First, I’m surprised by the backlash. I was just trying to do a good thing. After reading through CoG’s policy on everything AI, I can see that there’s little point in continuing with AI music.
This is a shame for several reasons:
- It is good. The quality of the AI songs is exceptional. I write the lyrics, create a persona, direct a style for the music, then let the AI do its thing. It is my creativity being sped up.
- US and UK Copyright laws are not clear, but favour the input that I am doing. Both suggest that ownership of the AI work should be somewhere between the AI software owners and the lyric/style writer. With a paid Suno subscription, this is bypassed and full rights are given to me, the lyrics and style writer. Hence, the competition.
- Unlike writing, which I can do, and art, which I can do, music is something that is much harder to achieve (although I have been successful here too, with @Samuel_H_Young’s music which was all composed by myself, albeit only instrumental music). This AI tool makes that much easier.
I guess what I’m trying to say is that the AI haters have it wrong. I’m the first person to say that AI is being used incorrectly - it should NOT be used to take away the creative aspects of humanity. We are denying ourselves fun and the speed and quality of AI will affect the lives of artists, musicians, and (after reading this thread, writers as well, it seems. Instead, it would be better if AI was used to do menial jobs and allow us all more time for those creative pursuits. However, that’s not the world we live in. AI is here and before it destroys itself, we should be using it to our advantage.
Not writing of course. I don’t use any AI for writing at all. The closest I get is googling a word to check the spelling (I don’t use a spellchecker, I google search with the spelling I think it should be, then scoll down past Webster to the OED. I am British, after all). Reading that people are using grammarly, for example, was an eye-opener. My only interaction with that has been annoying ads that pop up! I didn’t realise that it was actually used (I’d launch into a tirade complaining how education standards have dropped, but this post is already getting long).
I guess I will remove this competition and turn the thread into another AI discussion. Music wasn’t mentioned once in the policy thread I read, so perhaps this thread can be used to clarify the do’s and don’ts of AI music.
Finally, I love the irony in being told I can’t use AI music by @AletheiaKnights whose own profile pic is admittedly AI generated. Don’t worry, Aletheia, I’m not having a go. I’m just mildly amused.
