Choice of Rebels: Stormwright (XoR2 WIP)

That’s a tricky question to answer. :slight_smile: For the past couple months I’ve found myself at absolute max worldbuilding in terms of time investment–the most time I’ve spent on that since I started writing the game 12-13 years ago. But that’s exceptional, and there’s a reason for it.

XoR is a game about trying to change the system of the world. If I were writing it as a novel, I’d be a lot readier to paint that system in super broad strokes, just enough to bring out my chosen key themes. But that’s not good enough for an IF, where a reader who can’t recreate the Empire of Man or a democratic utopia by the end of G5 needs to feel that there are reasons inherent to the world standing in their way, not just the author’s aesthetic whim; and that while the world model is based on the author’s choices, those choices make sense within the relevant historical parallels, with fantastic differences that follow from the logic and limits of the magic system.

I’ve never been the kind of writer who poured huge amounts of time into worldbuilding (or character history) for its own sake. In general, if it’s not going to show up on the page, I don’t put much time into it. I don’t really enjoy having a big folder of endlessly ramified worldbuilding material. The problem with a game like XoR (or like the Infinity Saga, which is similarly about a whole sociopolitical/military world and how it can or can’t be changed) is that so much more ultimately has to be on the page. Not for every player, but for the ones who are intent on pushing the world in a particular direction.

I could get away with a lot of worldsketching so far, since I’ve been writing the periphery of the world system. Everything from now on is going to be immersing the MC in the wider world, and especially with Grand Shayard, I need to be setting up things that will have G5 endgame payoffs. So I’ve been doing the big worldbuilding push, looking at how the current Thaumatarchy holds itself together, how it would be transformed in the absence of MC intervention, and what the parameters are going to be for the MC’s new regime.

That will let me finalize my outline for the remaining G2 – at which point the balance will shift decisively toward the script. I doubt I’ll ever worldbuild as intensively for any project as I have for this one over the past year. :slight_smile:

27 Likes

@Havenstone I’ve been wondering how possible my two main runs are.

The first is the Permanent Revolutionary. She is Ruth/Skep/Cosmo helot and will fully devote into Com as the books continue. Her goal is to break the power of the Hegemony and the nobles and free every helot. She never wants to rule. She is fine leading rebellions and commanding troops but the further away she gets from the rim the more uncomfortable she will get with leading. Believing that people local to the area should be the ones to lead their movements. If all the helots are freed, and the nobles destroyed, then instead of settling down she will shift her focus to undermine autocracy, hierarchical societies, harrower states, and imperialist powers. If the ex-hegemonic lands settle and there are no more fights to be had, she will look to Hallasar to see if there are any movements brewing against their empire and offer her assistance.

The second is the Dragon Empress. She is Comp/Skep/Cosmo aristo and will either fully devote into Int or favor it while having some Cha. It depends if she can become immortal or not without full Int. She is genuinely kind but unbeknownst to herself or anyone else for that matter, super power hungry. Her end goal is to auto-Plektast into her family crest, a dragon, obtain immortality and rule over the entirety of the Hegemony for eternity. Her dream for her empire is supporting local cultures of her empire; probably working with Pheadrx; enacting land reform using Laconnier, and Loyalist land; putting down any Leaguers that get uppity about that; building a bureaucracy to help replace nobility; having local democracies that are beholden to her; standardizing the code of laws so that on paper everyone should be equal before the law, except her of course, or to put it more artistically, all are equal before the Dragon; Maintaining the current border with Hallasur; If Hallasur ever starts to fragment, invade; expand into the Xaos lands, annexing Sojourn; further diplomatic ties with the Seracca; and finally, the stretch goal that will take place well after the books, conquer the world. I feel like this will be very risky and the Empire she builds will be extremely brittle but can her empire survive long enough to stabilize.

Edit: Whoops, forgot some things for the Dragon Empress. Blood tax, secularize the government, and expanding the knowledge of theurgy to more people, maybe even opening it to everyone.

Thought I’d ask before the end of the current deep dive into world building.

5 Likes

You’ll be able to realize a lot of both characters’ aspirations.

There will never be a point in the game when all the territories in a fragmented ex-Hegemony are free from aristocratic/autocratic domination (the Permanent Revolutionary will end the game with plenty of dragons left to slay along the horizon, and some that have sprung up behind them). A dictator-empress is not going to succeed in having “local democracies” as the basic building block of her realm. Expanding the knowledge of Theurgy is going to make it pretty much impossible to establish meaningful sovereignty over anything above a medium-large territory (e.g. greater Aveche or Rim plus upper Southriding). And of course your Dragon Empress is not really going to rule for eternity, any more than Hera did; but the game may well end before the brittleness of a big empire causes it to re-collapse, so you can close with the (manifestly unlikely) dream of an immortal empire still intact.

All in all, more of your visions should be realizable than non-realizable – though of course anything I say now is subject to change over the coming years as I write the games. :slight_smile:

10 Likes

Hmmm…my mc would want local democracy because rejecting aristocratic blood nonsense or divine blessing means (theoretical) popular sovereignty is likely to be the formal, de-jure basis of state legitimacy. Plus spread of (self-sacrifice) theurgy (of particular necessity with the western option since self-sacrifice lessens the need for the scarce quicksilver that would be a major issue with the western option) as well as to make enslaving the population much more difficult, depending on how it goes he may want to keep the deeper mysteries somewhat restricted but also a realm that is big enough and strong enough to not have to entertain cooperation with things like “fugitive slave acts” from backwards and repressive neighbours and of course whether in the east or the west, though as of late you have succeeded in making the western option seem more appealing, particularly if that can get lowland Wiendrj with all that water power potential included, as an option. My mc would also still want to be a two ocean power, so he’ll need at least one good northern port to be his Vladivostok.

The western option might also have a way towards better relations with Halassur even if it is in exchange for the ward tech it might even be able to move towards actual trade and diplomacy but in that case in addition to abiding by no reintroduction of slavery in any of their western conquests they’d also have to cease their support for the Laconnier rebels.

Would also be ironic if that sort of deal ultimately accomplishes what a crusader state would not, democratization of Halassur itself, whether that happens the soft way with some sort of constitutional monarchy or the hard way with some sort of democratic revolution.

4 Likes

Spreading the knowledge of Theurgy will definitely make slavery much less stable and sustainable as an institution. It will for the same reasons make it much easier for local warlords and “free cities” to resist the expansion of your rule.

Both promotion of local-level democracy in your realm and broadcasting the world’s most powerful technology to the masses will weaken the MC’s ability to act as an unchecked sovereign. You can still choose to be an authoritarian (to make sure the people don’t pick the wrong things) but not on any large scale, if you’ve taken serious steps that empower people at village and town level.

13 Likes

Well you did mention the Nepal assembly type thing that seems naturally suited to political tutelage since it potentially allows mc and a few others to keep a heavy thumb on the scale, particularly at the higher levels that the majority of the population don’t directly interact with anyway and are thus less visible to them, at least so long as there is not a mass media revolution, aka newspapers. But, yes, it is a tradeoff and it will likely constrain my mc’s ability for an unbridled cultural revolution, so we’ll see in the next couple of years if the tradeoffs are worth it.

Self-sacrifice theurgy that is, if he can my mc will try to keep the knowledge of the higher mysteries at least somewhat contained and restricted, made easier by the simple fact that people endowed with the kind of brainpower to perform them also become progressively more scarce. In the western option it may also help that quicksilver is scarce there and my mc would have a heavy interest in controlling the supply of it with a strong state monopoly, like the Romans used to have on salt.

Yes, like the early US the tradeoff of possibly making a two ocean power that way will mean my mc would have to heavily compromise on including actual, federal aspects and indeed less control from the center than he would instinctively like.

6 Likes

Can’t we all just get along (by agreeing that vile Karagon is to blame for everything)?

10 Likes

@Havenstone Up thread there was a bit of discussion about land reform and I’ve been wondering if there’s going to be any difficulty in transitioning Helots from working large estates to working smaller individual plots. Whilst the basics are still the same small hold farmers tend to need to prioritise different things compared to larger estates. This is especially true if a potbof the blood based augmentation of yields is reduced, putting the new small holders far more at the mercy of the weather than the large estates.

I can’t help but fear this may lead to a situation where a few painful years as the helots transition to small holders. Perhaps some type of Yeoman led educational program could help bridge the gap.

3 Likes

By local democracies I meant elections for local community leaders in smaller settlements. Hoping it will free up some state capacity. If the is not feasible, is it possible to have a mostly advisory diet made of ‘elected’ members, have a free press, as well as a constitution the defines the state’s role in governance. Basically have an authoritarian empire, but hopefully have enough institutions that allow people to address their grievances. Hoping that the majority of those that oppose the new regime don’t feel the need to partake in armed revolt.

3 Likes

Jumping back to catch up on some earlier questions:

I’m going to hold off on trying to give comprehensive answers on those for a while yet. Some of that will become clearer as I write the rest of G2.

No, the 88% is just the ratio of total adult aristos to total annual Harrowings under the current regime. I’m not going to run the detailed math on an aristo genocide right now, because you’ll never really have the chance to do it Hegemony-wide (an MC who starts would either never reach or swiftly lose their continent-scale realm). As and when you try to do it in the territory you do control in G4 or 5, you’d get a pretty variable range of nobles depending on a bunch of factors. (And de Firiac would be only one of the many Pimpernels trying to help them escape Madame le Harrower).

Depends on your tastes. Nothing along the epic dark magic dimension, no. But I hope Azthyme is right that it’ll still feel pretty epic. :slight_smile:

It’s a transition plan, and one where the faction will be ready to shift back to other means depending on how things develop.

Yeah, that’s what I figured would be the majority reaction. Especially since losing Ennearch Ocharsis, the archmage responsible for the Lykeion, will be a harder hit to the Hegemony than any other single Ennearch other than Thaïs.

Something like that could probably be achieved, yes. Bringing in part of Erezza on equal terms into a “triarchy” would be more of a challenge.

I won’t say a hard no, but I’m not currently planning to write one. :slight_smile: Let’s see where the story goes.

When it comes to land reform and justice, you have a choice: satisfy the aristos at the helots’ expense, satisfy the helots at the aristos’ expense, or try to walk a middle road that upsets all of them while (hopefully) keeping the level of discontent manageable. “Wealth loss” or fear of reduced yields would not be the aristos’ first objection to your reform schemes; land isn’t just the primary means of production, it’s the cornerstone of their social status and power. You couldn’t pay them enough for losing that. Restorative justice, much as I personally love it, is not going to satisfy Kalt, and most aristoi would still experience it as a painful humiliation.

Jev likes the status quo and certainly wouldn’t want to see Nyrish nomadic pastoralism die out. O would like to see a sustainable nomad population on the plains, coexisting and commingling with a vibrant urban culture. But o’s least preferred future would be a Nyryal dominated by a brutally extractive nomad faction whose Theurgic elite developed a predatory version of the pastoralist ethos over decades of deployment in the military zone on the Erezza-Halassur border. You might get to hang out with them in G4 Ch1 and see what you think.

Like Gorbachev, she’s trying to reform the Hegemony to save it, and would be open to cautious liberalizing reforms if she believed they might help in that cause. (The majority of Ennearchs are more like Brezhnev, trying to save the empire with rigidity and repressiveness.) Phaedra has limited scope to implement most of her reforms in G3-G4 – the Diadoche is a future power-holder, not the current one – so unlike Gorbachev won’t be blamed too much for the collapse of the old order, and will have the opportunity to really come into her own once the Hegemony has at least half-collapsed.

I assume you mean if you stood, fought, and won? It depends on what you consider “significant.” It will make a lot of people more excited about your rebellion, and others more fearful. It will make the Keriatou look better and (all else being equal) help them establish a firmer grip on the Outer Rim, rather than being displaced by the Pelematou. It gets your followers more arms.

Any rebellion that doesn’t want to lock in deference to Karagon and oppression for the helotry will need to make changes to the current Codex of Laws. You can try to promulgate a whole new code, or just try to amend the most unhelpful bits of the current version. I’ve said I can’t give a lot more detail on that at the moment.

That is I think likely to be a feature of every single gameworld state. :slight_smile:

There definitely will be. It’s not an insoluble problem, but it is a significant one that will demand time and resource from a land reforming MC.

Promoting local elections would I think absorb state capacity rather than free it up. Your existing local social structure is aristocratic and patron-client based; if you want to free up state capacity, you ride on that, let the existing local elites be your agents, and build your own patronage network that includes them. Launching a system where the local elites have to periodically face a wider group of electors – even if that’s just the wider noble/merchant population, let alone the yeomanry, let alone the helotry – would have stability advantages in the medium to long run, but it would be destabilizing in the short run, and it would require a significant amount of state attention to keep that destabilization from turning violent.

Yes, various consultative councils and charters should be possible along those lines. They won’t stop a continent-scale empire from being visibly brittle and vulnerable to revolt at the end of the game; but they’ll be helpful at more manageable scales.

11 Likes

Is there going to be a way to reconcile at least part of the Keriatou family to an aristo-led Revolt (my gut says Callea is the most viable one) without pissing off the entirety of our Rimmer follower base?

11 Likes

Calea seems to have a lot of sociopathic traits to me, so I’m not expecting her to have enough loyalty to go down with a sinking ship. If she thinks that the Karagonds can really be gotten rid of and everything else will stay the same, I’d expect her to be on board.

I don’t think Hector is going to be able to get over how badly his cousin hurt his feelings by embarrassing his family that much.

6 Likes

You are right that Hector is in many ways, a big baby. It might be too late to mollify him before he throws a pro-Hegemony tantrum.

6 Likes

Man, seems like I’m unique in having no interest in spreading any kind of democracy through the post-rebellion Hegemony.


That said my Helot builds (2COM, 2CHA, and 2INT alike) WILL spread the secrets of Theurgy, mostly as a means to break down the Hegemony, without a care for what happens afterwards.

My Aristocrat builds will not, whether out of a desire to protect some semblance of order, or because they don’t want lowly Helots learning such things, will keep Theurgy secret.

7 Likes

@Havenstone Can we get cat ears as Seracca?

4 Likes

More importantly, @Havenstone can we discard all other wards and put all of the Hegemony’s theurgic might in the barrier that shields us from the Abhuman Federation i’m only half joking here

2 Likes

@Havenstone Hmm just thought about asking this (Since you are in a question answering mood about characters we know little about) what would Teren option be on the whole what to do about the system of Helot. I been a bit worried since you said they had high ruthlessness but since you can ro them as a Helot they can’t be too bad :pleading_face:?

3 Likes

Alas, I’m sure many of the people asking about Phaed would’ve rathered they be Brezhnev… in one specific regard.

So this is… not ideal, I’d agree with om there. But it would be oddly satisfying in a twisted kind of way for the Karagonds to be confronted with yet another monster of their own making. Once again, the Thaumatarchy poisons everything…


“before”, you say

Calea: 「 Hector hates you as he has hated nothing else in his life. He rails against you—and not just to the Hegemony’s servants or to Father. To his lovers. In his cups. He calls you death-leech and matriphage spider, feeding off the Keriatou all through your childhood and then trying to destroy us. 」

Imagine hooking up with the guy and in bed, he’s just ranting about this rebel in some deeply unsexy language. Who, in some versions of history, might be his ex. That’s like five red flags right there. Conclusion: nobody is Hector’s lover. Or, perhaps more precisely: nobody is Hector’s lover twice.

18 Likes

Hector does seem just a tad unstable. I wonder if one ending for him could be literal madness as things continue to get worse from his perspective.

6 Likes

Wait can someone remind me what the aristo MC’s relationship with Hector could be like?

I vaguely remember my MC had some sort of intense (and very petty) rivalry with him. So that’s one relationship state.

2 Likes