My favorite topic to discuss about, because there’s plenty of those games for me. I’ll go first!
No horror game has scared me nearly as bad as Fallout: New Vegas. And Vault 22.
For those who don’t know… Vault 22 is crawling with hostile humanoid creatures labelled Spore Carriers. They are green and hide into green plants. They don’t show up in V.A.T.S. (yeah, spammed my button pointlessly), they hide very well, basically. I literally wasted around 200-250 shots just firing at plants, making sure there were no enemies that could jumpscare me. The worst of all is that they’re fast. And lunge. God, I am an absolute coward, but I don’t even go to the place on new playthroughs.
Anyways, your experience doesn’t have to be a certain enemy, it’d be nice if you could describe what scared you the most in any game!
(Did I mention you can hear faint whispers in Vault 22 too? Oh, add that to the list).