I really think The Hero Unmasked is underrated. But it may just be that it came out before I got involved in the forums and I missed the love for it. But it’s one I replay pretty often. I really like the supporting characters and the different ways I can play my MC. I would definitely buy a sequel!
As far as underrated WIPs, I don’t think The Porthecrawl Witness is getting nearly the attention it deserves. It’s fantastic, and I’m more attached to the characters and my MC for that game than any other. It’s a romantic occult mystery and I LOVE IT.