Choice of Rebels: Stormwright (XoR2 WIP)

Y’know, a lot of questions have been regarding best case scenario for our MC, their rebel movement, and the post-hegemony at large… but what’s the worst case you could see for the end-state of the world? I don’t mean “the MC’s rebellion fizzles out and fails to make an impact,” but a true “it DID have impact and you’ve created a hell on earth” scenario? Is it just going off the anarchy point of no return? Somehow letting a worse regime entrench itself post-hegemony? Doing something really fucky with the Xaos-storms? Some fourth option I’m not thinking of?

(This will inevitability lead to some players BadMaxxing their runs as a meme)

8 Likes

I feel called out

5 Likes

Imo it depends on how dropping the wards and toppling the hegemony actually goes. I think that combined with an outcome where Shayard gets stuck in it’s version of the Russian Civil War and ceases to function as a breadbasket for the rest of the continent would be absolutely disastrous for everyone.

4 Likes

“as a meme”

I also don’t know what exactly would be the worst of all worlds, though I can imagine quite a few possibilities. I suspect that total anarchy with Xaos-storm-induced mass starvation and active destruction of knowledge and culture, where power ends up in the hands of WMD-wielding blood warlords is a good starting point, but there is still hope to hold onto there. People will form communities to support each other. New ideas will form and spread. Maybe in the end, it’s still better than being a helot. And so long as that possibility for a better future exists, there’ll be people trying to reach it – and then that end-state suddenly isn’t a dead end anymore.

I could imagine a world of Theurgic vampire-lords: share the secrets of blood magic with only the cruelest, most vile aristocrats and shape them into a ruling class, enshrining in law their authority in their own small fief to kill and harvest cattle as they please. Let them learn to make Xaos-storms. Kill all the people who know how to make a Ward while we’re at it (there aren’t that many of them). Let them learn Hera’s trick to eternal youth and see how many woodchipped bodies they make in pursuit of immortality. If Theurgic surveillance really is possible, let them learn it: make the Kryptast nightmare real. The Hegemony is too concerned with stability, with holding onto its empire. It can’t be everywhere. But a thousand little Hegemonies? That would be a horrifying experience for some time – and yet would it last? I doubt it. Too vulnerable to consuming itself and to mass collective action. And the secret of Theurgy still hangs over it like a ticking bomb.

“The world” is perhaps too large a place to lose hope. But it can be easy, all too easy, to make a single part of it hell seemingly beyond hope: all that takes is overwhelming power and callous indifference (or support) from others who could stop it. Mass violence fueled by hate: hunt down every last person of this kind, in this land, destroy all they’ve created, never rest until absolute victory has been achieved. That’s an atrocity that could viably happen in the Rebels setting, maybe checked only by our capacity to gather such power if we were to go down that route. Living in an empire that commits such atrocities might be a hell in its own way, but it’s hardly comparable. For some people, it might even feel prosperous. Would it be better to live in, say, a transitional world where every person is a walking weapon capable of killing people with their minds and people haven’t yet figured out how to navigate these new power dynamics? As a detached reader, I might think so, but if I’m a citizen of that empire? There won’t be consensus there.

Overwhelming force is uniquely terrifying because of how it grinds all resistance beneath it. You can fight, but you can’t survive forever. You can run, but there is no going back. It cannot permit the existence of hope. In that way, it’s a somewhat stable evil, but it can’t be omnipresent. We might create pure hell in a time and place while the rest of the world carries on.

This mirrors, darkly, some discussions about what would be a happy ending for our rebels: a question of whether it’s right to carve out a smaller refuge where a better world might start even when there’s suffering and injustice beyond those borders, inverted.


On a lighter note, we could just try to destroy the world. I doubt we or anyone else would be able to replicate what made Vigil into a Storm-source, but if we could, say, in the heartlands of Shayard… well, that would be an impact for the history books.

15 Likes

I always play a pacifist MC — ending harrowing, power to the people, the whole package — but wow, that was all really interesting. It’s got me tempted to try the opposite. There are just so many ways to be a terrible person in this universe it’s honestly overwhelming. I’ll have to think things through before taking a stab at anything like a tyrannical theurge-lord or a straight-up burn-it-all-down type

4 Likes

My go too MC is an extremely ruthless Helot… who steadfastly refuses to harrow a soul, and who will stop at nothing to end slavery wherever it might be found. I think contrasting someone who is willing to lie, kill, torture, and worse with this rock-solid moral core makes for an interesting Choice of Rebel. A high anarchy playthrough doesn’t have to be one devoid of scruples.

11 Likes

Agreed. I think there’s merit to the idea that a more ruthless path could lead to less bloodshed later. The character I’m envisioning is more nihilistic, not concerned with morality, motivated by the pleasure of destruction or the domination of others. Basically a villain in a fairy-tale sense: a theatrical, larger-than-life charcater that has a certain dark allure or magnetism.

5 Likes

I was hoping to throw up a different snippet, but the bit I’m working on has been taking longer to finish than I’d planned… so here’s one possible outcome set for the Auche elopement, if you inform Alasais about it:

Summary

You’re within eyeshot of the stables on the day when Alastor Korren and lady Alasais abruptly walk down from the manor, and stride in after Auche. You slip @{(com > 1) noiselessly|casually} to a place where you can overhear them.

“You’ve built up a nice little cache of supplies here, lad.” Korren’s voice is dry. “Planning a trip that you haven’t told us about? For two, by the looks of it?”

Give the boy credit for poise; there’s only a slight edge of tension to his easy response. “I thought I’d ride out into the moors for a few days’ hunt, and wanted to be well-supplied in case we met a storm. Is there some danger I don’t know of there, Alastor?”

“Son.” Alasais sounds both stern and sad. “We already know the truth of what you’re planning.”

“Dama, I don’t know what you…”

“We know about your elopement. We know about Earith.”

Silence. Then: “I love her, Dama.” Auche’s voice is high and cracking. “I’m so sorry, but I cannot go east while she’s at risk here. If there were any way we could be together like the Captain and her sister, I’d take it, in a heartbeat. But we all know that’s not possible for us.”

“It’s not,” Korren agrees, frank but not unkind. “And nor is what you’re planning, lad. Not on the roads as they are these days. The two of you would be snapped up and we’d never be able to save you in time.” After a pause, he presses on with, “If you truly love her, if you truly want to protect her…”

“Don’t you dare tell me I need to let her go!” Auche snaps at the Alastor. “You, of all people!”

“I’d like some words alone with my son, Captain.” There’s a taut undercurrent to kuria Alasais’s otherwise level voice. “Could I ask you to make the rounds of the area and ensure there are no bats in the outer rafters?”
*choice
#@{brasquedeirde I already know the secret she’s about to share with him.|That’s it.} Time to slip away before I’m caught.
[…]
*selectable_if (com < 3) #I think I can evade Korren’s notice. I stay hidden where I am.
*label evadekornot
*if ((int < 2)
*set spyausc true
*if (int > 1) and not(spyausc)
You’re far enough away that even if he found you, he’d never believe you could hear the de Irdes.
*if (com = 3)
Even with your capacity for absolute stillness, there’s a good chance of being caught by an enforcer scouring the area for listeners. But the kuria’s gratitude should offer you some protection; and you could probably beat them all in a fight, if it comes to that.
*goto auchedrop_2
#@{(com = 3) I recognize the weakness of my hiding place,|I don’t know if I can evade him,} but since it was only by my spying that they’re here at all…I’ll take the risk of being found.
*goto evadekornot
*label auchedrop_2
You focus all your attention on the quiet conversation inside the stable, doing your best to ignore the searching Alastor.

“What you’re dreaming of is…unacceptable, son. Unthinkable.” Alasais sounds like she’s groping for the right handholds on a nearly-sheer slope.

“Unthinkable? You’ve always taught us to think of the helots as not so different from ourselves, Dama. That the de Irde way is to treat them with humanity…”

Not like this!” Her voice is all the more intense for being held to a low volume. “Angels, tell me you’ve not…that there’ll be no new children ensuing from this madness.”

“She’s not going to let herself fall pregnant, Dama. Not until we’re wed.” Auche’s voice is a rebellious growl.

Alasais’s breath bursts sharply, audibly, from her nostrils. “Your grandfather also assumed that helots ate mullow.”

Neither of them speaks for several drawn-out seconds. “What are you saying, Mother?”

“That this cannot be, for reasons that go well beyond what you think you know.” In the stunned silence that follows, you
*if (brasquedeirde)
lean forward, not wanting to miss the revelation.
*if not(brasquedeirde)
@{(korcyn > 0) remember Cynneve’s light eyes, and Agarie’s, and understand|realize} the foundation of the mutual trust between the de Irdes and Stallards.
“Earith is…not just any helot, son.”
*set brasquedeirde true
*page_break
*if spyausc
And then there are hands gripping both your shoulders, yanking you bodily away from the stable, and hurling you into the dusty grass nearby. You tumble away and come up into a @{(com < 2) clumsy|} defensive crouch. Korren’s eyes are blazing, even though he keeps his voice to a whisper. “@{(ird_sus > ird_sus_low) Always it’s your ears pressed to the wall, isn’t it|So what has you pressing your ears to this wall}, ${ird_name}?”

“Lady Alasais wasn’t displeased that I’d been keeping an eye on her son,” you gasp, tracing a cautious circle around the Alastor captain. “If I’d not listened, you’d not be here today—and the boy would be on his way out of Irduin.”

“So you think that makes you, what—the lady kuria’s spy-in-chief? You think she’ll be content that you were eavesdropping on her?” In a smooth, unhesitating motion, Korren draws his sword. “Stay where you are, ${girl}. We’ll ask her.”
*label alkorcaughtch
*choice
*hide_reuse #“Did you hear what she told him?” I demand. “Do you know the secret that could get the Stallards killed?”
*set alkorc 1
“I don’t eavesdrop on milady.” Korren’s tone is bleak. “Breaking trust with her would do a lot more damage than whatever you’ve weaseled out.”

“It affects your Cynneve just as much as it does Earith…”

“One more word and I’ll run you through, ${girl}.”
*goto alkorcaughtch
#I can’t risk Alasais learning that I overheard her family’s connection to Brasque. I @{(com > 1) fight my way free and flee|flee from the Alastor captain and} Irduin.
*if (com > 1)
*label forkfight
Out of the corner of your eye, you see a hayfork leaning against the stable wall. Lunging too fast for Korren to prevent, you snatch it up—barely in time to catch his sword blow between its twin iron prongs.

The Alastor captain pulls back before you can disarm him, then circles you with a @{(alkorc = 4) growing fear. Not only does this make your claims more plausible, but he|new wariness. He} didn’t come armored today, thinking he’d only be stopping a boy’s elopement. “Drop the fork, ${alias}. Before you do anything even the lady kuria won’t forgive.”

“We might already be past that point, Captain.” You keep your voice hard, swallowing both your rue at being caught and your worry that one more hard blow might break your tool’s untempered iron. @{(sralibi = 4) “And you know I could kill you with this, so don’t try me.”|“And be warned—I could kill you with this. Don’t force me.”}

The clash of metal has brought the two de Irdes out of the stable. Auche gapes at you for a confused moment until lady Alasais thrusts him behind her. You don’t think there are any readily improvisable weapons in her reach, but the former Phalangite looks ready to tear you apart with her bare hands. “How dare you assault my captain, ${ird_name}? What by Xaos do you think you’re doing?”

“$!{he} was eavesdropping on you, milady.” Korren never takes his eyes off yours as he puts himself between you and the aristoi. “@{(alkorc = 4) Claims the Mystikon set ${him} on us. And|I’m sorry I didn’t catch ${him} at it earlier. But} whatever you were telling the lad…I reckon ${he} heard it.”

Focused on the Alastor, you don’t properly see lady Alasais’s reaction. But you hear the breath catch in her throat, and the dread tinging her flinty voice. “$!{he}'s @{(alkorc = 4) no Kryptast, Captain. $!{he}'s a spy for the Commotion.|a spy for the Commotion, Captain.} See ${he} doesn’t leave here alive.”
*label whynoguards
*page_break
*if alkorc = 4
This just confirms that she fears an unmasking even more than she fears Kryptasts—and that’s how you might yet escape.
“Why not call for your guards, milady? Worried about what they might hear? What I might shout?” The words spill out of you quick and low; you’re sure you’ve only got seconds before Korren takes his chance at you. “Is Telone Baldassare at the manor today? What do you reckon—could he hear me from here?”

No one moves. “And why haven’t you shouted already, ${ird_name}?” Alasais’s voice could freeze the Irdewater.

“Well, that might end with me dying, and killing the Captain here and a brace of your guards, and all Irduin knowing your secrets. There’s got to be some other way that works better for all of us.” After a moment’s pause, you add:
*if alkorc = 4
“You were right, milady. I’m no Kryptast. I just said that to keep Alastor Korren from skewering me for long enough to talk with you.”

“As if I’d look more kindly on spying by a rebel?”

It’s not worth denying it; you just let a little plaintive desperation into your voice as you nod toward the young kurios.
“If I desired to do you or Irduin harm, kuria…would I have told you that your son here was planning an elopement? I could have let that happen. $!{ird_oath}, I could have helped him.”

Auche’s tear-streaked face goes slack with shock. “$!{bastard}! Rimmer ${bastard}!”

Hopefully, his outrage will help your cause with his mother, whose face still shows nothing but implacable hostility. “You have an alternative to propose, ${girl}?”

“Send your son to fetch my
*if not(alone)
@{(cerl_here and gam) friends|companion} and our
things from the Chesnery. Meanwhile we’ll prepare @{alone a horse|horses} here. @{alone I’ll|We’ll} ride out of your lives. $!{oath}, @{alone I’ll even leave the horse|we’ll even leave the horses} at the canal. On the highway, they’d only draw attention @{alone I|we} won’t want. I’ve no interest in your property, or your secrets, once I’ve quit Irduin.”

“Do as ${he} says, lad.” Kuria Alasais doesn’t hesitate. “Tell no one. Bring no @{alone one.|one but ${his}}
*if not(alone)
@{(cerl_here and gam) companions.|friend.}
You understand now what’s at stake.” Auche swallows a protest, then turns and runs off toward the inn.

“Good of you to send the child away, ${ird_name}.” The tension in Korren’s voice and posture tell you that he’s still on the verge of an attack. You’re sure that both he and Alasais will be afraid of some groom or servant wandering by, seeing your confrontation, and raising the alarm. Killing you before you can shout out any secrets will still be their foremost priority.
*choice
#This is going to end in bloodshed. Best to kill them both now, while the boy’s gone and I’ve a chance of not being spotted.
You lunge for Korren first,
*label killkorren
*if (sralibi !=4) or (com = 3)
faster than @{(sralibi = 4) he can match, even after all your sparring. You’ve always known he wasn’t your equal in a fight…and when your eyes meet over the tines buried in his chest, you can see that he always knew it too.|he has any reason to think you can move. The shock of finding that you’re actually a seasoned fighter spills across the Alastor’s face—and seconds later, it’s wiped away by agony from the tines buried in his chest.}
*goto alkorcfight
*else
as you’ve done in so many sparring sessions since the summer. He almost dodges your thrust, taking a score along his side that puts him close enough to have a chance at your head. You duck fast enough to take only a grazing blow, but the pain is still blinding. Swinging the butt end of the hayfork around, you get in a lucky hit just under his ribcage, winding him so that his second attack goes wild.

In the seconds it takes him to recover, you dash the blood from your forehead and jump back to make the most of your fork’s greater reach. Korren’s also bleeding freely through his shirt, but comes after you with barely-diminished ferocity. This time, he brings his sword down hard enough to snap off one of the tines of your makeshift weapon. With a snarl, you shove it past his blade at the right angle to send it into his chest.
*set alkorc 8
*goto alkorcfight
*label alkorcfight

“Curse you, ${ird_name}!” he gasps wetly, trying with his last strength to throw his sword to Alasais. Seeing Korren’s intent, you shove him off-balance with the hayfork and snatch up his blade from where it’s fallen in the dirt, only halfway to the kuria. She’s already running into the stable to arm herself against you.

When you follow Alasais, you see she’s caught up a wooden manure hoe. All around you, the de Irde horses are whinnying and stamping, sensing the violence on the air. Tears streak the lady kuria’s face, but there’s no tremor in her hands or voice. “May the Angels damn your treacherous, murderous, spying soul to Taratur.” She attacks before you have a chance to reply, whether in mercy or mockery.

Twenty years ago, as an active Phalangite commander on the Halassur border, she’d probably have taken you. Her instincts are keen and her skills clearly rival yours, even when rusty from years of partial neglect. But in the end her improvised, unbalanced staff can’t counter steel. Bruised but not crippled by the blows she lands on you, you lunge past her defenses and slash Korren’s blade through her abdomen.

As her mouth works soundlessly and the life fades from her eyes, you crouch next to her.
*fake_choice
#“I offered you another way, kuria de Irde. You should have taken it.”
#“I’m so sorry, milady. You deserved a better end than this.”
#“I am damned, kuria. But I’ve more to do before Taratur claims me.”
#I say nothing. Why waste breath on the dead?
You drag Alasais’s body into the darkest corner of the stable, then hurriedly leave before the horses’ panic draws retainers to the scene. @{(aristo or (me_ride > 1)) There’s no time to try to calm any of them enough to ride away.|} When Korren’s body is found, they’ll hopefully try to locate the lady back in the manor to find out what to do. When she’s found, kurios Joet will surely set the estate’s hounds to find the murderer. You need to be as far away as you can before that hunt begins.

#Alasais isn’t brutal enough for me to be at any real risk. At worst, she’ll exile me from the village. I stay put.
*if int > 1
This would still be a good time to fish out the sharpened stone chip you use to draw blood. But as soon as your hand dips toward your kyrtle, Captain Korren’s sword extends to hover near your neck. “No knives, no weapons, no tricks, ${ird_name}. Keep your hands open.”

*label alkorcaught
You stay frozen in place until lady Alasais emerges from the stables with Auche in tow. Her eyes snap to you at once, then narrow with anger and apprehension. “Captain Korren. What is this ${woman} doing here?”

The Alastor commander speaks over your desperate efforts to make yourself heard. “Eavesdropping, kuria. Whatever you were saying to the young kurios there…I reckon ${he}'d already heard the first half of it before I found ${him}.”

Fury flares across Alasais’s face. “$!{he}'s a spy for the Commotion, Captain. Dispose of ${him} at once.”

$!{oath}. So much for her benevolence.
*if (com > 1)
*gosub hayfork [see above]
“Put it down, ${alias}. We can have a dozen guards here before you’ve time to run.”
*goto whynoguards
*elseif (int > 1)
*set alkorc 5
*goto bloodypalm
*else
All you can do is bluff, as fast and as persuasively as you possibly can.
*goto alkorckryp

*if (alkorc = 0)
*hide_reuse #He’s got to be at least a little worried that I’m a Kryptast. I try to intimidate him.
*if cha > 1
When you speak again, it’s in a flinty, emotionless tone that sounds gratifyingly unlike your normal voice.
*label alkorckryp
“If my next report doesn’t reach the Mystikon by Langnight, the next ${woman} sent here won’t be listening at walls. $!{he}'ll find out I was killed, assume you’re rebels, and kill you all, too.”
*if (cha < 2) and (alkorc = 0)

Korren’s lip curves back. “A Kryptast? You? Angels, ${ird_name}, don’t make me laugh.”
*goto alkorcaughtch
*elseif alkorc = 0
*set alkorc 4

Korren’s face becomes a blank mask. “Let’s neither of us do anything rash, then. I’m not about to let you go just for saying ‘Mystikon’ at me.” When your muscles tense, he barks, “Don’t try to run, ${ird_name}. I’ll cut you down, and explain why to anyone who comes asking, Theurge or otherwise.”

He clearly means to keep you under guard until kuria Alasais emerges from the stables to guide him.
*choice
*selectable_if ((com > 1) or (int > 1)) #If she thinks I know her family’s secret, she’ll tell him to kill me, Kryptast or no. I need to fight my way free.
*if com > 1
*goto forkfight
*else
*goto bloodypalm
#@{((com < 2) and (int < 2)) I’d never survive a fight with Korren.|} I can convince her I didn’t hear anything damning.
*label twonobex
When the two nobles emerge a few minutes later from the stable, you can see the anger and fear plainly on kuria Alasais’s face. “What by all Angels…?”

“$!{he} was eavesdropping on you, kuria,” Korren begins.

You interrupt him @{wisdisp by cutting your palm and levitating him to twice his height. Before any of them can do more than gasp, you snap out,|with cold confidence.} “As I was sent by the Mystikon to do.
*label rebprobe
The rebels of the Rim probe everywhere for an opening to the Southriding. I came here to reassure my masters that it will not come through Irduin.”

Kuria Alasais’s eyes dart in fleeting despair to her son, before coming back to fix bleakly on you. “What proof can you make of such a claim? Have you a warrant from…?”

“We carry no warrant, nor charter, nor letter of introduction.” The level of scorn in your voice cuts through her defiance. “Our @{wisdisp power is our warrant—as is our knowledge|knowledge is our warrant}. And I have already shared enough with you to prevent this boy’s folly.”

“Didn’t think that was how Kryptasts usually stop folly of this sort,” Korren @{wisdisp says, shakily but forcefully, from above you all|notes flatly}. Auche’s face is taut with terror.

“We kill where we must. Not wastefully or rashly. Not where a House is willing to discipline its own.” You cock your head to one side in a show of curiosity. “Enlighten me, kuria: what was it you sent Korren away to tell your son? The Alastor laid hands on me before I could hear whether the helot was herself with child.”

The two of you exchange expressionless stares for some seconds before Alasais growls, “She is not. And I wished to tell my son some matters pertaining to his father, my former husband, Tyndar de Wrase.” She hides the lie well—and you don’t think she’s sure that you’re lying about the last thing you heard. You can still see your death in her eyes, though. “With no warrant, ${kuria} ‘${ird_name},’ how is one expected to manage an outrage of this sort? I’m sure the Mystikon has some way of distinguishing its servants from @{wisdisp rebel Goetes|common spies}.” @{((theuknown > 9) and wisdisp) The horrid suspicion that you’re actually ${fname} ${lname} tinges every word.|}

There’s only one answer that might give them pause in killing you. “Bring back Seichareis. Tell him I am discovered. Let him take me off for Slow-Harrowing if I’ve lied.” You @{wisdisp return Korren swiftly to the ground|gesture to Captain Korren}. “Now tell your Alastor to sheathe his sword before we’re seen. If anyone else here suspects my purpose, it could lead to the rebel sympathizers among your yeomanry fleeing before we can draw in the net.”

It’s also a reminder that if they mean to dispose of you, they mustn’t do it where any passing retainer might witness it and tell an investigating Theurge. “It seems, ${kuria}, that you must be a guest of the de Irde.” With a thin-lipped smile, Alasais pulls the scarf from around her neck. “For subtlety’s sake, then…lie down, and let us bind your mouth.”
*page_break
It was an impressive piece of cleverness from the lady, you have to admit. She’d never have released you back to the Chesnery to await the Theurge’s coming; but for @{((ird_focus = 1) or (ird_subfocus = 1)) an ordinary retainer|a helot-friendly commoner} to suddenly be housed in a top-floor room in the de Irde manor would kindle rumors all across the demesne. The best excuse is for you to be taken suddenly and gravely ill with an illness that only a Theurge could be expected to purge. @{(lyssa > 0) Like lyssa.|Lyssa, the bite-madness sometimes spread by bats from the mines, fits perfectly.}

So Korren gagged you to keep you from biting, bound your wrists, then had you borne back in a feigned fever-fit by terrified servants. The fact that this made it imposssible for you to shout any secrets @{alone or warn an accomplice|} was no doubt also intentional on kuria Alasais’s part.

Now you’re locked into a room where only Korren will enter to bring you food, water, and medicine. You’ve not touched any of it yet, wary of poison.
*goto jailbreak

*if int > 1
#A display of ${wisardry} will convince them I’m a Kryptast, and that they can’t stop me.
*set wisdisp true
*goto twonobex
*else
*comment if nobles already out of stable
*page_break
Your threats, and the cold confidence with which you utter them, take the Irduines aback. “Such words are easily spoken,” Alasais says at last.

"Do you find them hard to believe, kuria?
*goto rebprobe
*comment not caught spying
And that’s when Captain Korren gets close enough to notice you. As he approaches, you raise one hand in greeting and (reluctantly) let your senses refocus to their normal limits. “Wanted to make sure the young kurios wasn’t about to ride off with anyone he shouldn’t,” you explain in a low voice, trying to keep the immensity of the secret you just overheard from affecting your demeanor.

Korren gives a rough shake of his head. “Won’t be happening. You seen anyone else hovering about with their ears open?”

“No one, Captain. The secret’s safe.” You make a quick bow and hurry off before the nobles emerge from the stables. The implications of the secret you just overheard buzz ceaselessly around your mind.

14 Likes

My yanking out the indents for forum readability is going to make this even harder than usual to parse. :slight_smile: But here are some of the alternatives when you’ve sent the boy away (other than “#Best to kill them both now.”).

Summary

#“I don’t want the boy harmed. Nor anyone else who might be an ally.” I’ll appeal to them to join the cause of the Commotion.
“You wear the omphalos, man, but I know your deeper loyalty is to Irduin and the lady kuria.” You don’t relax a muscle, but you don’t move toward him, either. “You’re not my enemy. Nor is any noble who governs her demesne as mercifully as lady Alasais. We all know that the real threat to Irduin comes from Baldassare, the Theurges…the Alastors and priests they’d send here, given half a chance. You know the Hegemony is the true enemy.”

*if ((ird_sus-(cha x 2)) <= ird_sus_low)
“I am the Hegemony, ${alias}.” The weariness in Korren’s tone belies his taut stance. “You can’t turn me against myself.”

“Didn’t you already do that, Captain? When you let yourself truly love a helot?” You pitch your words toward the lady kuria without taking your eyes off the Alastor’s poised sword. “And you, milady…you also have loved ones at stake. How can you serve the outsiders who mean to kill them?”

“So you’d have us turn rebel.” Alasais’s voice holds an odd note; could it be gratitude, for the obliqueness of your nod toward the secrets you just overheard? “Even though resisting the Theurges would lead even more surely to the death of everyone we love.”

“Only if you’re indiscreet about it, kuria. Only if you let it shape the decisions you make when no one from the Hegemony is watching.” Hardly believing your own boldness, you settle your weight back onto your heels and lower the butt end of the hayfork to the ground, leaving yourself open to a lunge from Korren. “But stay discreet, and it could be the way you save those you love.”
*set alkorc 2
*page_break
Korren doesn’t attack you. Alasais doesn’t repeat her order. Instead, they glance at each other, and the bleak-faced aristo inclines her head. Her chief enforcer lowers his sword and steps back to her side.
*label savethestalls
“Tell us how you imagine that ‘saving’ could work, ${ird_name}.”

Your mind races to come up with an @{aristo answer. "Sell|answer—and to find a way of saying it that hides your disgust at making decisions for others in their absence. “‘Sell’} the Stallards before the spring, kuria. Or write a document claiming that’s what you’ve done, anyway. I can bring them with me on my next visit to the Rim, and make sure they end up with folk who’ll look after them—folk who’d never name them helot.”

“Baldassare would never believe it.”
*gosub whobuyseld
“You could tell a story convincing enough to settle suspicions.”

“The Telone would dig into every detail, ${girl}.” Lady Alasais @{(alkorc = 3) has barely relented; she looks far|still looks} readier to kill you than trust you. “He’d guess we were just working to keep the Stallards from the Harrower. And Brasque would never accept anything he thought might bring down an angry Theurge on Irduin.”

“Even if it would save both his daughters’ lives? And put Earith far from the temptation of elopement?” You shrug. “I think you could sway him, kuria. @{(alkorc = 3) For your nieces’ sake.|} And I think @{(int > 1) we|you} can document the sale well enough to stand up to Baldassare.”

“So your solution is that we send them off to join the Commotion.” Korren’s voice is low, his face unreadable.
*fake_choice
#“Not to join the fighting. Just to the one place where they’ll be safe.”
Alasais raises a dubious eyebrow. “The Rim is anything but safe, especially for anyone found in rebel company.”

“And I reckon the Stallards would fight fiercely enough if @{aristo forced to. But I sincerely hope the circumstances won’t force that.”|they chose to. But the choice will be theirs, not mine." You pause. “Nor yours, kuria de Irde.”}
#“Where else would they have a better chance of survival?”
*goto commwipe
#“My solution is for us all to push back against tyrants like Theurge Seichareis, wherever we are, however we best can.”
*label commwipe
“Your Commotion is going to be wiped out, ${ird_name}…or whatever your true name is.” Alasais shakes her head, thin-lipped. “You’ve never faced the kind of force they’ll eventually send against you. Sending Brasque and his daughters into that maelstrom…”

“But where else?” you repeat. “Keeping them here might have worked before Telone Baldassare, kuria. Or before your son fell in love with…” His cousin, you leave unspoken. “When you had the power to see the folk of your demesne spared. But the Hegemony won’t let you keep that power. All we can do to survive now is resist Them—whatever the risks.”
*if alkorc = 3

“So. We ought to put our loved ones’ lives in the hands of a ${woman} who began sharing a deadly secret within minutes of spying it out?” The lady kuria’s eyes say she’d still prefer to have Korren gut you here.

“When both your son and your Captain are in love with your nieces, milady…that secret was never going to keep itself.” You notice Alasais’s slight flinch at your use of the word niece, but she doesn’t gainsay you. “You’d have realized that soon enough, and brought your most trusted advisor fully into your confidence. I just hastened that journey a bit.” When they make no response, you settle your weight back onto your heels and lower the butt end of your weapon to the ground, even though it leaves you open to a lunge from the Alastor. “I mean well by you, kuria. And by them. And yes, by the Captain here.”
*page_break
By the time Auche returns @{alone (still wide-eyed and trembling) from the Chesnery,|with a wary-looking}
*if not(alone)
@{cerl_here Cerlota|} @{(cerl_here and gam) and|} @{gam ${gamgee}|} in tow,
Korren’s sword is sheathed and you’ve leaned the hayfork back against the stable wall. Lady Alasais strides over to her son at once. “Good${woman} ${alias} and I have come to an understanding, son. @{alone $!{he}'ll|$!{he} and ${his}}
*if not(alone)
@{(cerl_here and gam) friends|friend} will
be staying here a little longer yet, until @{alone ${he}'s|they’re} ready to perform one last service for me. Meanwhile, ${he}'ll say nothing to anyone of what passed here today…and I expect you to be wise enough to do the same.”

You’re ready for Auche to protest, question the decision, or curse you again. Instead, after a moment of uncomprehending shock the boy’s shoulders slump, he closes his eyes, and the tears stream out. “Can we go home then, Dama?” Through the wretchedness, you can hear relief in his voice: at finding his mother unslain, certainly, and perhaps even at having the door slammed on his reckless leap into the unknown.

“We can.” Tears streak Alasais’s cheeks as well. “Back to the Chesnery with you, ${ird_name}. @{(alkorc = 3) And by all Angels: keep our secret better there than you’ve done here.|} I’ll prepare as we’ve agreed.”
*page_break
*goto minesab

*else
*label korstrike
If you’d @{(alkorc = 4) not raised the specter of your being a Kryptast, perhaps they’d|done less to stir up suspicion during your months here, they might} have heard you out. But @{(alkorc = 4) for Alasais, the risk of letting a Hegemonic agent ride away knowing that elder Brasque is her half-brother is intolerable. She dips her chins slightly; it’s the only warning you get before|before the last word has fully left your tongue,} Korren’s striking to kill. You dodge and lunge back at him,
*goto killkorren

#“If you give your sword to the lady and go saddle a horse while I stand over here, Alastor, we might all come through this alive.”
*if ((ird_sus-(cha x 2)) <= ird_sus_med) and (alkorc != 4)
Korren doesn’t move, either to follow your suggestion or to lunge at you. “Reckon that depends on how milady feels about the Commotion knowing…whatever it is you just spied out.”

Before Alasais can say anything, you retort:
*fake_choice
#“The lady kuria is mistaken. I’ve nothing to do with the Rim rebels.”
“What are you, then—a Kryptast trying to find evidence of our treason?” Kuria Alasais speaks @{(cha > 1) crisply, without any visible sign of fear|with heavy irony; you don’t think she’s believed you}.

“You think a Kryptast would have prevented your boy’s elopement, rather than punishing him for it?” You @{(cha > 1) shake your head|stubbornly persist in the lie}.
#“You think the Commotion cares about the secrets of a minor noble House, Captain?”
“Do you admit to being a rebel then, ${ird_name}?” Kuria Alasais sounds coldly curious rather than accusatory.

Acknowledging it openly now might tip them over the edge.
#“The only one trying to destroy you through your secrets is Telone Baldassare, milady.”
Kuria Alasais’s lips twist. “Why did you care then, ${ird_name}? What business did you think you had, sniffing out my House’s secrets?” The word Kryptast hangs unspoken in the air between you.

You spread your hands sharply as if to deflect accusations, both spoken and implied.
“I’m just a ${woman} who knows that sometimes you need the right knowledge to stay alive. So I keep my ears open.”

“Might keep you alive, or might get you killed, depending on what you hear,” Alastor Korren notes flatly.

“That’s the risk of it, yes. But I’ve done you no harm, milady, and I mean no harm to you once I’m gone. That only changes if you tell your Captain to attack me…rather than saddle me a horse.”

By the time Auche returns […] Korren has grudgingly prepared everything needed for you to ride away. The young nobleman shakily hands his mother a cloth bound around your things. “This is all I could find in ${his} quarters.”

Alasais
*if not(alone)
gestures curtly at your @{(cerl_here and gam) companions|companion} to join you. She
keeps Korren’s sword at the ready while tossing you the small bundle. “Go, then. But betray us, and I’ll hunt you down, ${ird_name}. You’ve the word of the de Irde on that.”

[cut hliariously lengthy code around possible riding arrangements of you, gamgee, and/or Cerlota]
“Keep your mind on Irduin’s troubles, kuria. That Telone’s the one likely to bring your downfall—not me.”
[…]

*if (korcyn > 0)
#“Your Cynneve is milady’s niece, Alastor. Brasque is her brother. That’s their secret.”
*set alkorc 3
“Kill the lying little ${bastard}!” Alasais gasps out before you’ve finished speaking. “$!{he} means to get us all Harrowed!”

if ((ird_sus-(cha2)) > ird_sus_med)
And the gap between Korren’s faith in her and distrust of you is wide enough that he obeys at once, dismissing your words.
*label dodgekorr
Barely evading his blow, you lunge back at him,
*goto killkorren
*else
But you’ve not given Korren that much reason to distrust you; he can see the truth on your face, as you can see the shocked realization on his. His sword comes down, trembling, as he half-turns to lady de Irde. “Bloody Angels, kuria. I’ve been blind. How…how did you think you could ever…?”
*choice
#And that’s when I lunge for him.
Shock and fury spill across the Alastor’s face—wiped away moments later by agony from the hayfork tines buried in his chest.
*goto alkorcfight
#“You both love them—that’s what matters. And I can save them, if you let me.” Maybe I’ll still win Korren, at least, to the Commotion.
“Korren.” Alasais stretches out her hands in appeal. “Cynneve and Earith have never known, for their protection. That’s the only reason I never told you. Now you’ll learn all.” One hand points sharply at you. “But for their sake: you must not let ${him} leave alive.”

Captain Korren looks between you both, then steps back to the lady’s side, lowering his sword.
*goto savethestalls
#“Sort it out between yourselves. All I want is to leave Irduin.” I gesture toward the horses in the stable.
“Korren.” Alasais stretches out her hands in appeal. […] “But for their sake: you must not let ${him} leave alive.”

The angry confusion on the Alastor captain’s face resolves into grim determination, and his sword comes back up. “$!{he}'s not one to keep ${his} secrets, is ${he}.”

“$!{ird_oath}, man—why would I tell anyone other th…?” But you can tell he’s not listening to you any more.
*goto dodgekorr

13 Likes

Poor Auche, he’ll really blame himself for everything that happens here and after this, won’t he?


The level of player expression is much appreciated, though I imagine it makes the writing process more challenging. To me, there’s a wide enough gulf between choices that the “right choice” for a given character will almost seem natural rather than strategic at this point of the story. A feeling of dominos toppling, even though by the nature of having a choice that’s not how it works.

9 Likes

Am I reading this correctly that even a Com 0 MC can take down Korren and Alasais in melee? Is this intended or just a case of unwritten fail states.

4 Likes

I wonder if Xthonic mysticism is a thing. Like, is there or has there been a Xthonic Symeon the New Theologian? We already know that sometimes a particular doctrine or interpretation can be “taught” to specific few (such as compassion serving order and chaos equally). Might be interesting for a PC who desires some kind of further religious experience.

7 Likes

That’s an artifact of the indent removal. :slight_smile: A COM 0 MC can not beat Korren with a pitchfork.

7 Likes

Since the snippets are hard to parse without indentation, I was doing a write-up of its structure to the best of my understanding of how the code flows.

But then I figured that it’d be easier to read if it was an amateurish diagram, so I made that instead.


Click for diagram (major spoilers)


The most brutal outcome here really has to be impaling Korren while he’s still processing the revelation that his helot girlfriend is also his aristo lady’s niece, and therefore marked for death in about fifteen different ways.

Meanwhile Alasais probably dies thinking that she failed to save her family and that everything she worked so hard to maintain will be destroyed.

18 Likes

This is genuinely a super helpful visual way to parse all this.

7 Likes

This all makes me (faintly) hopeful that we can somehow get the de Irde to join the rebellion, or aid it in some capacity…

Will the only way be by outing Auche’s elopement plans? Or will there be a few potential routes to such an outcome?

5 Likes

@Havenstone in our absence, has our band respected the Wiendish border? Do they just focus on Shayard or do they have any raids/contacts over the passes?

11 Likes

I imagine that would depend at least partly on the cosmo/nationalist divide. A Shayarin separatist group would only need to attack Wiendish positions that are logistically valuable to the Shayarin Hegemonic forces.

Cosmopolitans meanwhile don’t have much reason to pay the border any mind. It’s all getting liberated eventually, what’s an imaginary line on a map matter? Even for plans that involve all these countries being fully separate nations in the end, our strategy is based on building an international rebellion to bring the Hegemony down everywhere.

Now just how feasible attacking the Wiendish side is depends on how well fortified the borders are in a given location. So even if we’re not actively avoiding crossing the border, it’s hard to say what opportunities we’d have to cross it.

8 Likes

I mean, I’m sure even an empowered Shayardene Nationalist rebellion would probably strike out into Karagon to kill the beast if the opportunity presented itself (though I think a thaumatarchy without Shayard’s farmland would probably be doomed anyway), but it definitely would be a lower priority than an inherently cosmo rebellion.

I do wonder if Kors, as bandlead, would recruit from/encroach into Wiendrj more as well. I’m pretty flexible on my eventual ending I’ll go for (given that I have no idea how the circumstances in game 4 will look), but I’ve slowly settled into going for a smaller state of the Rim, Westriding, and Southern Wiendrj as a defensive but not devoid of natural resources option. Especially with whatever polity forms in Sojurn having access to rare alchemical materials from the Xaoslands.

5 Likes

I don’t know how much weight this will really have, but there’s this line at the end of Uprising after meeting Andrejna, the Eye of Clan Lesk:

We’ll run, then," you say, your tongue dry and stumbling. “Some back to Shayard. Some out into ${whendery}.” But for you, there’s only one direction left.

So maybe we’ll start expanding our operations into Wiendrj. And it seems like the allies of the dead Pan Szerick would be natural partners for the rebellion. The Hegemony has already sentenced them to die so it’s not like they have much to lose.

9 Likes