So what I mean is: when someone says their setting is based on “Medieval Europe” what they usually mean is: “this is the vibe my setting is meant to give off.”
We are indeed talking about a period spanning roughly a thousand years. And indeed, it’s true that there were many advancements in which will vary depending on what specific time in the medieval period we’re talking about. Things like the quality and availability of armour, the weapons used, the power and influence of guilds, the advancement of bureaucracy, the rights and privileges of the nobility, and so on, are all going to vary heavily based on time and place.
But what I’m trying to get across, is that when someone says “my setting is based off of medieval europe”, that is not the end point of their worldbuilding; it is the beginning. They’re telling you that their story/setting is not ancient, classical, renaissance, modern, futuristic, etc. Detail like how the government functions or the exact tech level will follow. Because if the writer isn’t intentionally delving into any specific period of history to pull these things from, they’re inevitably going to wind up fleshing those details out anyway as they create and explore more and more of their setting.
As you say, most “medieval fantasy” is based specifically on the late medieval period, and this is common across the genre. Writers who are actively trying to do something different are usually pretty quick to say or otherwise establish that they are, because they want to stand out. So it’s pretty easy to infer what is meant. I do feel like going: “I have no idea if you’re referring to the 6th century or the 14th century” is getting a bit lost in the reeds.
I was mainly objecting to the notion that saying “I based my setting off of medieval europe” tells people nothing. It’s also worth considering that someone who doesn’t know the difference between 6th century Thrace and 14th Century England isn’t actually going to get anything out of specifying. And someone who does know about those topics may potentially see any creative liberties you take as inaccuracies. That doesn’t make the setting inherently more “grounded”, which the person I first replied to claimed it did.
Plus: as you go on to say, even if you’re trying to be as accurate as possible, if you want your setting to be believable you are still going to have to make changes from what you originally wrote because you have to consider the geographical and political factors which actually cause culture to develop.
To be clear, I’m not saying there isn’t value in exploring this at all.
I took issue with the notion that telling someone your setting is based on “medieval europe” isn’t saying anything. Though I didn’t explicitly say so in my post, I also don’t believe that narrowing your focus to an even more specific period is somehow “more grounded.”
I have seen many writers with hyperfixations on very specific regions during specific periods of history and choose to copy/paste those things into fantasy settings, and the result was not a grounded fantasy setting because it just resulted in a bunch of unrelated cultures vomited onto a map. They gave hyper-detailed descriptions of how their society functioned and the people in it (who were literally named after and acted exactly like real world historical figures) but there was no soul or creativity there because it was just copied from historical articles they read. And it also didn’t feel grounded because the geopolitical factors which led to the development of those real world cultures were simply not present in the world we were trying to create together.
On the opposite end of the spectrum? Privately I’ve also personally had to deal with other people assuming I was doing the exact same thing because I gave them a brief summary of a concept that I was intended to serve as a hook before I elaborated in more detail. In a private personal nation-building roleplay: “Yeah this kingdom draws elements from both the Scottish and the Norse” received the feedback of: “oh so you’re just slapping the Norse and the Scottish together with no regard for how they are different or how the mingling of those two cultures would affect each other?” Because they took my vague concept and assumed that was the end of my worldbuilding rather than the beginning.
Worldbuilding can be tough. Communicating your worldbuilding to others in a way that doesn’t lead to them misunderstanding or making assumptions is even harder. That said, certain things can be inferred and just because something isn’t as detailed as you would like it to be doesn’t mean it should be dismissed.
All that to say: if someone tells me their setting is based on medieval europe my reaction isn’t: “which kingdom during which century?”, my reaction is to instead ask them about the geography, politics, cultures, and technology of their setting. That is what actually makes a setting grounded. And if the answers are things that I recognize, I can go: “oh cool, that sounds like…”
Meanwhile if I do ask: “which kingdom during which century?” there’s a chance that I might be putting them on the spot or that they might name something I myself do not know about. Because I’m not a historian and chances are, neither are they.
