAAAAHHHHHHhhhhh this is wonderful!!! :sob: :sob: I started playing yesterday and I am still super excited re-playing it today. It’s really a lot of fun! I love the concept; it’s really refreshing and interesting. All the tropes are used in a super creative way!! And the characters that have appeared so far are super lovely. Aside from MC and the twin, I love Roselyna the most so far. She is just lovely!!! :sob: :sob: It broke my heart seeing her sad stat emoji when I was playing the cold twin, I went to replay it again just so I won’t make her sad. I am getting super attached to her. Looking at the forum thread it looks like she’s going to go through several stuffs and I am ;__; I am so scared for her.

I really love the Tagalog use!! I’m Southeast Asian myself so being able to play a game set in Southeast Asia is a wonderful feeling. Being able to call my twin ate/kuya/kapatid is wonderful. It’s not a term I use myself daily, but being able to call your siblings with the proper term is just exciting :sob: :sob: :sob:

ALSO everything is super pretty!!! I love the stat screen so much :sob: :sob: Took me a while to realise that your handwriting affects your stat header, that was such a nice small touch!!! Honestly I am super amazed by the amount of effort you have put into this. It makes everything much more immersive and enjoyable. I know this is going to be one of my top favourites when the full story is out ;____; i’m already having so much fun now. I’m looking forward to it :heart_eyes: :heart_eyes: :heart_eyes:

I was super excited when I see the stroller bag option. Stroller bag!!! That really took me bag (:wink:) to my childhood. It was such a hit thing back then. Everyone at my school treats it as the heights of luxury, together with those multifunction pencil cases and the branded color pencils :sob: :sob: :sob: This game really makes me feel nostalgic.

also just some errors i have found:

wrong pronoun for randelle

B and hair color


MC’s twin has black hair, only MC has light blond hair.


same situation, different POV. this is from the twin’s POV playthrough.

capital letters

Screenshot_4

wrong pronouns for B.


I was really surprised to find out that nobody wants to rule their own kingdom. Less competition for my MC’s twin I suppose…?

I kinda feel the MC (and twin’s) name are kinda out of place, but they are my existing OCs so gotta roll with it;;; Their name are Celestyn (he/she/they) and Caelestis (he/they). Basically the same name, just different origin. No work was done there by Mama Maggie… and me, I guess :sob: I thought it was sorta funny tho. I… want to talk more about them but seeing the length of this post already makes me a little embarrassed. Maybe another time.

tldr; this was such a wondeful and creative work. I love every parts and seconds of it, and am looking forward to more!! xxxx

7 Likes

i remember that when i was in grade school, Faber-Castell was THE brand of coloring pencils (especially the 64-colors ones) and collecting colored gel pens was a craze.

Also, if you’re worried about your MCs’ names being out of place, remember there are parents who named their kids like Abcde, KVIIIlyn and X Æ A-Xii. Yours may be unusual but not totally outlandish.

if you have the time, give some facts about your twins. i would love hear them!

3 Likes

Hello everyone! I want to address a few things in this post. I’ll put these in a FAQ section when I have the time.

First, it has come to my attention that the twin reunion scene was a little unsatisfactory for cold MCs/MCs with a complicated relationship with their twin, and I plan to address that on the next update. As I said, I kinda rushed the update and it totally slipped my mind since writing the cold interactions requires me to have a different mindset. That said, the cold personality doesn’t mean violent, and the MC will never be 100% antagonistic toward their friends. If they were mean all the time, they wouldn’t even be in the friend group in the first place. That is not what the story is about. Of course, there will be plenty of opportunities for conflict later with the group and your twin as the story goes. Yes, the group may even split later. :shushing_face:

So if you find a scene where the MC acts inconsistently/out-of-character, please don’t hesitate to tell me! I have a million variables (customization, traits, personalities, previous choices) to keep track of, so I will definitely miss something. I love the flavor text as much as you do.


Another thing I want to address is that I won’t be making the characters into teenagers. I’ve already aged the characters up by 3 years, and unfortunately that’s the maximum for both plot and theme related reasons. There are plenty of stories with teenagers in them. In fact, if Roselyna seems a little too childish, that’s because I first wrote her as an 8-year-old (and trust me, she was way too bratty back then). :sweat_smile:


Regarding the pacing: Most people think it’s fine, however the reason I asked it in the survey is because I KNOW that it is slow, and with my current outline, the first act (set-up) won’t be finished until Chapter 6, when the fieldtrip starts. I’m currently brainstorming ways to make the plot move faster (and maybe reduce a little bit of banter), but it’s mostly slow because the way I structure my scenes, there’s barely any timeskips, since that’s when MC usually does their internal monologue. Chapter 2 is fairly long, but hopefully Chapters 3-6 will be a lot shorter.


Replies and Comments

@TheSleepwalker Yup, you’ll be able to see the first effects of the branching in Chapter 6, which will have persistent effects during the story, although it won’t actually branch out for real until the climax. Of course, you’ll be able to select a different ending if you’re not happy with your initial choice.

@Mistyleaf123 Thanks for the report! The first one refers to Wayne and Roselyna though.

@Jose_Garcia Aaaah, thanks for checking out my WIP! I’m glad you liked the writing style. :smiley:

@fuciphagus AAAAAHHH right back at you! I really appreciate the long and wonderful comment! And I’m glad you loved Roselyna and all the little details. :blush: Also, don’t worry too much about Rosie, she can whack more than just bullies. :wink:

I love your twins’ names actually! Themed twin names are common anyway, and they won’t be too out of place once the real adventure starts. Do Celestyn and Caelestis have any nicknames?

Oh, and thanks for the reports as well! They should be fixed now.


Yup! I don’t think it’s spoilery to say that they did use to have a friendly competition with each other. It goes a lot deeper than that of course.

I guess you’ll have to wait until Chapter 3 then! There will be an actual puzzle you need to figure out to guess Aunt Julie’s password and access her laptop. But if you don’t want to wait, the clues are all there in the prologue. :wink:

That was actually one of the first choices I’ve ever written! Although, I’m not sure if hugging B should automatically accept the sidequest. And yup, there’ll be more opportunities for sure! Not as many as Roselyna, of course. Hehe.

About Abe's twins
  • 12th and 26th is quite the gap! I hope Ryan doesn’t mind that!
  • Taekwondo and piano is a weird combination. :stuck_out_tongue: It hasn’t come up yet, but Roselyna is actually very good at playing the organ/piano! She got interested because of her time serving as an altar girl.
  • If you were wondering, I’ll definitely drop a reference to TV Tropes later. Hehe.
  • Haaa, does Ryan like ATLA partially because of the reference I sneaked in there? :stuck_out_tongue: I’m not sure about Patrick’s stance on Korra though, now that you mention it. There might be more references to it later, shh!
  • Ooh, and it’s nice that you finally found second names for them! I actually had a character named RJ before, but the nickname initials eventually went to JM.
8 Likes

It’s probably splitting hairs at this point, but my cold!MC may not get along as well as he’d like with his sister, but some of the word choice, particularly the use of the word “hate” felt very off to me. He’s resentful of his mother abandoning him and his sister, but even describing that relationship with a word as strong as “hate” isn’t quite right.

Instead of being natural, it almost felt like words, and feelings were being imposed on him, rather than having the chance to clarify the distinction that unhappiness isn’t necessarily hate. He’s the “star”, so he doesn’t get all that emotional about things. I dunno how the narrative intends to evolve from here, but I do honestly know that he’d be willing to forgive his mom with just a chance to talk. Judge with proof–not petty inferences driven by emotion. That’s how he’d look at it, or he wouldn’t agree to give B a chance. :upside_down_face:

Gotta agree about the ‘not sleeping in the same bed’ being very different from selfishness; they’re both almost 12, which kinda means puberty is about to smack them both silly. Put another way… If one twin feels more embarrassed about the idea of still sharing a bed, then that’s not as unnatural as the other twin’s response would have it, though I’m willing to forgive their frustration about things changing that “didn’t have to” as they might be thinking. :slightly_smiling_face:

2 Likes

That’s a good point! :slightly_smiling_face: I’ll see where I can put a choice where you can choose the primary reason why you were angry. (With an all of the above, of course)

Now that you mention it, does the twin mentioning the ‘sleeping together/not sleeping together anymore’ during the fight work/make sense? It’s in the heat of the moment, but I primarily put it there to put extra weight on that choice you might not have expected (to frame MC as a somewhat unreliable narrator) and because at this point, aside from the MC potentially not calling their twin kuya/ate anymore, there’s not much I can use to justify the twin’s anger especially because the big fight happened three years ago.

I’m willing to consider alternative reasons.

1 Like

It does seem to come out of left field when the angry twin brings not sleeping together up, but that’s why it does still work as something they mention. It leaves the twin being scolded baffled in a “Wait–why is that one of the problems?” sense that indeed sells the point that the one doing the scolding is genuinely unhappy. Children can be rash with their emotions at times, so they’ll sometimes say things that don’t make sense in a fit of upset that they have a hard time apologizing for because they sometimes know after the words are out that it didn’t make sense.

As long as it doesn’t count toward increasing selfishness as a stat, it still works. I may have confused you by not being clear enough, so I apologize for that. :sweat_smile:

5 Likes

Is it possible for our twin to be nonbinary? Like ‘but they did understand’ when you confess?

I don’t know, there’s possibly that the author may include it in the future but it’s going to be kinda complicated. Right now there’s still some problems with our MC and their twin’s gender like changing gender, name ,… so non-binary won’t be a good idea now

1 Like

As much as i want to have the Twin have a choice to be nonbinary (when i do Ryan’s run), Manaxaggd is right. The game already has a lot of variables to consider and Franzinyte already has set her mind on having the Twin be of the opposite sex of the MC.


As a commment to everyone's comments on the Valdez twins:
  • Ryan is the more stubborn sibling and doesn’t really care about grades that much. If he passes, that’s good enough for him.
  • Seeing that Korra has some graphic death scenes, i can see Patrick being hesitant to have Ryan to watch Korra. As for Remy and Madoka, everyone assumed it was just a cutesy magical girl show based on the art.
1 Like

For future reference, I wouldn’t trust anything on the old thread. :stuck_out_tongue:

This is actually a great argument, which I haven’t considered before. It does seem unfair especially if you play the other way around. This isn’t a priority for me right now, and I’ll see how it looks again in the future. (It’ll definitely be easier to implement once the story is done since the Twin uses pronouns a lot more often than the MC.)

But yes, the twins will stay opposite sex, and no plot hole will change that.

3 Likes

He waves his pen again, this time pointing his lips at my paper.

Quick suggestion! As a fellow Filipino, I understand the action our dear sibling is doing since it’s a common body language that we share, however, I think it’s best of you re-word it cause I don’t think that non-Filipinos or people who aren’t familiar with the lip thing know what he’s doing.

Maybe “He waves his pen again, this time jutting out his lips to point at my paper.”

1 Like

@Queen_Elizabeth Hi there! I appreciate the suggestion! :blush:

Maybe ‘sticking out’ could be better? ‘Jut’ is a weird verb, especially for a child to use.

Anyway, I hope you enjoyed the story so far! I’d appreciate it too if you can give me some feedback.


By the way, since Valentine’s Day :heart: is almost here, I just thought I’d let you guys know about a few extra variables I deleted during the locker scene, since I didn’t have enough time. There’s a hidden ‘attraction’ variable that tracks how much each group member likes you (depending on traits, personality and appearance), and if you got enough, there’ll be a Valentine’s Day card in your locker (that you have received a couple of weeks earlier since it’s Feb. 27 in the story). This also determines their initial reaction when you choose some of the flirt options.

You can find out who sent it during the Secret Exchange, but getting the card is totally not necessary if you want to have a crush on someone–it just gives you some bonus dialogue.

I wanted to do something a little special for the event, but I guess I’ll just have to wait for next time. (I made a card some time ago actually, but I can’t share it yet since it features one of the characters you’ll meet later. :sweat_smile:)

Anyway, Wayne and Roselyna’s birthdays :birthday: are in a couple of weeks, so hopefully I have something new to share by then!

8 Likes

Hello again! :blush:

I’ve updated the survey results! I stopped being lazy and finally created a spreadsheet so it’ll be a lot easier for me now to evaluate the codes and see the stat distributions.

Summary

It’s all very helpful and interesting, actually. I’m quite surprised that about 40% of people have an 80%+ Reliant stat, with only 1% having 80%+ Independent. I also didn’t realize that you can get as high as 60%+ relationship with B, so I’ll most likely reduce that by about half.

I wasn’t sure if I made the stat requirement for the Top 5 Choice a little too high, since everyone seems to have a high INT stat (it actually tests your precocious and discipline stat), but at least 15% managed to pick it, so that seems okay for now.

I also wasn’t expecting that B would B the second most popular character so far (next to the Twin), so I’ll have to reevaluate their role a little, since they were actually a late addition to the story. :thinking:


So uh, we’ve been busy moving, so I’m afraid there isn’t much progress. But here’s what I’ve been working on!

Updated Locket Gems


The other locket gems are smooth stones, so they’ll mostly stay the same.


Updated Group Shot with Paddy


This is all very much a work in progress, so the scaling is a little out of whack. :stuck_out_tongue: Also, sorry if Brandon/Beatrice isn’t included, but I promise they’ll be there in the next update!


I also figured out how to make Chapter 2 shorter and move the plot a little faster. There won’t be a group meeting anymore, and instead I’ll merge the scene together with the current scenes. There’s supposed to be a group discussion about the short stories you wrote about, but I thought it’d be better if your friends shared their stories with you instead as you meet them, which should better segue into their introduction songs.

And yup, you’ll get to visit each story world–I hope this isn’t a spoiler at this point! :sweat_smile:


Anyway, that’s all for now! Thanks to everyone so far who have given their feedback and submitted their code!

7 Likes

i hope the move isn’t stressing you out. i hope you and your companions take care!


i'm also glad that we get to see Patrick. i admit that it's easier for me to visualize him so thanks!

Also, (belated) Happy Birthday to Wayne and Roselyna!

1 Like

Just playing for the first time but HAD to come back and say a literally squeeled with excitement when I saw the Tagalog, since I’m trying to learn.

2 Likes