I found out about your WIP in the femboy dating simulator thread, you said that your story has a femboy in it and I was like
, and decided to read it.
I really enjoyed reading it! I love the heavily oppressed and religious setting of the story. Your writing style overall is really nice, it sort of lively and dramatic, never dull and boring. Some descriptions are rather poetic, and some scenes have a good emotional punch. Probably my favorite emotional scene was the soccer short story when MC was poisoned and Marcus realised his feelings, that was very moving. There’s also a lot of humour, which is also a big plus in a story. You made me laugh several times, I especially liked the description “His eyebrows shot up so high, it was as if they were trying to escape his face and make a break for it.” ![:rofl: :rofl:](https://emoji.discourse-cdn.com/twitter/rofl.png?v=12)
Love the MC, I’m glad we’re a vampire, and the transformation scene during fight was cool and unexpected. We should drink more blood though, I remember it happened only once in the story, and the rest was just normal food. Also I really enjoyed being a badass who intimidates people just by looking at them.
I read through the thread and found out that you want to make poly routes with three or two ROs. Personally I enjoy the drama, so my MC flirts with everyone, but I want to only have a relationship with Marcus (I just love seeing him jealous, sorry bb
). So the question is: can I accidentally stumble into a poly just by flirting with everyone, or will you include some separate options that will make it clear that they’ll trigger a poly route (e.g. special flirt-choice with two ROs at once instead of just one RO)?
Coming back to femboys, I wasn’t disappointed by Marcus, he is amazing and so cute! I love how shy he is, I want to make him blush as much as possible with my dominant MC (btw, my dominant stat at the end was 69%
). It’s very hard to find an RO like Marcus, so thank you so much for him. ![:smiling_face: :smiling_face:](https://emoji.discourse-cdn.com/twitter/smiling_face.png?v=12)
Now more specific feedback and some mistakes under the cut.
I’ll start with things that would improve inclusivity of the story. I’m very passionate about this topic, so I hope I won’t come on too strong ![:sweat_smile: :sweat_smile:](https://emoji.discourse-cdn.com/twitter/sweat_smile.png?v=12)
- Pronouns and gender identity is not the same thing. I suggest changing the wording when you ask about pronouns to include gender identity with it. It might be nitpicky, but this change will make what you’re asking about clearer, because, for example, some amab people can identify as non-binary, but use he/him pronouns. Coding gender identity and pronouns separately may be too much work, but making the question clearer will make it better, I think. Example:
But what gender do you identify with and what pronouns do you choose for yourself?
I identify as a boy and use he/him pronouns.
I identify as a girl and use she/her pronouns.
I wasn’t really one for genders. (They/them)
-
After choosing gender and pronouns the game calls the MC “handsome boy”, “beautiful girl”, or “good looking person”. “Beautiful” and “handsome” are heavily gendered adjectives that limit MC’s appearance, because they imply that MC conforms to traditional gender norms. For example, the word “handsome” wouldn’t be a suitable adjective for Marcus, because of how feminine he is. I suggest changing it to gender neutral version for every gender: “good looking boy/girl/person”. There was another instance of using such words later in the story: “handsome young man”, consider changing it as well for better inclusivity.
-
I could be wrong, but are MC’s clothes gendered? I only got the option to wear jeans/pants/shorts as a male MC, no skirts. It’s better when all clothes are unisex, unless female MCs also didn’t get to wear skirts.
Other stuff:
People already noticed bug where MC corrects Mr. Vigil on their gender despite being cis; I don’t know if you’ve already fixed it or not, but just letting you know it’s still there.
You can buy ammunition for your gun endlessly, you don’t lose any money.
There were a couple of height mistakes with 6’3 and taller MC:
-
“Marcus sat right next to you and scooted close to you, resting his head against yours.” - He should probably rest his head against MC’s shoulder because of height difference.
- When hugging Marcus: “You asked, voice muffled with your face buried in his chest.” - Doesn’t make sense unless MC is kneeling in front of him.
Some screenshots:
Hayes relationship stat is always bugged, but sometime later it bugged Marcus’ stat as well. Also there’s a full stop mark after Vivian.
This choice lowers “Deceptive” stat, but shouldn’t it increase it instead?
“Ear” sounds awkward and the word “hair” is missing (also first line - “y” in “you” shouldn’t be capital).
The sentence cuts off:
Blaine referred to as “Marcus” before you get to choose their gender:
Marcus’ eyes are hazel, but maybe it’s intentional, like they looked darker before lighting up, I’m not sure:
Some mistakes on the stats page:
- Athletic and muscled build or body (also Athletic shouldn’t start with the capital “A”, and it should be “an” instead of “a”).
- Above - “A” shouldn’t be capital.
- pure - should be capital “P”.
- And last, save slots still don’t work, but you probably know it.