June 2026 Writer Support Thread

About stats and testing and so on:

I basically borrow and tweak the below method to gauge how difficult my games are:

It’s pretty reliable - I used it to make sure that Royal Affairs was a bit easier to succeed at than Creme de la Creme, for example, and it helps me gauge how powerful stats are and even whether I should cut them from the game if they’re not pulling their weight.

In The Earth Has Teeth for example, one of my stats is Connect which is about connecting to someone on a social level or understanding them empathetically.

In startup I create the following:

*create con 35
*create con_very_lo 25
*create con_mid_lo 40
*create con_mid 50
*create con_mid_hi 60
*create con_hi 75
*create test_con 0

Here’s an example of a testing choice using Connect ingame:

#I try to make a connection with him so he drops his guard. @{stats [Tests Connect]|}
	*set test_con +1
	"If you're here to see the Superiors," you say, "you're in the wrong place. I can take you that way."
				
	The stranger hesitates.
	*if con > con_mid_lo
		He glances over his shoulder, his grip loosening on the dagger. "We got in by mistake," he says, "we're not here to hurt anyone…"
	*else
		*set health -5
		He looks for a moment as though he's convinced, but then he lunges with the dagger, slashing along your ribs. As you stumble back, clamping your hand to your side, he grabs you and slams you against the tunnel wall.

After my final chapter I add my stat balancing file to the *scene_list.

One of the sections includes this along with the equivalents for all the other stats. When I run RandomTest with line coverage lists enabled, it tells me how high or low the stats can go, and how often that happens.


*if con <= con_very_lo
	*comment Connect [b]Poor.[/b]
*elseif con <= con_mid_lo
	*comment Connect [b]Unremarkable.[/b]
*elseif con <= con_mid
	*comment Connect [b]Commonplace.[/b]
*elseif con <= con_mid_hi
	*comment Connect [b]Noteworthy.[/b]
*else
	*comment Connect [b]Exceptional.[/b]

I also have this section. The exact numbers will vary depending on where I’m at in the game. The line coverage stats will tell me approximately how often a player will encounter a Connect test - ie how powerful/useful that stat is.

*if test_con = 0
	*comment con 0
*elseif test_con < 5
	*comment con 1-4
*else
	*comment con 5+

It gives me a ballpark idea! I definitely fill in the gaps though. Recently @gracierocket came across a branch in The Earth Has Teeth in which a couple of early testing choices didn’t include Connect at all, which is annoying for players at the best of times but especially at the beginning, and that kind of thing is where RandomTest doesn’t give useful information. So I’d say it’s really good at top-level information and does help me have a broad sense of whether I’m in the right direction, but it doesn’t replace player feedback.

I like it too when it’s done well, there’s a nice voice in The Ghost and the Golem back-and-forth with the PC that I enjoy. I think there’s a bit of it in the delightful Choice of the Deathless as well.

24 Likes