First of all: Kudos to you for creating such a fascinating story and just as fascinating characters!
The characters you created are really multifaceted and interesting. Every person has something unique about themselves and no one is stereotypical. I like to discover the unique dynamics of everyone and enjoy learning more about everyone as the story progresses.
First of all regarding Valerie: I think you managed it really great to make her annoying yet still endearing. She’s a handful and absolutely suffers from ADHS - but she has her heart in the right place.
About Rawlin: I didn’t really like him at first, especial when it came to his behavior regarding Valerie, but he is starting to grow on me as I learn more about him. I’m curious to get to know him better.
Can’t say much about Kira so far, but she’s certainly interesting.
I like your idea of involving a mundie in the science of magic - although Andrei seems disturbingly obsessed with his studies. But I’m sure that there’s a lot more to him and I’m curious to learn more about him. His approach during the confrontation was certainly great!
Then there’s Callum, of course, and I absolutely love him! I picked the lovers background, hoping for some angst and tragedy, but now I’m just wishing for a surprising plot twist that redees him! Really didn’t expect to succumb to his charms, but here I am. lol
And I’m desperately asking myself: Why did he betray us?! But I’m sure the answer will be awesome!
Charlotte is great as well. She’s so bratty and snobby, but you avoid nasty clichés and show that there is more depth to her. And now she’s starting to question her worldview a little - wonderful.
The trio’s entire dynamic is just great! I never expected that the group would work so well and I didn’t think the love triangle would feel so authentic, but I’m absolutely blown away! And soooo excited to read more about the past.
Truly, past and present read like two separate books! It’s wonderful how immersive both of them are.
You wrote a truly compelling story and I’m curious to see how everything is going to develop, how the questios will be answered. We haven’t even been introduced to all the characters and it seems as if so much has already happened!
So all in all: I’m thrilled and just want to say, how much I love your story - from the plot to the characters to your style of writing. It’s wonderful and I’m excited to read more!