Choice of Rebels Part 1 WIP thread

Minor correction: in a theocracy there’s no difference between religious and political police (as I mentioned above).

A gendarmerie refers to a police force that is also a branch of the military, and is usually armed and trained as such. Italy’s Carabinieri and the Mounties, for example. The Alastors are both gendarmerie and religious/political police, and so they serve both as a military garrison and as the guys who intimidate the helots (and to a lesser extent merchants) into compliance.

1 Like

The Alastors don’t really need to be stronger than the military. Alastors are nearly everywhere; the military is obviously superior in terms of the force that it may apply, but the military is not numerous enough to be everywhere, at least not without getting diluted to the point that it’d be incredibly weakened. Everywhere that the military is not present, the Alastors are the main holders of power. Obviously it’s not great to have a revolution with just Alastors on one’s side, but turning them to one’s side from all across the Hegemony would force the Hegemony to use its military to occupy the most important areas just to keep the taxes and strategic interests of that area going their own way rather than elsewhere, and starving it of resources in such a manner would obviously limit the extent to which it could strike back.

Hopefully, their interests are aligned with those of the more military-minded and I can champion some sort of coup against the state with their power. You know, we reorder society with my character and friends making the rules together with several reform-minded officers, hopefully we do well enough to make it all less of a powder keg liable to blow up in the faces of our descendants or other successors.

I’ll just note that this is

(a) true,
(b) no longer affordable for the Hegemony, and
(c) a significant reason why the Alastors have become more predatory over the past generation or so.

You’re starting a rebellion in a destabilizing system, which is why this story can stretch to 5 games rather than ending in an early and brutally unsatisfactory fashion. :slight_smile:

Now back to making sure the tax raid still works. Update coming soon…

18 Likes

So the Hegemony is being crushed under its own weight, huh. If so have they raised taxes or tariffs?
Could we use that to get the nobility or merchants on our side?

1 Like

Not only that, but the system is being destabilized by the very factors that uphold its security - it can’t afford its iron security anymore both because of the cost of keeping the helots down so that they can be used as livestock, and because it’s hard to keep up a productive helot population when they’re slaughtering said population as very slow-maturing beef.

…hm. Maybe a new Hegemony should focus on Harrowing adult men and post-menopausal women, and enforce helot polygyny to increase the population.

I think the thing of particular note was how little blood the Thrueges had at the Harrowing. I think they should have expected trouble, and even if they didn’t why not take a full bandolier just in case? I would never go on patrol with out my normal consignment of ammo even if I thought it was going to be routine. Either they were getting complacent, or there is a blood shortage.

3 Likes

Both, from the sound of it. It was mentioned that they were Harrowing more than usual this year for some reason, but nobody was expecting a revolt then.

That, or the Theurges were led to be a bit complacent because a Kryptast had decided to stir the pot on the Shayard Rim.

2 Likes

Most Alastors are criminals though and I would obviously never let anyone of them work in law-enforcement ever again.
A completely new police force, free of former Alastors will be needed (along with a system of civil laws not tied to the Xthonic religion and caste system) if the former Helots are ever to be truly free.

I’[quote=“Golgot, post:3931, topic:1601”]
reform-minded officers
[/quote]

Ha! If you want to build a better society the officers are the ones who have got to go. Any reform that “reform minded” officers in the Hegemony would agree to would most likely keep the caste system intact, create a warrior caste, if there isn’t one already and still be generally bad for the Helotry.
Reform minded officers might have ideas on how to make the army better and more efficient but it would not be an army that serves the people in any meaningful sense of the word.

Most likely a little of column A and a little of column B. We do come from a podunk village out in the middle of nowhere so the Theurges assigned there are hardly going to get priority when it comes to supplies such as blood, plus the Hegemony is likely to be far more vigilant of the possible restive, yet still formally free, underclasses in those cities @Havenstone mentioned a while back and does not really consider the possibility of a Helot rebellion, or if they did they certainly didn’t anticipate if starting in such a backwards region as Rim bloody Square.

A blood shortage would be interesting as it would eventually force them to cut back on their wasteful prestige projects, such as (most of the) Wards or else to start Harrowing, or otherwise harvesting blood from (nominally) free citizens of the provinces, which won’t do them any favours in the mid to long term.

My ultra-religious, patriotic noble MC has no intentions of suffering the existence of any treasonous heretics like the Alastors in the future Kingdom (Possibly Empire) of Shayard. A Shayardene Holy Order will hunt them all down to the edges of the world. Even in Xaos lands the vile minions of the heathen empire won’t be safe from the wrath of the angels.

1 Like

As you hear at one point (I think at the Harrowing), the blood shortage is being caused by wasteful prestige projects (like some lord wanting a seventh harvest in the year).

It’s not like any of us suspected anything else all along. :smiley:

1 Like

I wonder if its something in the general make-up of human psychology that causes most oppressive overly absolutist governments fall.

Its not meerly that when forced to live under an oppressive freedom squashing regime the citizenship of said regime will rise up fighting for their freedom.

Its often not revolt that ends up toppling these regimes, often its their hubris and arrogance that gradually corrupts the government rendering it invlaid in the eyes of nobles, citizens or in the case of medival Europe the catholic church which often saw fit to meddle in the affairs of secular lords.

Its been argued that because these sorts of governments often severely opress their population whether its their respective versions of nobility, citizenry or both.

History however speaks in contrast to that notion, or at least provides examples of this not being the case equall to those supporting it. An example of this and one that struck a cord with me when i learned about it …would be the pilgrimage of grace undertaken by the various vasssals and common people against king henry the eighth.

Although the actual members of the plot claimed to be and probably for the most part actually where …they still considered taking arms against their sovereign lord to be an appropriate course of action…despite the fact that at this point no one in the Tudor court did anything with out king henry having at least some knowledge of it and possesing the power to stop these actions supposedly forced upon him by his evil.councilors the pilgrims of grace still held that it was not the king but cromwell or sir richard rich that was the cause of their woes or at least being bullied into agreeing. No one bullied henry the eighth into doing anything…especially not at this stage. In fact when people tried this no matter theor rank he would routinely go out of his way tp do everything possible not only to prove his own supremacy but usually also to annihilate whoever attempted this and their families.

After a negotiated peace the king effectively backstabbed the pilgrimages leaders after luring them into violating the truce. No rising followed this and once the duke of Suffolk the kings personal friend and childhood companion commited what was basically our concept of genocide not surprisingly no one said much after that. This policy continued to be used by all but one of henrys successors and would actually prove to be instrumental in establishing the British empire creating one of the greatest imperial dictatorships in history, opression birthed greatness .

This novel in my opinion captures the subtle nuances of the quandry ive just mentioned. The fight for freedom is never as clear cut and black.and white as its proponents claim . havenstone has captured something special with this novel. Lets hope he continues to draw inspiration providing us with this visceral representation of human nature, power politics and empire.

[quote=“idonotlikeusernames, post:3937, topic:1601”]
Ha! If you want to build a better society the officers are the ones who have got to go. Any reform that “reform minded” officers in the Hegemony would agree to would most likely keep the caste system intact, create a warrior caste, if there isn’t one already and still be generally bad for the Helotry. Reform minded officers might have ideas on how to make the army better and more efficient but it would not be an army that serves the people in any meaningful sense of the word.
[/quote]I see no reason not to continue the current system with regards to helotry. The helots and poachers we associate with are generally impertinent vipers at best, and the worst of the crowd are disgusting little monsters such as Kalt; as we certainly can’t afford the costs of a general education to their bunch immediately, the best option is to uplift the cream of that group with outstanding achievements to their name where feasible and consign the rest to their destruction in the Harrower for the good of all. It’s an imperfect solution, but in the absence of any other ideas on what to do about Xaos storms the hands are tied.

Still, too much honest blood is wasted on needless decadence and adventures, and so the sacrifice is not given the respect it deserves and harvests are called too frequently. There is a need for a severe justice to be administered to those who allegedly support the Hegemonic system when they cannot adhere to its laws… It is a given that local authorities far from the eye of the capitol will be prone to corruption and error, but the people must have a reasonable belief that such authorities will be destroyed when their wretchedness becomes known to the highest powers.

Ah, but that is where our greatest difference lies, or my Helot character the true rebellion is against the Hegemony’s caste system and the Xthonic faith they use to enforce it. The Thaumatarchy is merely stage one, or even a sideshow.

The same can be said of the nobles and the other higher castes, most of them will never truly respect someone who was born a Helot. Which means the society of the Hegemony must be overthrown, deconstructed and rebuild from the ground up.

Is he any worse than Hector though? I would think not, there will always be rotten sadists, best we can do is try to make sure they do not rise to positions of great power, unlike in the current Hegemony, which seems to favour these sorts of people.

I disagree, education is how we will win this thing. If everyone able to learn was taught basic literacy, numeracy and the fundamentals of theurgy, the social system of the Hegemony would be impossible to sustain.
Education, general education for a classless population, will be the fundamental part of any post-Hegemonic system.

The operative part here being “where feasible”, which will be virtually “never” if you intend on leaving the caste system intact as the Hegemony currently suppresses even the mere concept of manumission.
Social mobility between the castes is virtually non-existent, you’re a Helot, a Noble or a Yeoman and the current system is set up to make sure you will remain that way and that sytem will be far harder to change than merely instituting a coup of the Thaumatarchy or installing a new, monarchial government in an independent Shayard.

I don’t disagree there.

The Harrowing is neither a sacrifice, it’s ritual murder pure and simple and as such it does not deserve any respect whatsoever.

The Hegemony is very good in severe it’s very bad at administering anything that could even charitably be described as “justice”.

Nobody is more wretched than the Thaumatarch buddy, except possibly his heir(s), it’s practically a requirement for the job.
As for justice it seems that the Hegemony largely preaches that Xthones and his “merciful” Angels will take care of justice…in the afterlife so there’s little need for us to worry about such trivial concerns as “justice”.

1 Like

[quote=“idonotlikeusernames, post:3943, topic:1601”]The same can be said of the nobles and the other higher castes, most of them will never truly respect someone who was born a Helot. Which means the society of the Hegemony must be overthrown, deconstructed and rebuild from the ground up.[/quote]Suzane is great, she’s really the only likable one out of the whole bunch to follow us into the woods and stick with us for the long haul… at least, not including those who just joined up at the very end of the last chapter, since I’m not quite sure how to evaluate them yet. Her and the Telone, anyway. The helots are essentially cannon fodder to me, I’ll bribe them here and there and provide some favorable treatment to ensure their goodwill but they’re not going anywhere.

Yes, I think so. Hector is heavily incentivized to kill us all, at least, there’s no reason for him to consider holding back. His violence, while deplorable, makes sense. Kalt freely attempts to kill those he dislikes without any regard for whether or not it’s a good idea for his cause.

[quote=“idonotlikeusernames, post:3943, topic:1601”]
I disagree, education is how we will win this thing. If everyone able to learn was taught basic literacy, numeracy and the fundamentals of theurgy, the social system of the Hegemony would be impossible to sustain.Education, general education for a classless population, will be the fundamental part of any post-Hegemonic system.[/quote]And again, we can’t afford this. The population is tremendous, supported by the agricultural efforts of a massive population of terribly impoverished helots and magic derived from their blood. If they’re all in school after the revolution, who’s working in the fields? For that matter, where are you getting all the schools to fill with the people, or the teachers to staff them? If you aren’t even harrowing folks, then all the business about the wards and Xaos-storms aside you’re going to have massive famines when theurgically enhanced crops can’t be collected.

I agree with you that education will be the key out of the old system to bring in new thoughts and advances that allow for a transition, but this is just impractical.

[quote=“idonotlikeusernames, post:3943, topic:1601”]
The operative part here being “where feasible”, which will be virtually “never” if you intend on leaving the caste system intact as the Hegemony currently suppresses even the mere concept of manumission.Social mobility between the castes is virtually non-existent, you’re a Helot, a Noble or a Yeoman and the current system is set up to make sure you will remain that way and that sytem will be far harder to change than merely instituting a coup of the Thaumatarchy or installing a new, monarchial government in an independent Shayard.
[/quote]Frankly, that’s fine by me. If there’s only a trickle of the most extraordinary departing from the helotry, that maintains the blood base that makes possible everyones survival. This change has got to come gradually to avoid mass misery on a grander scale by far.

[quote=“idonotlikeusernames, post:3943, topic:1601”]
The Harrowing is neither a sacrifice, it’s ritual murder pure and simple and as such it does not deserve any respect whatsoever.
[/quote]Feel free to think this, but I’ll say that if it keeps everyone from starving and being morphed into horrific centipede monsters or whatever other Xaotic abominations then it’s worth it.

[quote=“idonotlikeusernames, post:3943, topic:1601”]
Nobody is more wretched than the Thaumatarch buddy, except possibly his heir(s), it’s practically a requirement for the job.As for justice it seems that the Hegemony largely preaches that Xthones and his “merciful” Angels will take care of justice…in the afterlife so there’s little need for us to worry about such trivial concerns as “justice”.
[/quote]We have this (likely correct) impression because the entire bureaucracy such that we have been able to see is scum. A better Thaumatarch would see the worst examples of needless suffering of their people under at least the most heinously corrupted nobles and utilize their righteous might to provide a burning impression of what not to do for the rest of the nobles, and repeat as needed. The Thaumatarch does not need to be nice or pleasant, but if they have set a law it must be upheld harshly so that the general order is respected. If the nobility in their role as natural leaders do not act in an upright fashion and willfully disregard the public order, it’s inevitable that those below them will emulate the false model and become crooked as well. The nobles enjoy privileges due to their higher station, but this must also come with higher responsibilities.

For one it would only be the children who would be in full time school and if that isn’t feasible we could always do more formally what farmers in this country did in real life for quite some time, send their children to school only 1-2 or 3 days of he week. As for the adults I plan to introduce one free day in each week unit, those that want to can learn then, or in the evenings, like my own character did.
The immediate purpose is to raise a generation taught to think for themselves and not fear Xthonos and other make belief demons.

The physical buildings aren’t that important one can learn in a tent or under the sky if need be, though barns or re-purposed former noble estates could go some way to meeting the demand. As for the teachers, If it will likely be a condition of the pardon of many of the younger and more useless former nobles, perhaps some former Alastors as well as it will be either that or be branded a “dangerous counter-revolutionary” and work on infrastructure for the rest of their lives anyway.

The abhumans are still around despite of living next the Xaos for centuries now, I think it will all depend on our own ability to learn how to harness Xaos ourselves and the negotiations with a certain someone in the very last game, but the wards were not there for centuries and they likely won’t need to be either.

There will likely be some lean times, no mass famines though. Havenstone has previously said that farming depends mostly on a certain class of theurge, not the nobles or their overseers for the most part.
As for the blood, either a blood tax and/or more theurgically trained farmers using their own and other peoples fresh blood might work. The one free day my character will promise isn’t going to radically break the bank here especially since we’ll waste less food on decadence, as in nobles needing seven harvests along with a colossal amount of food waste to finance their decadent lifestyles.

See, running a slave society is not fine by my character’s reckoning especially since he’s one of the slaves.
Besides with a blood tax everyone can contribute to our collective survival, no need to designate a caste as blood cattle anymore.
Also if you keep the Hegemonic laws and social attitudes you can’t really, legally or practically manumit anybody, the obvious loophole to this is discovering somebody’s “great and noble” ancestor and “restoring” them to where they should have been all along, needless to say my character won’t want to be part of such a charade under any circumstances, particularly since it means having to play the game by their rules when I’d much rather have them scrambling to keep up with my new rules. Furthermore such a system can only ever work if it’s a very small trickle indeed.

The Xaos abominations are a problem Hera and the warlike early Hegemony likely created for themselves in the first place and there will likely be ways to deal with it other then the wards, again the Abhumans are the example here.
As for starving the Harrowing is, or was about getting the most potent blood possible in order to fuel their little conquests, there’s no convincing evidence that some other way of harvesting said blood isn’t “good enough” if the primary objective of it isn’t conquest anymore but to keep anybody from starving.

If by “better” you mean more just and fair, instead of just more magically powerful I’d say you’ve got yourself a fine oxymoron right there. :wink:

Doubtful considering the whole system is predicated on suffering on a mass scale.

Bwahahahahha…the Thaumatarch and “righteous” might don’t really fit together in the same sentence. :laughing:
Their might is based on extracting it from their suffering people in the most horrific way possible not on any divine or popular favour.

Yes, yes, the whole “It’s better to be feared than loved spiel” What the Thaumatarchy seems to have forgotten is that the full quote is “It is better to be feared than loved, if you cannot be both.”. However the Thaumatarchy and the Hegemony have long since given up on even trying the latter, which means that if you make enough people no longer fear the Thaumatarchy it will be gone.

This isn’t the Infinity series the whole idea of the Hegemony’s current nobility as “natural” leaders is, frankly laughable cause there ain’t nothing “natural” about Theurgy, it’s a learned skill rather than some inborn “gift” and merely possessing it, much like the Infinity series banesense does not make one a “natural” leader anyway. Never mind that a great many of the Hegemony’s nobility, particularly in the provinces do not even possess said skill and are nothing but idle-rich, or as my character would probably be fond of saying parasites.

Privilege should come from individual merit, not class, incidentally not meriting it likely explains why so many of them cannot or will not handle their responsibilities in any acceptable fashion.

[quote=“idonotlikeusernames, post:3945, topic:1601”]
For one it would only be the children who would be in full time school and if that isn’t feasible we could always do more formally what farmers in this country did in real life for quite some time, send their children to school only 1-2 or 3 days of he week. As for the adults I plan to introduce one free day in each week unit, those that want to can learn then, or in the evenings, like my own character did. The immediate purpose is to raise a generation taught to think for themselves and not fear Xthonos and other make belief demons.
[/quote]The Hegemony to my understanding doesn’t have all that many labor saving mechanisms, the magic has been used to tremendously boost the yield of crops but it’s still necessary to draw it all in regularly or else it just rots in the field. Without all those extra crops, a tremendous number of people will starve, since this is boosted way beyond what would be a natural limit on the population. One free day a week to every helot is a tremendous cost in man-hours for bringing in the harvest, and when you consider that the bell curve of the helot population is shifted significantly towards the younger end of the spectrum I think that 3 days off for the children would make it even more severe. This would be feasible with some more labor-saving inventions, but so far as we’ve seen the Hegemony utterly lacks those because it’s had no need to devise them. I’m not willing to risk mass starvation to fulfill an ideological goal. Maybe you could have them learn on days where the weather is too terrible to harvest properly, but the regularity of that probably varies pretty strongly throughout the Hegemony.[quote=“idonotlikeusernames, post:3945, topic:1601”]
The physical buildings aren’t that important one can learn in a tent or under the sky if need be, though barns or re-purposed former noble estates could go some way to meeting the demand. As for the teachers, If it will likely be a condition of the pardon of many of the younger and more useless former nobles, perhaps some former Alastors as well as it will be either that or be branded a “dangerous counter-revolutionary” and work on infrastructure for the rest of their lives anyway.
[/quote]Aren’t the barns we’ve seen mostly ones for storage that get packed up with the frequent harvests, not just empty spaces? You can’t just cram children in those, there’s not room, and under the sky is well and good until there’s any inclement weather or its the wrong time of year. You’re only going to be able to get a fraction of the nobility that hasn’t been killed off by your rabble to go along with this scheme, most of whom are likely to be abominable teachers even in the best of circumstances. Think of the issues that one using harsh corporal punishment on an insolent child would bring up, for instance… I’m not thinking that what little they’d learn in such an environment is really worth the cost you’re imposing on society.

[quote=“idonotlikeusernames, post:3945, topic:1601”]
The abhumans are still around despite of living next the Xaos for centuries now, I think it will all depend on our own ability to learn how to harness Xaos ourselves and the negotiations with a certain someone in the very last game, but the wards were not there for centuries and they likely won’t need to be either.
[/quote]If you’re willing to accept being transfigured into some sort of abomination or dying in the horrific storms that will crash through the continent then yeah, I guess it’s not all that big a deal to live with. Best of luck in convincing everyone that follows you of that when you turn off the wards and the first of those leaps across to ravage the land.[quote=“idonotlikeusernames, post:3945, topic:1601”]
There will likely be some lean times, no mass famines though. Havenstone has previously said that farming depends mostly on a certain class of theurge, not the nobles or their overseers for the most part.As for the blood, either a blood tax and/or more theurgically trained farmers using their own and other peoples fresh blood might work. The one free day my character will promise isn’t going to radically break the bank here especially since we’ll waste less food on decadence, as in nobles needing seven harvests along with a colossal amount of food waste to finance their decadent lifestyles.
[/quote]A certain class of theurge is required, yes, the bulk of which are even more closely aligned to the Thaumatarchy from which they have learned their powers than the nobility. Training takes a large investment of time and blood for practice before the person may even become adequately skilled, and if I recall correctly the aetherial blood that provides the best effect was said by Havenstone to require something of the suffering and gristle. If you use other blood then that’ll require even greater quantities (I sure hope none of it goes bad) and from a public health perspective a blood tax on everyone is a nightmare. Can you imagine the infections transferring between everyone as the whole community contributes their pint, and how trained can our bloodletters possibly be right away to take even the most basic hygienic precautions if they’re even known in this setting? Yikes!

But OK, the wards are thirsty and you’re getting rid of them, and you’re sending the nobility out to be hobo teachers instead of living luxuriously. That frees up a lot, so leaving aside the number of trained theurges you have access to we’ll say that you have enough blood to keep up the current number of harvests. You still need the labor force to draw those in, do you not? The grain’s in the field, now it needs to be harvested and stored before it’s destroyed by the elements and vermin. For that you need laborers.

[quote=“idonotlikeusernames, post:3945, topic:1601”]
Also if you keep the Hegemonic laws and social attitudes you can’t really, legally or practically manumit anybody, the obvious loophole to this is discovering somebody’s “great and noble” ancestor and “restoring” them to where they should have been all along, needless to say my character won’t want to be part of such a charade under any circumstances, particularly since it means having to play the game by their rules when I’d much rather have them scrambling to keep up with my new rules. Furthermore such a system can only ever work if it’s a very small trickle indeed.
[/quote]When you are a great leader, to an extent it becomes possible to expend your tremendous influence to make a new custom. Alexander, Temujin, Ivan #4 and many other rulers have been able to shatter customs that their ancestors could never have dared and integrate new traditions into a glorious whole. If my character is from the helotry and he has been able to grab at the reigns of society and hold to them firmly, he is in an excellent position to argue that the most capable of the helots may advance from their low station. Out of the millions, despite what they must overcome, some will inevitably prove to be exemplary.

[quote=“idonotlikeusernames, post:3945, topic:1601”]
The Xaos abominations are a problem Hera and the warlike early Hegemony likely created for themselves in the first place and there will likely be ways to deal with it other then the wards, again the Abhumans are the example here.As for starving the Harrowing is, or was about getting the most potent blood possible in order to fuel their little conquests, there’s no convincing evidence that some other way of harvesting said blood isn’t “good enough” if the primary objective of it isn’t conquest anymore but to keep anybody from starving.
[/quote]Regardless of how it happened, it’s here now and no one has any ideas on how to make it stop happening. You may freely advocate for your people to just deal with it as a necessary cost, just don’t be surprised if they’re less than enthusiastic about that decision. I’ve already mentioned above what I think of a blood tax.

[quote=“idonotlikeusernames, post:3945, topic:1601”]
Doubtful considering the whole system is predicated on suffering on a mass scale.[/quote]It is, most assuredly. The system maximizes the number of people to maximize blood production to maximize the power that the state may wield, and we must deal with the consequences of the system. Removing the use of unethically sourced blood will cause the system to topple, and with the millions of lives that it unnaturally supports.

It’s a shame that this is the system that’s here, and I think it would be best to enact some sort of three child policy or something ASAP in order to start bringing the population down to something more manageable. We have to deal with what we have instead of wishing it was something else, though, unless we’re willing to cause even more misery on a wide scale.

[quote=“idonotlikeusernames, post:3945, topic:1601”]
Bwahahahahha…the Thaumatarch and “righteous” might don’t really fit together in the same sentence. :laughing:Their might is based on extracting it from their suffering people in the most horrific way possible not on any divine or popular favour.
[/quote] Their might is derived from the necessary suffering of the people, true, and if the Thaumatarch’s weren’t decadent devils then they would limit that suffering to what is required or inevitable considering that they can’t be everywhere at once. I was speaking in terms of a hypothetical.

[quote=“idonotlikeusernames, post:3945, topic:1601”]
Yes, yes, the whole “It’s better to be feared than loved spiel” What the Thaumatarchy seems to have forgotten is that the full quote is “It is better to be feared than loved, if you cannot be both.”. However the Thaumatarchy and the Hegemony have long since given up on even trying the latter, which means that if you make enough people no longer fear the Thaumatarchy it will be gone.
[/quote]I don’t think you quite understand. It’s not about bringing fear to the people, but the middle authorities. They have grown complacent as they are not punished for their excesses, so they freely and chaotically commit the worst atrocities on their lessers in opposition to many of the official codes that are simply ignored. If their superiors did their job and brought them to heel, it would bring a much better life to the smaller people which would bring a love of sorts. The common people in Russia cherished Ivan the Terrible for his severe justice, as did Wallachians their Prince Vladimir.[quote=“idonotlikeusernames, post:3945, topic:1601”]
Never mind that a great many of the Hegemony’s nobility, particularly in the provinces do not even possess said skill and are nothing but idle-rich, or as my character would probably be fond of saying parasites. Privilege should come from individual merit, not class, incidentally not meriting it likely explains why so many of them cannot or will not handle their responsibilities in any acceptable fashion.[/quote]They are the only group that is to an extent educated and capable of administering to the country with the funds to continue the process for their successors. In the absence of a strong bureaucracy capable of usurping their place which will take time to develop, they will serve nicely if their excesses may be reigned in.

Do Theurges get long life spans or just what anyone else has?

This is indeed what we’ve seen so far but it’s not entirely true, our characters are from a very backwoods and backward part of the Shayard province. @Havenstone has previously alluded to the fact that the Hegemony in fact possesses quite a bit of technology, or Teche, as they call it and its full extent would become more obvious once we reach Shayard city in the next game.
Therefore I think the technology or at least all the theoretical knowledge to construct the basic labour saving devices does likely exist, however you’re partially right that helots being used as blood cattle who trend towards the younger end of the spectrum there has been little incentive to deploy it, at least in relatively fertile and populous Shayard (once we get there Erezza may present a different story) because labour is too cheap and abundant and the ground to fertile for it.
Remember though that the Karagonds themselves come from a significantly less fertile and populous place and heavily restrict what tech their provinces can have.

It’s still better than not learning anything at all, like they do now, and those are merely stop-gap measures until proper replacements can be trained and/or imported. As for corporal punishment the society of the Hegemony is so desensitised to egregious acts of violence that wanton corporal punishment of children, as awful as that may be is hardly even noticed.
As for training the teachers if you get the teachers who are now at most tutoring 1-2 noble brats at one time in front of a classroom of 20 potential new teachers, that’s a huge gain in both scale and efficiency right there.
The Hegemony and the Xthonic faith rely on keeping the populace dumb, ignorant and fearful, to really break the (caste) system and achieve anything more than a Pyrrhic victory it’s going to require educating the masses. There really is no way around that.

You’re forgetting the re-purposed noble estates, there will be plenty of them and they are huge. I bet you can house a school for the entirety of Rim Square’s children in just Hector’s quarters alone.

Or labour saving devices and techniques, from what we’ve seen there’s minimal use of even animal power currently and as I’ve said before the tech probably exists and may already be in use in some other less fertile and populous parts of the Hegemony and almost certainly within Karagond itself, so it just becomes a question of deploying that on a grand scale.

With the Hegemony and the faith of Xthonos it is the laws themselves that are the problem, not any perceived lack of enforcement. We will need an entirely new set of laws to begin with, the current ones are utter rubbish and I believe that what passes for formal laws in the Hegemony was always explicitly based on Xthonic nonsense, of which large parts didn’t apply to the nobility to begin with.

No the merchants and telones of what passes for the middle classes in the Hegemony are too and it is those people who will be absolutely critical to my efforts, not the (former) nobility.
As we see with Bleys the beginnings of a bureaucracy able to displace the nobles does seem to exist already and it is likely that this is the plan of the current Karagond leadership as well as the status-quo is starting to become unsustainable.

From what we know Theurgy can prolong live for quite a bit but it is likely a certain bit of skill and power is required for it and thus not every Theurge would necessarily be longer-lived than the average person.

This goes so fundamentally against everything the Hegemony and the Faith of Xthonos stand for or believe in that by doing this without some sort of fig leaf of “restoration” instead of elevation you’d utterly shatter the caste system the Hegemony rests on in the first place, which you claim to want to preserve.

Yes, I’ve never claimed to want to do anything else as the current system is way beyond any meaningful reform.

Considering that there are other and far more wasteful areas to cut out of the current blood use first this is somewhat doubtful, but if that’s the price to pay well…, it will be what it will be.

No they won’t they’d never serve a Helot for example and they are defined by their very excesses, reigning them in to a degree where it would even begin to make any appreciable difference will be next to impossible. Which may be why the Hegemony may in fact be taking the first, tentative steps to eventually replace them with a bureaucracy made up of people like Bleys.

The hegemony certainly relies on this, but this doesn’t necessarily apply to the Xthonic faith itself. It’s not the faith’s fault that the hegemony has at the point of swords and spells put in place a religious hierarchy that it can use as a tool to justify its atrocities.

The laws aren’t really an issue for the faith of Xthonos, they are a civil matter. What is an issue is the doctored canon that the Hegemony-controlled religious hierarchy has been pushing on the populace in order to justify its own atrocities. Charges of heresy and corruption are a powerful wedge that can be used to pry the support of the devout away from the hegemony, especially those suspicious of Karagond’s corruptive influence on the faith and/or are troubled by their consciences.

[quote=“idonotlikeusernames, post:3947, topic:1601”][quote=Golgot:]
When you are a great leader, to an extent it becomes possible to expend your tremendous influence to make a new custom. Alexander, Temujin, Ivan #4 and many other rulers have been able to shatter customs that their ancestors could never have dared and integrate new traditions into a glorious whole. If my character is from the helotry and he has been able to grab at the reigns of society and hold to them firmly, he is in an excellent position to argue that the most capable of the helots may advance from their low station. Out of the millions, despite what they must overcome, some will inevitably prove to be exemplary.
[/quote]This goes so fundamentally against everything the Hegemony and the Faith of Xthonos stand for or believe in that by doing this without some sort of fig leaf of “restoration” instead of elevation you’d utterly shatter the caste system the Hegemony rests on in the first place, which you claim to want to preserve.[/quote]

It doesn’t necessarily go against what the Faith of Xthonos stands for, only what the Hegemony wants everyone to think the Faith of Xthonos stands for. I consider that to be a highly important distinction.

1 Like

A slight pronoun disagreement.

Original:
He looks up as you approach and beams. “You saved us, captain!” She looks like she’s barely checking her desire to throw her arms around you.

Suggestion:
In this play through, de Firiac was female. So, you should double check the “He” in the very first sentence.

1 Like