When I first saw this I thought “eh, just another isekai (sent to another world) fantasy story” but seeing that you included very diverse sets of pantheons (I am quite the mythology/religious texts nerd) it got my attention. Let me say I am quite surprised by the fact thwt I went here for the Gods and I came out feeling very VERY attached to Caleb! That is such a great portrayal of siblinghood in a broken family. I mean, I personally wouldn’t know how realistic it is since I never had a sibling and my family are in a pretty stable position all things considered, but damn did you got me hooked into protecting my sweet baby bro! That alone deserves praise!
Besides your relationship with him though, I am very much interested in why he was drawn to the Vault of the Gods in the first place. If Caleb gets to have a big role in this Divine ordeals we are going to face then damn I am going to be so stoked! That gives a good amount of flavor in your story that I’ll admit I otherwise once thought of as kinda cliche (at least for me cause time spent watching Anime burnt me out of the Isekai genre, or anything that sends you into a fantasy world at least)
Other than that, I found it kinda peculiar how you formatted the personality stats. I am used to the Red and Blue bar that builds upon one color whenever you do something that affects personality. If anything seeing that a lot of your personality stats are oppositte of each other, like Open and Close, I am surprised that it isn’t that Red/Blue bar that I mentioned. May I ask the reasoning behind it? Since I just found kinda strange but not unappealing. Like it is kinda weird for someone to be both Open and Close to people unless they are interacting with somebody different, but if your intention is more freedom as to how our MC acts then it is understandable I supposed.
Also since there is a reletionship stat for the Mayan pantheon are we going to be expecting to get a Mayan Patron? Or are they not available for now intentionally? You don’t have to reply if you wish to keep us from being spoiled of course.
Anyways that is all I got to say for now. It already has strong character writing despite the length of this WIP and I love the inclusion of a variety of Deities. Now all I need is them interacting with each other morethan those little quotes and I am absolutely into this game. I love seeing large scale crossovers like this so yeah this is my cup of tea!