Poor Prii!
Also why I said Prii babies before.
2 Likes
Mm, fair enough; figured as an extra set of eyes (or ten orā¦) Iād mention it since it pertains to the main-plot functionality. I expect it to come into play in future. 
Something that has quite a large impact is the minor stat-boost from Chapter 2: this can make the difference between succeeding or failing a check, and thereās no way to opt-out of receiving that boost in the normal gameplay. Testing from a skip-ahead point without that enabled wonāt be an accurate representation.
Iāll be honest, I thought this chapter wasnāt finished yet. Thereās some essential missing context that makes the Ch11 startpoint and combat (most of the chapterā¦) awkward and pretty confusing:
Chapter 11 Feedback:
(Disclaimer: I canāt sugarcoat to save my life, so I love it when authors provide feedback forms. I do my damnedest not to eviscerate peopleās newborn projects and stomp the remainder of their guts out in a public forum, so hopefully the below doesnāt sound too harsh. I save my most pointed (and therefore most helpful) constructive criticisms for places nobody else can ogle it. Some things I just donāt say if one isnāt provided, as itās really nobody elseās business. Promise Iām here to be a positive influence.)
Hereās the general notes I jotted down when the chapter originally came out - itās still valid:
āAbsent a bridge from Chapter 10 to Chapter 11, I donāt know what the goal is (presumably ābeat everybody upā; but in the absence of knowing why I would want to do that, it gave the rough impression of a loosely-plotted action movie where the only reason people are throwing punches is for the sake of throwing punches, without any greater intent behind it), what details or narrative Iām meant to focus on story-wise, or even any intel about the opponents Iām facing.
Iām a bit lost with characters and events lacking any natural-timeframe introduction; and I canāt tell what state Dime is in with regard to powers-in-play (I also didnāt see any option to activate the specialties, but then part of the narrative makes me think theyāre already up? Iām so confused)ā
- the lack of ability to properly assess the fight (stakes and goal are essential for fights to have meaning; we can expect those arenāt āsurvivalā since we walked into the situation with eyes wide open instead of getting jumped by S.C.U.M. in the street) meansā¦ I couldnāt give any sort of valid feedback on how the fight went (what the feedback form asked for), as being so uninformed it would be all too easy to potentially steer you in the wrong direction.
General impressions:
- looks like weāve got new Balanced options for fighting. This looks promising; Iād like to see some effects enabled for not hitting the high-end of the spectrum but certainly being more to one side than the other.
- a checkpoint to rebalance your āpersonality statsā more to your intended playstyle before a fight kicks off would be nice, since the game likes to run away with that and assign what it thinks you should be ā and no matter what variety of character Iām attempting to play that go-round, my own personality as the player seems to be overriding it, since I canāt do a sufficiently accurate impersonation of a personality I myself donāt possess. (This makes it very hard for me perform testing, since I canāt organically get the numbers in their intended places, and have thus given up on attempting some routes.)
- full points for including options to both be highly concerned about and ignore the helpless civilians entirely; bonus points for including the villain option: agency is always welcome, and I know we have some folks around CoG who like to play the ah, unheroic characters; so thereās something here for them too.
All the compliments for providing the opportunity to play a grey character, rather than a firmly designated glitter-sparkly hero or mustachioed villain. Honestly, this is what Iām here for
- the list of choices seems to be ballooning - I suggest not displaying the inaccessible items. While itās truly great theyāre there, itās just taking up page space if theyāre not a choice we can actually pick.
- Loved the option to be pragmatic this chapter. Iāve been getting moralized at by the narrative so far (which leaves me scratching my head going āā¦ehhh? Whatād I do? ā¦Do youā¦ have something against being practical..?ā) and this made me feel right at home. [beams and casually breaks Teddieās bones, because heās my teammate and he asked me to.
] - Option I want: when I save the civilians and put down a Cannibal, the option for feeling āJustifiedā is disabled. (ā¦he threw a car of civilians..?) Iād like one for āResolvedā, because āNothingā isnāt accurate ā some men, just need a good killinā. (To that end, Iām disappointed I didnāt get the option before he threw a carfull of people at Dimeās head; because personally, I expected that behavior out of him.)
- Ranged options for Spring Breaker: whatās the point of being a tentacle-monster if you canāt use your great long tentacles?
The narrative tries to enforce that āthis person totally isnāt a big dealā (they run with SCUM. Iāll be taking them seriously, thanks); and if we get suspicious about how she keeps trying to get her hands on Dime, we simply have no option not to close with her (if weāre not taking the suspicious energy drink that came out of the evil lab). Which goes about as well as youād think and ends up being awfully frustrating, since Iām not seeing any option to avoid it. - Pretty sure Dime can prevent being identified by Insider at the cafe? The option for āhe knows my faceā should be greyed-out if Dime hasnāt been.
- Ghoul thinks they killed Insider. Theyāve run off and abandoned us, just like everybody else on our team
I canāt believe Iām saying this (Izzy WTH have you done to my thought processesā¦) ā this is the perfect opportunity for another villain option. 
Cheers!
6 Likes
Yeah, i am planning for my MC to pull a Billy Butcher on him. With a crowbar and all.
4 Likes
Now fully available!
Just FYI there isnāt a skip to the latest chapter. I havenāt had the work time to create that. But! You can restart the latest chapter with alternate variables which will allow you to see a lot of the differences, so thereās that.
(the big one is of course whether or not you actually caught Rocket)
24 Likes
Awww, and saves are bust, crap. 
(Also, for some reason everyone and their dog decided to pile up their updates onto the last days of May. Fuc..ā¦iiiine, like I need a weekend anyway. 
)
6 Likes
@izzily haha dog
2 Likes
Hi, Iāve noticed in the latest update in the variation where you killed both Cannibal and the civilians, a lot of the choices seem to be bugged?
I think it has something to do with the fact that my relationship score with Mallory is in the negative, because the error message I keep getting says: āinterocket line 3254: Canāt fairAdd to non-percentile value: -13ā
Iāve noticed the bug with the following choices (there might be some Iāve missed):
Summary
āCannibal was too dangerous. It was my only optionā.
āTruthfully, Iām starting to have doubtsā.
āWeāre villains. What is their damn problem?ā
āI made a mistakeā
āI made a mistake. [Lie]ā
āTell her sheāll rot hereā
āEmphasise the pain sheās in forā
āIāll kill herā
āI can live with thatā
āAdvocate for Rocket: we already beat her entire gangā
āAdvocate for Rocket: the DPR are the real enemy hereā
āYeah, Wyrdās rightā
āUnless we put an end to her right nowā
āSpeak against Rocket: it may bite us if we donāt deal with her nowā
3 Likes
Oh lmao, I forgot about flat minuses to relationship causing issues. Iāll get that fixed.
(Specifically I messed up my failsafe for preventing it going under 0)
6 Likes
Does eating spring breaker give her powers to the MC?
4 Likes
No tragically, that would be a net positive of her existence and she is unable to do that
7 Likes
Guys, what do you think would be the best weakness for a Jason Todd/Robin character? I STILL canāt make up my mind lol. I know I want him to use hand to hand combat, and for power speciality, idkā¦ I usually do carapace but idk if bullet sponging is the most interesting dynamic for him lol
2 Likes
I remember reading that Dion may become a RO if we ever get a second book. Is that still considered? Because I was going to romance Teddie but Dion kinda started stealing the show haha
3 Likes
Ya, but donāt let it stop you from doing other RO routes because there will be some shenanigans that may or may not cause some RO to not be accessible in the second book (if it happens)
5 Likes
BE WHO YOU AREEEEE hum but yeah I think you should do martial arts and carapaces #work
3 Likes
Not ominous at all haha Still going to check Teddie and Wil routes in the meanwhile. I had a lot of fun playing the demo ^^
2 Likes
just cheat on them
5 Likes
Thank you for the feedback, and sorry it took this long to acknowledge! I appreciate you taking that much time.
I choose to start the next scene in media res to spare yet another briefing scene. I did try my best to sprinkle in context as I went, so perhaps that could have used some more juice.
The very first choice in Ch12 is actually an opportunity to calibrate personality slightly rather than a skill check. They nudge instinctive one way or the other (or keep it the same). Truthfully Iām not 100% what you mean as the changes in text based on personality values, Iād think represent how youāve been playing the character?
I generally prefer to use selectable_if just as a like, signal to people of āhey, there are different options here if youād done other stuff!ā
The justified part is cause that option is intended to be a ākilling Cannibal because they killed civiliansā, but the point is taken.
While you can avoid getting actually nabbed by Insider, heās zeroing in on Dime regardless in the cafĆ©. I could maybe adjust the text slightly to make it a āpresumableā thing, but I did think it was relatively clear that Insider had narrowed it down.
This is diabolical and I kind of wish Iād thought of it because tragically Iāve now built a bunch of assumptions into how that shakes out that make it kind of impossible to have that as an option 
10 Likes
Izzily, your secretary is promoting cheating on ROs!
Granted, I did too, 
5 Likes
Itās false advertisement is what it is. I tried in the last playthrough, but the game wonāt let me. 
2 Likes