Typically, when you are conquered, you don’t get too much from the treaty. The nobles were supremely lucky to have been able to keep their lands at all, let alone be in a position to dictate how their conquorers ruled over them.
Maintenance of order by any governement depends greatly on some degree of concent by the governed. This is especially true of law enforcement as they usually depend on human intelligence to do their jobs. At the end of the day the alastors are still doing the normal police grunt work of arresting or deterring the rapists, murderers, thieves, and cart parking violators of the Hegemony. Even if they just beat an accused thief to death without a trial it still generally depends on a regular citizen identifying said thief. Patrolling and standing guard deters crime, but you would have to be the dumbest thief in history to rob someone in front of an alastor. You might say “the Hegemony doesn’t care about petty crime,” but in reality a tyrannical regime must particularly if it is a theocracy. Tyrannical regimes can hold on to and justify their power in only two ways really. “Do what I say or I’ll kill you,” which works sometimes or, “I may be harsh but I make the trains run on time, provide security, and keep us all from chaos,” which usually is the better long term position. The Hegemony is really harsh so both of those things need to be true most of the time to keep its vast population and territory in check. The alastors are a front line part of that.
Perhaps the Alastors are as you mentioned, meant to be both a carrot and a stick at the same time.
They’re there to be the Hegemony’s SS, sure, but they’re also there to enforce ilaw and order. If the Hegemony relied on local police to keep the peace, they’d lose that and people would just see them purely as the Hegemony’s attack dogs.
You assert. I see no evidence of that; usually the Alastors are said rapists, murderers, and thieves (per the trial scene).
The social contract between the Hegemony and the helots doesn’t include making the trains run on time. It doesn’t even offer "do what I say or I’ll kill you, it’s “do what I say and I’ll kill you, or don’t do what I say and I’ll torture you and then kill you faster.” Helots are effectively under the control of a Reichskommisariat; order is maintained through naked force, and if the entire helotry of a country rises up, they’re willing to simply slaughter the helots indiscriminately until the rising is quelled. The only thing even remotely looking like the consent of the governed involves religiously-backed Stockholm Syndrome reinforced by the Diakons, combined with the clear futility of rebellion. Hey, you might even live to be 25 and get your eternal reward afterward if you work hard, why waste that by rebelling?
Don’t underestimate the “eternal reward” part, by the way. The consistent failure of rebellion is designed to crush the helots’ hopes of anything better in this world, and then the Diakons offer the helots the only hope they can possibly have in the form of religion and a better place after they give their lives for the Thaumatarchy. It’s a great way to reinforce the self-rationalizing Stockholm Syndrome.
Again, per the trial scene, that’s about how they are seen by the helots. (To merchants, they also guard market towns from the inevitable outlaws and rebels.)
Of course, one of the Alastor’s jobs is keeping private property safe.
Especially when it runs away. The “property” in question takes an understandably dim view of the people whose job it is to keep them on noble estates.
Well, yeah.
The difference is that helots have no private property, they don’t even own themselves. So they can’t complain to an Alastor if they’re stolen from, or raped (hey, might make a new helot), or murdered (though their owner might be inconvenienced by the vandalism). A merchant with a good relationship with the local Alastors might be able to call on their help in dealing with attacks on himself (assuming he’s paid up his unofficial taxes). They certainly aren’t going to investigate a theft on their own initiative, though.
If a helot murders another helot, the Alastors might get involved for the reason @cascat07 mentioned; a murderous helot is damaging valuable property. If I were a murderous helot, though, I’d be at least as worried about the lord’s personal guards, or the reaction of my fellow helots for that matter (tragic midnight accident).
You are right in the fact that law and order doesn’t really apply to the helots, but there is a considerable proportion of freemen as well. They must be maintaining a degree of law and order with them. While it is not explicit there are things like taverns and traveling minstrels. That implies a free economy that trades in currency, which is something the helots are only participating in as farming equipment. A capital economy that trades in drachmas also will have thieves, con artists, tax evasion, and fraud. As far as I can tell alastors are the ones investigating and resolving those petty crimes.
This is in the extremely provincial locals like Rim Square. How is this working in Shayard City? Again not saying it is impossible, but a police force that is purposely comprised of non-locals, that are regularly rotated, and have no personal connection within a city is going to have a hard time keeping a lid on crime. Failing to do that in the capital of a Conte or any major population center puts the Hegemony’s control at risk.
Did you see any evidence of them having tremendous rapport with the merchants and other free persons? I didn’t. I imagine that they do a fairly half-assed job about it and go around beating anyone who complains, take all sorts of bribes to decide which way justice goes, and I don’t think there’s much to do about it from the crime victim’s position unless they’re able to use whatever connections or money is at their disposal.
It’s not a perfect system, for sure. There’s no doubt that that would make at least some of the affected people disgruntled against the alastors and the order that employs them. But you’d kind of expect that from a society in which you could spark a tremendous rebellion, couldn’t you? It’s not all stuff without precedent, and again the Hegemony doesn’t have to be as careful as many societies in our world due to their magic system.
Sure, but I would expect it to work especially poorly even in terms of just keeping the alastors in remote stations like Rim Square fed, paid, under arms, and with their head attached. Maybe it works better in other parts of the Hegemony, and maybe it doesn’t that is kinda what I was asking of @Havenstone. One thing you normally get with a “federal” agency vs a local one is consistent performance. If the alastors are consistently as shit as they are in Rim Square throughout the Hegemony I don’t understand how they could maintain control for so long.
Edit: I did actually think of one instance where they kinda do their job. When the alastors hear a disturbance going on at the local telone’s house…
@cascat07
1)I would say there IS some local police, although it is informal and not permanent. Hector’s posse does hunt down and eliminate crimimals. The overseeres make sure that helots behave well. All of this qualifies as law enforcement duty.
2) It seems that one purpose of the Alastors is to represent Hegemonial power. Rim Square seems to have far more Alastors than neccessary for a place with this population.
Yes, they have very strong religious overtones and I think they may have originated as a more formal religious police, way back when. It would go a long way to explain their corruption and brutality.
Also since the Karagond version of the Xthonic religion basically exists to pacify the gullible population and legitimise numerous acts of state brutality. They presumable serve Xthones by doing anything that brings “glory” to the Hegemony and for its “good and faithful” works that glorify Xthones, the Hegemony needs taxes above all.
Is it any wonder that the nonsense of the Xthonic religion and its enforced caste system are what my character despises most and intends to shatter beyond repair.
Aren’t you kind of contradicting yourself there? While obviously there’s going to be more consistency when an office is being run by one authority rather than countless tinier ones, I think the local conditions really count for far more as you alluded to at the start of that post. The Rim is an impoverished backwater; Alastors don’t likely want to be posted there in the first place, so whoever shows up is going to be likely disgruntled about it. Most everyone is relatively poor and not willing to spare what they have, so the Alastors need to be more thuggish if they want to enrich themselves-- and what else is there to do in the area, really?
I would imagine that the situation would be much better in the large cities. The Alastors selected would likely be the cream of the crop to ensure fewer problems with the wealthier and more influential residents, they want to continue being stationed there so that they are more hesitant to screw things up, and there’s more opportunities for bribes and so on so that even greedy Alastors can get by as just being corrupt without needing to resort to thuggery to enrich themselves.
Consistancy in large federal organizations is usually a feature of how they are inspected and trained. Since the alastors are required to move frequently in an effort to ensure they don’t build any lasting connections with the local population, I don’t think you would see a big difference in behavior between the ones in the city and the rural alastors. The ones that are corrupt would have to set up their extortion rackets every time they were moved. Not much time for subtlety, and the local merchants are probably going to wait to be hit up rather than risk the ire of one of the few honest alastors by bribing them upfront.
As far as the contradiction, that depends greatly on the Hegemony. What I’m saying is that the expectation of performance and this the requirements should be the same for alastors anywhere they are stationed. It would be considerably more challenging to meet that standard in Rim Square vice Shyard City. Either the Hegemony shorts the rural posts or they keep expectations low across the board. Either way your frontline policing is suboptimal at best, and that is not including the self imposed handicaps of moving alastors regularly to avoid local entanglements.
The local populations are not identical. An Alastor going around and cracking in all the heads among impoverished freeholders in the Rim is going to be seen rather differently than one doing the same in wealthy districts of the capitol; the more influential and important in the latter region aren’t going to tolerate that so easily going on with their own, and they actually have the sway to do something about it. Look at how a certain high-born noble in the story was treated in a trial as a result of his status compared to how that would have gone down in the Rim with any of the other main characters.
Standards from the Hegemony as to what is acceptable policing for an area is clearly not going to be constant, it’s not even constant nationwide across most any country in our world. Those with wealth and influence who desire that their local police act as a cut above the typical thugs will pull the strings necessary to achieve it, so the Alastors aren’t going to be the same across the board regardless of whether or not they were initially trained and held to the same standards. The cream or the connected are going to find themselves in the best positions, the worst of the lot that have no friends in higher stations will find themselves assigned to the worst positions. Regular rotation of alastors would actually help to ensure this as a fixture; ones who shape up and make a name for themselves may be assigned to better jobs, while those who are too extreme for their position and offend the wrong person will be exiled to horrible postings like the Rim. The Hegemony’s most highborn nobles aren’t going to tolerate thugs smashing in the teeth of their children for a single drachem, no one will care if the same thing happens to Shayarin freeholders on the edge of the civilized world.
Those in the best positions would be encouraged to act with some restraint and to keep the peace in a way that those in power approve of to keep their positions; those with positions from the very bottom of the barrel don’t really have to act with such restraint since no one will care about the opinions of the residents where they’re based, all they have to do is not be outrageous enough that they spark a fire that they can’t extinguish.
I think that is making a lot of assumptions about things we don’t have complete information. The nobles seem to have less regard for the alastors even in rim square, but a city is going to be primarily comprised of non-helots or at least helots with a different social status than a farmhand. The alastors being rotated has little to do with performance from what I can tell so far and more to do with ensuring that can’t facilitate a local rebellion and stand in opposition to the local populace.
I’m just saying that the conduct of the alastors is going to be based a lot more on who they’re around than any sort of national standardization, so while it’s true that the Alastors are terrible at the Rim to even those who fully abide by the law they’re likely to be at least somewhat less awful around the centers of Hegemonic power. Using Alastors from other regions and regularly rotating has the benefit of that the Alastors don’t have prior personal ties murkying up their work as well as (at least in theory) leaving people room to respect their more local authority figures while their attack dogs can be presented as ‘those jerks from the coast’ or something. Divide and rule, all that.
If the Alastors are the Hegemony’s gendarmerie I wouldn’t put it past the Hegemony to have the wealthier districts in the cities primarily patrolled by either noble guards, like a modern gated community or for some wealthy cities to have their own municipal police who are less brutal since they deal primarily with the upper and what passes for the middle classes of their respective regions.
Those forces, if they exist are not likely to be numerous enough to make a difference in any uprising and in any case they would be even more on the side of the Hegemony and the local nobility in case of a Helot uprising.
No doubt your rabble will feel so. Yet, if the heavily armed forces of order deployed along the most influential and wealthiest supporters of the Hegemony were somehow convinced not even to stand idly by but to universally join in the rebellion… I think that hypothetical would have the potential to cause a more terrible disorder throughout the whole of the Hegemony than the plundering of thousands of helot hovels or even hundreds of estates. A cut along the neck is more dire than dozens on the feet, after all, and a large army is little good if it cannot be adequately supplied nor armed.
Good luck in getting there, I know.
You forget that the Alastors are merely the gendarmerie, like other real world gendarmes they seem to be a paramilitary force, at best. If a heavy hand, or a violent example, is somehow needed in one of the wealthier districts they might send in the Plektoi to really send a message and no noble guard or municipal police force can compete with the regular army.
Though the Hegemony seems to prefer dealing with discontent among its wealthier and more powerful subjects through the liberal use of Kryptasts who arrange mysterious accidents like the one that can befall Horion and is blamed on our merry band of rebels in case you decide to let them go.
If no real rebels are handy they’d likely have arranged for some “bandits” and the outcome would have been the same.
It is precisely that the mere possibility of someone ever getting there is so completely disregarded by the Hegemony that they did not plan for such an unfathomable event.
Don’t forget though that such full-throated noble support would be just as risky to my “rabble” as it would be to the Hegemony, my character would probably prefer it if they’d just stand idly by, otherwise I’d risk turning the revolution into just a Pyrrhic victory over the Thaumatarchy.
It’s one of the tightropes my character would have to walk as he needs enough noble acquiescence to actually prevail against the Hegemony but limit their influence enough so that they cannot hijack his movement in order for himself and the Helots to retain enough bargaining power to form a compromise “unity” government afterwards. That government then merely serves as a front in order to draw out the most dangerous nobles, such as the Laconnier supporters in order to have a second revolution a few months/years later in order to truly deal with the caste system.
In a theocracy is there really a difference between religious police and gendarmes, since any rebel is by definition a heretic and any heretic is also a rebel.
