This is the type of character I love with all my soul tbh. And this is the type of RO I have been looking for for a long time. Someone who is lovely and kind, but will not hesitate to destroy their enemies.
AV is a chaotic good person. They will not hurt innocents and will only protect and help them, but those who hurt them? Yikes. They’ve been known to completely disintegrate nobles and even just middle class people who are guilty of really horrible shit.
AV is also the owner of multiple homeless shelters, no-kill animal shelters, and low income housing that is actually really good. And they help run many charities, ESPECIALLY in the future.
O and Alain help out a lot once they all get to know each other.
So, first off, I like what you’ve got going so far. You have a good ratio of asked to answered questions, as in you give the audience enough questions to keep us curious and the right amount of answers so that we’re not completely lost. You’ve given me characters I’m curious about–why is MC’s boss such a jerk? Why is AV so cool despite magicians usually being aloof? How did MC meet their best friend?
Also, I really like Grandpa. He’s a cool dude.
I do have 2 issues, though. First, I feel like the story and narrative are a little clunky. Some scenes move really slowly, and there are some scenes and interactions that I just don’t know what purpose they serve (like the stablemaster guy.) If you want to keep all of them, then that’s your style, but if you’re not super excited about some of them I’d revisit scene by scene and consider whittling down or getting rid of non-utilitarian scenes altogether. If this is just a case of we’re not seeing these things pay off yet because the demo is still so short, that’s fine and ignore this point.
Last, your dialogue does not feel natural. Your characters tend to overexplain something, just use too many words, or speak like they’re giving exposition. Again, this could just be a stylistic choice, but I recommend you say these lines out loud and see if they still sound good to you.
Thank you so much!! Thank you for giving me and my demo a chance!!!
We are definitely still looking for non-binary testers! If you have a discord, click the Discord hyperlink in the demo’s description or dm me and I can give you a link to the server!!
Ah, okay, some constructive criticism to go through!! Lets see…
I hadn’t actually thought things were clunky or anything like that, to be honest. Interacting with Mister Cormin, showing what happens in the shop, exploring the town, etc is all to build normalcy and show what the MC normally does! I’m trying to see where you’re coming from, but I’m not sure I do… if I cut so much out, then scenes wouldn’t move from one place to another. I would need to cut out Mariweather, I’d need to cut out a character who has tried to show the MC kindness in light of Gilin’s actions, and I don’t honestly see how that would make anything better. Maybe you could try to explain better, please?
Could you give examples, please? This is hard to see without knowing what you’re referencing. If you could provide 2-4 per issue, it’d be helpful, to be honest.