Whew, sorry to have let this go for so long, everyone. And especially mshan, who’s been waiting over a month. I’ve had some substantial speaking engagements (on the intersection of politics, history, and religion); plus emergency thrice-weekly English tutoring sessions for an autistic teen who was kicked out of her school and has exams coming up in May; plus ten days of family trekking in the high Himal. (Up to here.) It’s been a good month, but a slow one for all things XoR.
But that changes from this week–starting with a catch-up on the thread.
@apple was right that the official “light treason” zones would be the main area where your scheme would struggle. If you want a big cosmopolitan empire not dominated by either party, that’s going to set up an unavoidable conflict with the Shayardene imperialist nationalists. The treason they’d be plotting wouldn’t stay “light.”
The domination of Wiendrj and Nyryal wouldn’t naturally fall on Erezza’s priority list, etiher. Not just Cerlota, but almost any Erezziano regime would be inclined to see those provinces as distractions from the all-important task of keeping Halassur at bay, and would prefer to see them left to their own devices. However much you try to demonize the western pagans and northern apostates, even the most fanatically Xthonist Erezzianos have a much more readily demonizable and threatening enemy to preoccupy them.
That said, keeping Shayard from trying to bite off chunks of western Erezza would be a significant secondary concern, and I suppose if the Erezziano thought the best way was encouraging Shayard to prey on other neighbors, they’d give it a thumbs up. They’d much prefer a Shayardene ally focused on naval war with Halassur, however, and you couldn’t expect them to commit their own forces (or governors) in significant numbers to imperialist adventures on Shayard’s other borders.
As for reducing the Seracca to a client state suitable for predatory Harrowing…don’t count on it. Disruption of the current trade relationship would be if anything more likely to have the opposite impact.
More likely she’d prefer the Pakistan vis-a-vis Afghanistan model of trying to keep neighbors weak and in chaos. Easier to do that in the name of threat reduction than to try to impose stable dictatorships in the name of resource extraction.
Not to run back to my favorite metaphor, but the carbon markets offer examples of this dynamic in our world, too.
And while it’s an interesting trend, the process of empires moving from “workshop” to “banker” takes place over a long enough timescale that I don’t think we’ll see it represented in this game. Even if you end up a near-immortal Theurge, the game isn’t going to play out over your whole lifespan–just long enough to bring us out of the immediate post-collapse period, with a new world (dis)order and some sense of the direction things are going. Not even sure if the prospect of being the “world’s workshop” is going to be on the table, let alone already having some inkling of what might follow.
Debating this with S is one of the most interesting ways I can flesh out the character, and I’m not going to set hard limits on how far they’ll move before I write out those debates. But as @Jaher notes, abolishing the nobility would be a devastatingly big shock to their worldview and values. Not sure that their ideals would ever carry them that far.
Needless to say, the stories circulating among the Norther Rim noblesse about the de Merre massacre don’t mention their abuses.
If they’re at all capable with swords, yes. If they’re not, they’d keep it hidden until someone who can use it well comes into a trusted top leadership role.
Yes, the soldier training from Korszata and seasoned insurgent training from Bethune should both make a difference in G2 rebellion capacity.
Absolutely! Some of those opportunities come as climaxes to the Irduin stuff I’m writing now; others I’ll add in once I’ve got the backbone of the story down.
I think that Öcalan’s vision is the kind of system a stateless group would fight for in a world already thoroughly dominated not just by states, but by nation-states. Nomads following an imperial collapse would mostly fight to keep a new state from coming into being on their turf in the first place.
@SilverOsbourne, so glad you’re enjoying Stormwright so far, and thanks for the encouraging words! I am indeed going to be adding more substantial arcs for each of the companions once I’ve finished writing the main plot, so I can have them responding to what’s going on around them and affecting the situation in Irduin. Hopefully you’ll find that more satisfying.
And we should get a little more about Breden’s past, too.
Probably going back to the camps. The victory in battle makes for a good miracle story, but a miraculous escape would do just fine, and the more people you’ve got to spread your stories, the more your legend will grow.
Yes – the ANC in South Africa offers a prominent example of how a movement can move into violence, then largely back into nonviolence, and ultimately prevail with the latter approach. That said, there are plenty of other examples of movements where the transition didn’t work, and you’ll certainly struggle more to keep nonviolent discipline and earn the trust of dissatisfied elites if you haven’t been consistent in your nonviolence.
Happy to! In Game 5, Wardfall.