Choice of Rebels: Stormwright (XoR2 WIP)

Oop. Hard to keep all the snippets straight lol, completely forgot about that one.

Yknow, there’s a lot of potential I think in speccing into bombings as a rebel group here. They’re a very dramatic tool, and one outside of the context of most citizens of the Hegemony. I imagine detonating some government building in Grand Shayard must seem like something akin to magic, and yet distinctly un-theurgical.

10 Likes

Mind you, this isn’t as useful for a victorious land-holding rebel group, since bombings are not a field combat tactic and black powder is utterly useless in a conflict with Theurges. It’s a trivial Change to make the stuff follow its telos.

5 Likes

You’re welcome. Sorry for not being more active; some of it is real life stuff (caregiving older relatives, day job)…and some of it is also trying to get back to some ideas working on and getting into shape some ideas I was going to work Eiwynn about. The latter was a bit tougher than expected.

9 Likes

Will there be any opportunities in book 2 to spread knowledge of theurgy, it would be interesting if Yebben were to do this on his own. I assume a high degree of literacy in your followers would help there

4 Likes

After reading through all the various discussions on state-building and blood economics and demography, I had a flash of inspiration for my main MC’s future country and how it would be governed. I’ve made a map representing my ideal maximalist vision for it in all of its arrogant ambition and naivety, I hope you enjoy! (The image quality got compressed, the link has a higher quality version).

  • “Syneidesis” is a fancier name for the Inner Voice religion
  • Arden Oakfell is the name of my helot MC
  • Higher Quality Version
24 Likes

I’ve been doing more research on the different political and philosophical schools of stateless peoples like the Kurds recently and it brought to mind some of the groups in XOR. How would something like Öcalan’s Democratic Confederalism go over with nomadic and stateless groups like the Brecklander’s, Xaos Nomads and the Qasqer Zhuj/Nyrish pastoralists?

8 Likes

Helots are arguably another example of a somewhat stateless group as they live in fear of any official attention and seem to for practical purposes be governed by elders

6 Likes

Wow, I remember playing Uprising when I was a tween. Every so often when I’d browse the CoG store I’d check back in to see if the next game was out, and I was vibrating with anticipation when I realized a demo of Stormwright out. The Xaos lands were really fun, and honestly lived up to what I had imagined all those years ago when the tantalizing hint of what lay beyond the wards was brought up in Uprising. I also wondered if we’d meet Sarcificer the Goete in the Xaos Lands, back when I had finished Uprising, and meeting Cerlotta now is really really cool.

Irduin is also fantastic, trying to stir up revolt among the yeomen and helots is awesome, and it’s filled with tense moments (esp if you’re bad at managing suspicion lol). It’s depressingly realistic to the real world where the folk at the utmost bottom, and those only one step above simultaneously have so much in common, and yet can be divided easily too. “the helot’s need to be put in their place, because if they’re not at the bottom then what does that make us?” and “the yeomen have is much easier than us, so why are they complaining about their oppression? they should try being us for a change!”, it’s so realistic to the way people irl act, and yhea my MC is kinda putting his hands on his head in frustration with them lol.

Really, Irduin presents a very interesting moral dilemma. Two things stood out to me, the healing of the helot mother with lyssa and the fact that de Irde is actively working to prevent helot deaths. It really makes you think that de Irde might be “one of the good ones”. We’ll see if she’s willing to throw her lot in with a rebellion that’s so far been about total equality.

The ability to trans your gender in the second instalment of a series is really unique, and allows for some very interesting explorations of trans-ness that other works can’t do. As a trans person myself, it’s really cool that my MC can literally evolve with me. My “female” helot from all those years ago can now realize she’s actually a he just like I did!

I literally only have one criticism, and thats that I feel like your Xaos companion feels like they don’t impact the story very much. It feels a bit unlikely that Breden (or any other person), person who helped start the Rim Uprising, and who had strong opinions on the direction of the rebellion, wouldn’t do more to effect Irduin. That being said, it both looks like there’s still some content to be added with respect to your companions, and also it would add to the scope bloat this series is already suffering under. You can bring way too many different people into the Xaos land’s to make writing totally unique stuff for each of them feasible, I’d imagine.

That being said, I really do hope we get to learn more about my beloved Breden (seriously, I replayed Uprising and found myself just as hopelessly in love with Breden as I was when I was a tween lol), and the mystery of the traitor. I’m almost certain now that Breden wasn’t the traitor, and certainly if they ever were they aren’t now (my pet theory is that they could have been blackmailed), but that means that I’m even more curious about their past.

All that to say… this is AWSOME!

15 Likes

As much as you’re willing to answer, which would do more to spread your claim/grow your legend as an Eclect? Going back to the camps (where there’s some ingame text that makes note of your beliefs spreading), or winning a battle against the hegemony to provide ‘proof’ of divine guidance?

Separately, will it be possible to transition into a non-violent movement from a previously violent rebellion? I noticed one of the takeaways you can have in game two regarding the events of the end of game one is that violence is not the proper ground to fight the hegemony on. How would a violent resistance be able to transition properly into a nonviolent one, since even a low anarchy run would be known to the public to have caused some measure of casualties? I feel like once you’ve crossed that bridge into an intentionally violent movement, its hard to walk it back

Hope everyone has had a wonderful April so far!

7 Likes

Interestingly enough, the helots’ reaction to your Eclecthood claim is described as being pretty polarized and lukewarm: some helots vehemently reject you because they perceive it as blasphemy, while the rest are still cautious even when they accept your rebels.

The first outlaws you send back to the Rim are some of your most passionate devotees, bringing not just the word of rebellion but a call to follow the rebel Eclect. The idea that the Angels have Chosen an earthly leader outside the priesthood is polarizing; some helots immediately throw out your followers, shouting that the last thing they need is blasphemers as well as rebels. But rather more are cautiously curious…and your small outlaw groups find a temporary home, and your legend grows.

This is entirely speculation on my end, but I suspect that infiltrating the camps will spread your claim as Eclect far more (you’re reaching thousands more helots in the camps), but also require you to work harder to see it accepted among the helots relative to if you had a battle victory to wave around as a sign of the Angels’ blessing. This is the part where the extraordinarily charismatic Breden would be really useful… except for the part where Breden doesn’t believe you’re really Eclect and thinks Linos proclaimed you Eclect just to save his own life. Really frustrating, because Breden is incredibly valuable for this strategy to the point where they match even a 2 CHA MC in convincing the helot camps to accept your coveys. So I anticipate there’s going to be some tension where Breden isn’t enthusiastic about supporting your Eclect claim in the helot camps, and you have to find some other way to get your credibility up without a dramatic battle victory.

10 Likes

Hello, I know that by this point the test version has reached chapter 2 and beyond but still, would someone comment their thoughts on what exactly do you think the Xaos Storm origin is?

2 Likes

all pre hegemonic nations had some level of theurgy, from what we see of black stone buildings theurgy that was used in former Xaos lands was very advanced it probably had paralel development most likly they managed some things that even curent hegemony cant do, my guess is some theurgic ritual gone wrong(or right). most likly it was done as a way to stop/deter hegemonic invasion

2 Likes

Whew, sorry to have let this go for so long, everyone. And especially mshan, who’s been waiting over a month. I’ve had some substantial speaking engagements (on the intersection of politics, history, and religion); plus emergency thrice-weekly English tutoring sessions for an autistic teen who was kicked out of her school and has exams coming up in May; plus ten days of family trekking in the high Himal. (Up to here.) It’s been a good month, but a slow one for all things XoR.

But that changes from this week–starting with a catch-up on the thread.

@apple was right that the official “light treason” zones would be the main area where your scheme would struggle. If you want a big cosmopolitan empire not dominated by either party, that’s going to set up an unavoidable conflict with the Shayardene imperialist nationalists. The treason they’d be plotting wouldn’t stay “light.”

The domination of Wiendrj and Nyryal wouldn’t naturally fall on Erezza’s priority list, etiher. Not just Cerlota, but almost any Erezziano regime would be inclined to see those provinces as distractions from the all-important task of keeping Halassur at bay, and would prefer to see them left to their own devices. However much you try to demonize the western pagans and northern apostates, even the most fanatically Xthonist Erezzianos have a much more readily demonizable and threatening enemy to preoccupy them.

That said, keeping Shayard from trying to bite off chunks of western Erezza would be a significant secondary concern, and I suppose if the Erezziano thought the best way was encouraging Shayard to prey on other neighbors, they’d give it a thumbs up. They’d much prefer a Shayardene ally focused on naval war with Halassur, however, and you couldn’t expect them to commit their own forces (or governors) in significant numbers to imperialist adventures on Shayard’s other borders.

As for reducing the Seracca to a client state suitable for predatory Harrowing…don’t count on it. Disruption of the current trade relationship would be if anything more likely to have the opposite impact.

More likely she’d prefer the Pakistan vis-a-vis Afghanistan model of trying to keep neighbors weak and in chaos. Easier to do that in the name of threat reduction than to try to impose stable dictatorships in the name of resource extraction.

Not to run back to my favorite metaphor, but the carbon markets offer examples of this dynamic in our world, too.

And while it’s an interesting trend, the process of empires moving from “workshop” to “banker” takes place over a long enough timescale that I don’t think we’ll see it represented in this game. Even if you end up a near-immortal Theurge, the game isn’t going to play out over your whole lifespan–just long enough to bring us out of the immediate post-collapse period, with a new world (dis)order and some sense of the direction things are going. Not even sure if the prospect of being the “world’s workshop” is going to be on the table, let alone already having some inkling of what might follow.

Debating this with S is one of the most interesting ways I can flesh out the character, and I’m not going to set hard limits on how far they’ll move before I write out those debates. But as @Jaher notes, abolishing the nobility would be a devastatingly big shock to their worldview and values. Not sure that their ideals would ever carry them that far.

Needless to say, the stories circulating among the Norther Rim noblesse about the de Merre massacre don’t mention their abuses.

If they’re at all capable with swords, yes. If they’re not, they’d keep it hidden until someone who can use it well comes into a trusted top leadership role.

Yes, the soldier training from Korszata and seasoned insurgent training from Bethune should both make a difference in G2 rebellion capacity.

Absolutely! Some of those opportunities come as climaxes to the Irduin stuff I’m writing now; others I’ll add in once I’ve got the backbone of the story down.

I think that Öcalan’s vision is the kind of system a stateless group would fight for in a world already thoroughly dominated not just by states, but by nation-states. Nomads following an imperial collapse would mostly fight to keep a new state from coming into being on their turf in the first place.

@SilverOsbourne, so glad you’re enjoying Stormwright so far, and thanks for the encouraging words! I am indeed going to be adding more substantial arcs for each of the companions once I’ve finished writing the main plot, so I can have them responding to what’s going on around them and affecting the situation in Irduin. Hopefully you’ll find that more satisfying. :slight_smile: And we should get a little more about Breden’s past, too.

Probably going back to the camps. The victory in battle makes for a good miracle story, but a miraculous escape would do just fine, and the more people you’ve got to spread your stories, the more your legend will grow.

Yes – the ANC in South Africa offers a prominent example of how a movement can move into violence, then largely back into nonviolence, and ultimately prevail with the latter approach. That said, there are plenty of other examples of movements where the transition didn’t work, and you’ll certainly struggle more to keep nonviolent discipline and earn the trust of dissatisfied elites if you haven’t been consistent in your nonviolence.

Happy to! In Game 5, Wardfall.

14 Likes

Oh, damm. I should have seen that coming? Very well, now I have another question: do you it necessary for players to discover this origin, or is it fully optional with no greater impact in this game?

5 Likes

so we do somhow know that MC may try to restore hegemony, yes its not good idea for like 1000 of reasons but question i have is how would anyone would go about it from practical standpoint. who would be support base for that endevour? harowing is here to stay so no helot rebelion, i dont think any of yomen really care about it so they are out, 2 main sharyad noble factions should also not be too keen on that and even if you somhow manage to convince them i doubt they actualy have strength to achive that (i think it may be possible with leaguers? + phadea alliance) .
Only factions that i can really see going for it are merchants, silent noble majority, and priests + hegemonic remnants and theurges as long there powers dont get curtailed . at least thats my best guess :thinking:

i should do it as helot that romances calea she would make great empress

2 Likes

which paths in Irduin will lead to that

2 Likes

It’ll be interesting when we tell him.

4 Likes

When choosing the yeomen as main focus Odier Murager thinks MC is a rebel despite having 0 Suspicion and 99 Unity. (“She doesn’t always speak out against the de Irde. But with all her suspicious behavior and the trouble she’s left in her wake… I think we know who sent her.”) - Is this a bug? I think I picked one option where MC is not happy with the de Irde, otherwise I picked the “protect” option.

3 Likes

When talking to M’kyar in Sojourn, choosing the option “What do you mean by spirits?” In the Hegemony, the word is really only used to mean morale sometimes leads to an error, although I’m not able to consistently replicate it on different playthroughs.

5 Likes

Odd! All the indents there are contingent on int checks; I don’t suppose you know whether your playthroughs with one or another int score correlated with getting that error?

I’m going to go ahead and make an if/else block out of the first indented section in case that’s where things are falling out.

5 Likes