What is the general process for beta-testing a game?


I’ve kind of been dreading the beta-testing part of the creation process, and I’m not really sure how to get started.

In my poking around I found the Beta Testing category, but I was hoping to get some advice on best practice so I don’t do it wrong.

Any suggestions?

Thanks in advance!


Well, it you want to do a public beta, first you want to put up a publicly accessible demo on Dashingdon. Then just make a thread here on the forums! Tell everyone a bit about your story…maybe if you’re looking for feedback on specific areas mention that.

If you want to do a private beta then put up a thread with info and ask for volunteers.

There’s really no wrong way to do things! :slight_smile:

Polls can also be very helpful - you can ask stuff like ‘For Important Choice, did you choose A, B, or C?’ and use that to see if anything’s unbalanced. They’re good for getting a response from shyer readers.


One of the best things you can do is to ask your beta testers what you would like them to pay closest attention to. I think it’s way more important to ask for story and continuity things than microlevel issues. Small issues of style and syntax are important, but not nearly as important as the large stuff like “does this character work?” or “is this scene coming out as touching as I hope?” If you are going to end up doing large-scale revising of a scene anyhow, it won’t matter if a word is spelled wrong.


Just wanted to say that the terms beta-testing, private-testing, and alpha-testing are similar but different. The definition goes by this:

Private testing: A testing that takes place privately
Alpha testing: A testing on the alpha-build of a product (usually games)
Beta testing: A testing on the beta-build of a product


Welcome to the CoG writing and readers community forum. Most of us are both writers and readers, so you’ll see both open WiP (Work in Progress) threads from us and us volunteering as beta readers.

There are two different beta processes - the first is the official process if you are writing a story under the CoG label - that is covered in the contract and such that CoG would send out to you but basically, your project manager will set it up and run it for you. @Gower is a published author here, so he can go into more details of this beta process then I, who is writing for the contest or publishing under the HG label like @Scribblesome is.

For most of us, setting up a “public” thread for basic communication in the sub forum HG WiP is the first step. In this thread you can present your project for the initial feedback most of desire before green-lighting it. Some of our hopeful authors are on this stage of their projects.

The next step is the step @Scribblesome and I are on and that is presenting your green-lit project to a group of beta readers. Scribblesome has chosen to present a public “demo” that they first put on Dashingdon web hosting - a free service for the community (a treasure really) and which they update with regular rewrites, revisions or with new material.

Another approach, which is the one I took, is to solicit volunteers for a private beta session(s) which you open a private thread involving only those you invite to it. You then present your work and have the volunteers beta it.

In both of the above cases, you can ask for what CoG classifies as “low-level” feedback and “high-level” feedback. Low level feedback is the English 101 feedback, including: editing, grammar and such things as structure and spelling. High level feedback is the stuff @Gower mentions: the continuity, character development, mechanics and such.

The public threads can stay open as long as you are actively pursuing the project (they automatically close if the project has no activity for three months) and are ready to submit the game for publication. I think our record is the recently published Choice of Rebels by @Havenstone at 6 years. He is an advocate for the open public testing and can answer most anything asked.

The private threads stay open until you close them or “archive” them. I suggest keeping up on the housecleaning aspects if you go this route - having multiple private testing threads open can be confusing - I speak from experience here.

Now that I given you a wall of text I will end by saying Welcome once more. We all look forward to your project. I also have some links for beginners I can provide if you desire them.


Alpha and beta testing are nebulous terms that mean different things to different communities and different publishers. Here, they are really mashed into one category for the HG label and the process is broken up by the author/developer.

For the CoG label (outside of the contest) the process is different. The alpha stage is the per-production phase where you submit an outline, etc to the CoG team and they work with you on getting things green-lit. This continues all the way up through and includes copy-editing and an eventual “official” beta from CoG being presented to the community.


Hoh. So that means our usual HG WIP phase is even “earlier” than alpha phase? :thinking:

No. In gaming an alpha phase is where the development team puts together a “slice of life” proof of concept. This means the developers build a portion of the game to prove to the publisher that their ideas and concepts will work. In Mass Effect:Andromeda they built a planet with missions and open terrain to showcase how everything would work for the player exploring.

With the CoG label - this is like the outline and pitch that the author gives to CoG that convinces them your idea works.

With the HG projects here - like I said above, everything is sort of mashed together.


Wow! Thanks for all the information. I like walls of text, so I totally appreciate it! :stuck_out_tongue:

Yes please on the links, that would be amazing.

1 Like


Oh, thank you for bringing this up. I’m not sure I would have thought of it!

1 Like


Thank you for suggestions, they’re very helpful! :smile:

I know the question isn’t aimed to me, :raised_hand_with_fingers_splayed:t4: but here is the link

Feel free to ask for new stuff on that thread, if you feel something need to be covered

1 Like