Beat Part 3 (twice). Really enjoyed it, more so than Part 2, but I love all of JimD’s work.
The biggest thing I had a problem with was player agency at the Silverthorne’s camp. More specifically, when I eavesdropped on that tour guide and Silverthorne soldier in the tavern, I knew something was up, that they were maybe laying a trap.
I went back to my group and said as much, and straight up picked “Yeah, it’s a trap, let’s get out of here.” And Rachel overruled me and said something like, “Well, we have to confront them anyways. Let’s walk into the trap.” And my eyes just popped out of my head. I was like, what?! What are you doing?! I thought I’m the leader!
That being said, after meeting with the Silverthorne leadership, I can see why I was forced to go along with it. I get it. So afterwards, it didn’t bother me as much. In fact, after meeting with the Silverthorne leadership, I was tempted to start trading and allying with them, even though I was vehemently opposed to the Silverthorne group previously.
Then the zombies attack. I don’t want to help, but I don’t want to hinder, so I pick to observe the Silverthornes fight off the zombies. My character does that for awhile, and then the game says, “Okay! Now what?” Wait, what? I want to observe. I want to observe the battle. Maybe I just have to pick more options until the battle is over. So then I choose to fight off the zombies. Then I’m forced to escape the camp, which shocked me.
My desire was to hunker down in the Silverthorne camp until the battle was over. I know that the Silverthornes won’t get wiped out from the zombie attack; I know this. So I wanted to wait and speak with the leadership when they finish fighting. But I’m forced to escape from the camp, which I didn’t really like.
But all in all, loved Episode 3. Did run into a few bugs. Namely, when I was at the museum, I chose not to release the prisoners, and I didn’t side with anyone in the museum. As I was exiting the museum, Jude was standing outside, somehow having teleported from the generator room. I offered him to join my group, and it seemed like after that, sometimes he appeared in my group and sometimes not.
It kills me to know that Episode 4 probably won’t be out until 2025, at the earliest. But hey, quality takes time, I know.
Anyway, thanks for your work, JimD.
Edit: Oh, and as an aside, I think it’s cool that Jillian can get pregnant. I can’t stand Jillian, but I think having a child with another survivor really adds more emotional depth to the story, so that’s great. I think it’d be awesome if Rachel (my character’s love interest) could get pregnant, but I’m not sure she would allow that, with her type of personality.