Cup's Review: (Latest: Wizard Confidential)

NGL this is an advertising failure, because Hunter shouldn’t necessarily imply vampires at all. They’re different game lines for a reason.

5 Likes

Don’t let other people prejudge it for you. A lot of people love Sins of the Sires, including many writers of the most popular CoG games (including other WoD ones that are almost universally beloved) and a lot of SFWA members. It’s one of my all-time favorites.

I understand why a lot of people don’t like it - it’s pensive, brooding, very literary, and bleak even for a WoD game, with even the best endings heavily bittersweet. If the first thing you want to know when a new game comes out is who the ROs are, it’s probably not going to scratch your itch. If you want exciting action sequences and decisive victories rather than the kind of slow-burn drama that hurts and haunts, it won’t be your cup of tea. All of that is fine.

What I don’t understand is why some people hate it so fiercely that they can’t seem to bear the thought that anyone might actually like it. I’ve been dragged on Reddit for saying I enjoyed it. I’ve seen people who have obviously never played [redacted], [redacted], or The Sons of the Cherry state it as a matter of universal agreement that it’s the worst ChoiceScript game ever. People who don’t actually understand the Nebula nomination process were speculating about some kind of ulterior motive behind its nomination, instead of accepting that maybe SFWA members have different tastes, and they complained that they were being silenced because they were told to complain about the game anywhere other than the thread that was created to celebrate the nomination. I wonder at this point if the hatred for this game isn’t at least as much a meme as an honest reaction.

Anyway, please don’t let anyone (including me) tell you what to think about a game you haven’t played yet, especially if you want to be a reviewer.

8 Likes

For what it’s worth, I have two of Theodoridou’s games in my list of favourites, and I’m selective about the games that I put there. (I haven’t played the other two yet.) But I can see why some people might not like his style as IF.

""

2 Likes

If you like his (fyi) style, there’s a good chance you’ll enjoy Sins of the Sires too.

2 Likes

Thanks for the correction. I hope so! :crossed_fingers:t2:

2 Likes

Hunter isn’t always vampires, but AToM was explicitly a vampire hunter game in the marketing in the same way that Beast of Glenkildove was marketed as being about hunting werewolves.

5 Likes

I think perhaps the best entry into the World of Darkness Interactive fiction scene would be Beast of Glenkildove. In terms of scope it is more manageable and it gives you a baseline for Night Road and Book of Hungry Names.

Sins of the Sires is a bad entry-level story. It and Parliament of Knives are better read after Night Road. Night Road has our character start as an outsider which creates many opportunities to learn about the world. It is also the best of the Vampire games for making varied clan builds. Now that being said, Sins of the Sires is a travesty of a book. It starts out very strong but then falls victim to plot contrivance and becomes extremely linear by the end. Parliament of Knives follows a similar course but has more variation in character fates.

I wholeheartedly suggest Beast of Glenkildove though. It is a perfect representation of what a Hunter game should be.

4 Likes

Beast of Glenkildove is a near masterpiece. It did an exceptional job of creating a story of Hunters and werewolves without damaging the lore of the latter and it still managed to weave vampires and the Fae into it without distracting from the core element. It is what A Time of Monsters failed to be. The Monsters were an afterthought and thus the player role as a hunter was as well.

2 Likes

Noted. :writing_hand:

1 Like

Sin of sires is actually on my to read list (not enough hours in the day, I have quite a list), but I suspect I’ll like it, and probably far more than Night Road (heresy I know). I find a lot to like about aspects of their writing in general that I have read. It is generally seen favourably outside of COG’s sphere (including nebula nominations). Its just their style sometimes to clashes with the louder, power fantasies that are most popular and expected here. It doesn’t make it good or bad necessarily, just different.

6 Likes

Journey Into Darkness

First Impressions

  • Final Score: :star: 5.6/10

Before I started, the cover and title already promises an archaeological period adventure. The description promises the Victorian era, globe-trotting, a magical jewel, and apparently a tomb or two. So far, so good.

Then the very first thing you read is a warning: Journey Into Darkness is closer to a traditional gamebook than the usual ChoiceScript game. There is one correct path through the story, and taking a wrong turn can result in death.

I can’t say that got me excited. I’m more of a plot guy than a puzzle guy. Still, I appreciate Clark giving the player a heads-up about exactly what kind of game this is. I decided to engage with it on its own terms and at least try to reach the proper ending. I failed. Eventually, I decided I had played enough. I enjoyed the time I spent with it, but not enough to keep trying until I found the one true path.

(Because of the title and the premise, somehow I thought it had something to do with Black Heart by Henry Haggard. But it has nothing to do with it, except that both happen in Somewhere, Africa.) (@HalfFinished reminded me that “Heart of Darkness” is by Joseph Conrad no Haggard, and I was thinking of Haggard not Conrad when I wrote the review, though, now that I cleared the missunderstanding the titles do not seem similar at all. :sweat_smile:)

Writing

  • Premise: :star: 8/10

    I love a Victorian era, globe-trotting, relic-hunting adventure!

  • Development: :star: 4/10

    Maybe I’m biased, but at some point I didn’t even remember what the goal was anymore.

  • Prose Style: :star: 8/10

    It’s serviceable at worst, and funny in its best moments.

The prose is functional, fast-paced, and sometimes genuinely funny. Every once in a while I would huff in mild amusement. The narrative time is heavily compressed, which suits the kind of game this is. You’re not here for lengthy introspection; you’re here to get on a ship, explore a jungle, fight things, die, and hopefully remember not to do that the next time.

The plot, if you can call it that, is all over the place. You keep stumbling into one adventure trope after another, often with very little connecting them. At one point, I had completely forgotten why my character had joined the expedition in the first place. (No, really! I can’t remember what the actual goal was.)

During my attempts, I encountered pirates, fungus zombies, a ghost ship, a vampire, skeleton warriors, a giant spider, a giant crab, indigenous people living in cities built at the top of trees, a flying dinosaur (I don’t remember the name), and an ancient temple containing an eldritch entity. It felt like Clark wanted to include as many pulp-adventure tropes as possible.

But that chaotic quality is also part of the charm.

Cast

  • Cast: :star: 8/10

There’s not much character development here. No relationship meters, no elaborate dialogue trees, no romances. Your companions are simply there, accompanying you on the adventure and regularly contributing with a witty remark. And that was enough for me to liked them.

In one playthrough, Lady Jane was killed by a vampire. I actually could have continued without her, but I started over anyway just because I didn’t want to leave a friend behind. Considering how irrelevant that decision was, the fact that I cared enough to do it must count for something, right?

Game Design

It is a puzzle game. And one of the “maze” variety. It is what it is and the author and the game are very honest about it. Whether you like it or not is a matter of personal taste.

Exploration & Puzzles

  • Exploration & Puzzles: :star: 5/10

    It’s honest, but that’s the best compliment I can think of.

I used to love traditional gamebooks. Every time I got a new one, I’d get excited, play it over and over… and then eventually get frustrated and start “cheating”.

Journey Into Darkness reminded me why.

The problem I have with this kind of puzzle design is that the solutions are often arbitrary. Eventually, it becomes less a puzzle game and more a memory game — or a note-taking game, if you want to take it seriously. You try something. You die. Next time, you remember not to do that and try something different.

The game does provide checkpoints. When you die, you can either return to the last checkpoint or start over. Unfortunately, a checkpoint can occur after a point where you are already doomed, no matter what you try.

At one point, I reached a temple with a stone circle and some red doors. No matter what I tried, I ended up dead. Eventually, I realised I should not have gone to the temple in the first place. In hindsight, considering it was called something like the Temple of the Dead, perhaps I should have seen that coming. Unfortunately, my checkpoint was already inside, so my only solution was to start over.

In another branch, I explored as far as I could in one direction until I found a ghost ship. Inside I found a note telling me: This is not the way. Right before I was attacked by a swarm of skeleton warriors. Thanks? That’s the sort of humour you’ll find in the game.

But there’s something interesting; every time you die, the game also offers you a hint. The hints are more enigmatic than the puzzles themselves. They’re presented as seemingly random memories from the character’s life. One described my in a lecture at school where the teacher enphasizes the number 3, while in another my character was dying in a friend’s arms while admiring the night sky. What was I supposed to do with that information? I have no idea. But I do have an inkling that there may be more going on here than I initially gave the game credit for. I’m choosing to interpret the whole adventure as the protagonist’s final hallucination while dying in his friend’s arms.

Don’t correct me. I like my ending.

Combat

  • Combat: :star: 1/10

The game isn’t mechanically complicated. You have some basic stats, an inventory, Stamina that effectively functions as HP, and Luck that depletes every time you test it. I actually like the concept of Luck as an exhaustible resource.

Combat, however, didn’t work for me at all. You select Battle, the game resolves the entire fight, and then it gives you a blow-by-blow report of what happened. Since I wasn’t making any decisions between those blows, I very quickly stopped reading the report and skipped to the bottom to see whether I was dead and how much Stamina I had left. Eventually, I started using the Instant Win option and skipped battles altogether.

If there’s no strategy during combat, I don’t need to know how many times my character and the enemy hit each other before the dice finally decided who won.

Minigames & Replayability

  • Replayability: :star: 5/10

    I mean, that’s the whole premise. I just didn’t care very much after a while.

The little activities at the club were enjoyable, particularly because they were short. They add some mechanical variety without overstaying their welcome.

As for replayability… well, repeatedly playing the game is the point of the game. You’re expected to explore, fail, remember what went wrong (sometimes that’s not that obvious), and gradually discover the correct route.

I eventually reached the point where I understood that perfectly well and simply didn’t want to do it any more.

My Takeaways

All in all, Journey Into Darkness is an enjoyable game if you calibrate your expectations. Clark delivers exactly what the game promises. Unfortunately, I don’t think what it promises is what most ChoiceScript players are looking for.

Play this if you want a light-hearted, witty, chaotic Victorian adventure where you’ll encounter every pulp trope possible, die repeatedly, and gradually discover the one (and only one) correct way forward. If you enjoyed old CYOA or Fighting Fantasy gamebooks, I suspect you’ll have a much better time with this than I did.

As for me, I had fun while it lasted. I just didn’t have enough fun to keep dying until I found the real ending.

5 Likes

Ah the premise sounds like something I’d enjoy. The actual game play loop a bit less. I don’t like replaying most games though. Much less doing so to find the one path, although the hint system sounds like it’s nicely done.

The premise sounds more in line with work by Haggard to be sure. But Heart of Darkness is by Joseph Conrad.

1 Like

You’re right! I mixed up Conrad’s “Heart of Darkness” and Haggard’s “Black Heart” (actually, the full title is Black Heart and White Heart: A Zulu Idyll; I had to look it up!)

Ah I wondered if you meant a different one all together. I haven’t read much by Haggard and while I actually don’t mind Conrad’s writing, Haggard seemed like the more fitting author for a potential comparison. But of course I do not know the book you mentioned. Maybe I’ll add it to my reading list.

1 Like

Keep in mind the usual disclaimer for any of Haggard’s work: It’s a product of its time. That said, I do like it. It’s a short story with his famous Allan Quatermain.

4 Likes

Hah, this reminded me of how I feel playing The Dark Picture games by Supermassive. There, you get premonitions of events that can happen in the future, so you can try to avoid them. My problem is, the screen got so dark and shaky to be ~spooky~ I couldn’t even tell what the vision was.

Great review as always, cup! (I meant to reply earlier, oops.) I was unfamiliar with the game, so I looked up Journey Into Darkness. I forgot to add “choice of games,” which brought me to a nasty true crime book :sob:

1 Like

:hushed_face::hushed_face::hushed_face:

Thanks, Kate. Unironically, the true crime book seems interesting. :joy:

1 Like

An Imp and an Impostor

First Impressions

  • Final Score: :star: 6.5/10

I’ve played this game before, not too long ago. In fact, it was because of this game that I decided to start writing reviews. On my first run, I tried to split my build between magic and gadgets, but I started failing important checks because I wasn’t good enough at either. This time, I played as a male imp, focused entirely on magic, and romanced Alia.

I have mixed feelings about An Imp and an Impostor. I liked the characters; the setting has some interesting ideas, and the amount of work that went into accounting for different builds is genuinely impressive. Unfortunately, I also found the game frustrating, especially towards the end, when I was spending more time worrying about stat checks than actually roleplaying my character.

And that was with a focused build. More on that later.


Metrics
Metric Value
Declared word count 620k
Actual word count with code 616_754
Word count without code 576_225
Number of runs 1_000
Average 58_605
Median 58_517
Shortest run 44_596
Longest run 71_995
Replay factor 9.85

Writing

  • Premise: :star: 8/10
  • Development: :star: 6/10
  • Prose Style: :star: 7/10
  • Setting and Worldbuilding: :star: 7/10

The premise is that you’re an imp, an extraplanar creature who has been stripped of all your magic, and you are now stranded in the mortal plane, trapped in a human body. You infiltrate Arkan, the institution responsible for keeping magical beings and people in check, hoping to recover your powers.

It’s an interesting premise, and I did want to get my magic back. The plot itself, though? I don’t know how I feel about it. It was serviceable. Nothing particularly remarkable, but it kept me going.

There’s also a plot thread about Arkan stealing people’s powers and using them for some mysterious purpose. It’s hinted that they’re preparing to face the Mercy, some sort of godlike entity. That’s an interesting development, but it comes rather late in the story. I wish it had been introduced earlier, because it would have given the whole investigation a more sinister undertone.

We do learn early on that Arkan has pawned off your magic, but at that point it feels more like local corruption than part of something much bigger. By the time the larger conspiracy starts taking shape, I felt it hadn’t had enough time to develop properly. And it doesn’t, because it’s already the end of the story.

One thing that bothered me was the use of so many foreign words. I understand wanting to add flavour, especially when you’re writing about your own culture. You want to share your love for your home, your language, the food, the clothing, and so on. But it’s easy to overdo it, and I feel like Fikry overdid it. Khediwe, talsama, motalsem, galabeyat, tarboosh, tarabeesh, Raqout, melaya, motalsemeen… And more.

Some of these I have no idea how to pronounce, and often I couldn’t tell from context what they meant. Maybe I could guess something was a type of food or clothing, but unless I stopped every time to Google it, the words only served to paint a very vague picture in my mind. Which is the opposite of the intended effect, I suppose.

I don’t have much of a reference for turn-of-the-century Egypt. Actually, none at all. So instead of adding flavour, all those unfamiliar terms sometimes made me picture generic, bland, 1990s Hollywood stereotypes of Arab clothing and scenery. Not proud to admit that, by the way. I have no idea how far off the mark I was. Probably a lot.

The first time I came across talsama, I looked it up and learnt that it’s related to the English word talisman. Cool, it’s a type of magic. But every time I encountered another unfamiliar word, I became less interested in stopping to look it up. I wasn’t in love with the setting or the plot enough to want to do the homework.

As for the prose, it’s competent. Nothing particularly stood out to me. However, there were a few passages I found difficult to parse, mostly early in the game, which is odd because you’d expect the opening chapters to be more thoroughly vetted.

Here’s an example:

⚠️ Spoiler warning

“I’ll anchor you. Just focus,” you say.

“How…gallant,” Kamal says. It looks like they might want to say something else, but think better of it. Instead, they tighten their grip on the fishing rod and pull.

The sea rages.

There is a mounting pressure. More of that aggressive nothing scent, blocking out even the sharp iodine cold of the sea air and the smell of wet sand. And then, like a balloon—

Pop!

The pressure is gone. The sea calms to how it was before. And stretching out along its surface: boats. Fishing boats, a whole row of them painted in blues and reds and yellows, each more colorful than the last. Each carries at least two people, and between them, a wealth of just…stuff. Crates, statues, even street signs, you think, and suddenly you know what they’ve been doing.

Sorry, what?

They were fishing, then the line went taut, then they started pulling, and then… there was a row of fishing boats? Huh? Did they pull the boats out with the fishing rod? Were the boats underwater? Where did they come from?

Later, you find out Kamal has some space-distorting powers. But it’s never explained plainly, and definitely not when it happens. I only understood this passage on my second read because I already knew Kamal could do that sort of thing. The first time, I had to read it a couple of times before I just accepted it and moved on.

This wasn’t the only passage where that happened, but unfortunately, I didn’t note down the others. Luckily, the problem seemed mostly confined to the beginning of the story.

Also, a very small nitpick: there should be a space after the ellipsis. (OK, I looked it up, and apparently Chicago style doesn’t require one. Thanks, I very strongly dislike it.)

Ah, I remember another example. Kamal’s gang is called the Fishers, but I don’t recall that ever being stated explicitly. At some point, the text said something like “the Fishers followed Kamal”, and I thought the Fishers were some characters I hadn’t met yet, some siblings, because the name was capitalised. Only later did I realise it was the name of the gang, and I felt really dumb.

I don’t usually need authors to spell everything out for me, but it often felt like some connective tissue was missing from the prose. A simple sentence each time could fix that.

Cast

  • Cast: :star: 9/10

Now for the positives. I actually liked the characters in general, especially Alia.

To be honest, I started out indifferent to her on both runs, and she won me over both times. She’s the unbothered type. She seems distant and uptight at first, but slowly opens up to you. Eventually, I warmed up to their banter. Twice.

Kamal is also charismatic, and I only didn’t engage more with Selim for lack of opportunity.

I don’t have much else to say about the cast, but I enjoyed spending time with them.

Game Design

  • Mechanics: :star: 2/10

This is where my biggest problem with the game lies.

As I mentioned, on my first playthrough, I tried splitting my build between magic and gadgets. Bad idea. I started failing important checks because I wasn’t sufficiently good at either.

In other words, this is one of those games where you have to pick a build and stick to it. The choices might offer several ways to approach a situation, but in practice, you only have one viable approach: whichever stat you started improving first. Try branching out, and you’ll just fail repeatedly. It’s very frustrating.

There are a few ways I can think of to mitigate this: adding randomisation, introducing some sort of mercy factor, lowering the thresholds, or allowing skills to improve through failure. Anything to make experimenting with different approaches less punishing.

For my second run, I decided to focus exclusively on magic. Surely that would solve the problem, right? Well, not quite.

Because of my experience the first time, I also started peeking at the code a lot. And one thing I have to praise is how intricate the checks are. There are small variations accounting for all sorts of combinations of stats. The amount of work that must have gone into this is impressive. Unfortunately, the results weren’t always satisfying.

Even with a focused build, I was still failing a lot of checks in the late game. At least twice, I found myself in situations where there was no option I could successfully take, regardless of what I chose. And for the other choices, I found myself carefully selecting whichever option gave me the best chance of success rather than the one I actually wanted to experience as part of the story. So I just exchanged one kind of frustration for another.

For example, when I confronted Fadl, I wanted to beat his ass to a pulp. That’s the least he deserved. But apparently, my character was too affable for that. If I tried, I’d get a bad outcome, so I had to choose a different approach.

The whole final stretch of confronting him was so disappointing, and it’s the actual *climax* for my character’s personal story. Instead of choosing how I wanted my character to behave, I was cautiously navigating the available options to find the ones that would let me succeed.

The complex check system is commendable, but in practice, it’s not only counterintuitive, but the difficulty threshold means you’ll fail even with a focused build. And it’s not one of those games where failing is just as interesting. I can’t even imagine playing it blindly – well, actually I can; that was my first run. It was just frustrating.

I don’t want to have to read the code to know which choices my character is allowed to make successfully.

My Takeaways

There’s a lot of work behind An Imp and an Impostor, and I can appreciate that. The intricate checks and small variations are impressive, and the characters, especially Alia, were enjoyable enough to win me over twice.

But more complexity doesn’t necessarily make for a better experience. If the player is constantly worrying about which stat a choice will test, they’re no longer choosing what their character would do. They’re choosing what the game will allow them to succeed at.

And when writing about an unfamiliar culture or setting, there’s a balance to strike between adding flavour and giving the reader enough context to understand what they’re looking at. Unfamiliar terminology can make a world feel richer, but only if the reader can actually picture what it describes.


On an unrelated note, this is the second game where I didn’t get the option to rate it after finishing. This time I played in the browser, but I played A Time of Monsters in the app, and neither gave me the option to rate the game in the “Play Again” menu. What’s up with that?

9 Likes

To be fair, the PC doesn’t know at this point that Kamal has space-distorting powers, so while (being an interdimensional imp and all) they aren’t quite so confused as you would be if this actually happened to you, it’s still pretty confusing for them in the moment, and I think the way it’s written reflects that.

Ooooh, you’re missing out, Selim is my second-favorite character … and my favorite is Batates, so yeah, I recommend playing a Selim route.

4 Likes

Damn, that’s a really impressive replay factor / delta between wordcount and playthrough. This game must be boasting a ton of replayabillity and / or reactivity.

I find this super interesting, it speaks to a design issue I often find myself grappling with as I design challenges for Pactbinder: the tension between making a player’s build truly meaningful, giving people freedom to tackle situations in plenty of different ways, and working out when it’s appropriate for a player to have no win conditions at all as a result of the build they’ve chosen and the actions they’ve taken.

Such a complex question, I’m sure the answers are different for every game! Very interesting to think about, though.

3 Likes