Yup. Nice = let us out of the cell, gave us food, a bed, Sociable = carried on basic social interactions
I didnât say they were moral, ethical, or cooperative.
This isnât where weâre different. I always prefer honesty and actually get really angry when others wonât let me make an informed decision.
However⌠where we differ is the the value and implications we put on these behaviors. Iâm old and bitter enough to know the world isnât brutally honest, I donât expect it to be, and I see those who havenât figured this out as being the cultural/social deviants. Acting like âbrutalâ honesty is better than having social graces hasnât gotten me anywhere in life or my career. I had to soften up to just not be abnormal. Now, after 5 years in China, Iâm even more hyper-attenuated to how being pleasant is infinitely more valuable to them than being honest or accurate. (As much as it drives me crazy and messes up my projects and life plans.)
So, trying to analyze behaviors and intuit motivations, the fact that my first kidnappers are being civil, even being as superficially pleasant as they can be means that Iâm worthy enough of such treatment. As in, Iâm less likely to be raped and eaten alive when we arrive at the destination if theyâre bothering to be reasonably social on the ship.
If their intentions were outright malicious, they likely would have kept me drugged, kept me in the cage, etc.
I actually think they are. They put me in a pleasant and homey environment and put a seemingly benevolent person as my companion who explained things to me. She could be lying, but either way, theyâre still putting in effort to try and make me comfortable which is better than keeping me in a box.
Since my abduction, they have been showing that my life, and then later my cooperation are valuable. Iâll take it. Not like it, but take it. Our fatherâs and his councilâs brutal honesty actually put me slightly more at ease, if that makes you feel better. They donât expect me to trust or like them, but it will clearly be better for me to cooperate. Iâll take that over every employer who lied to me in a job interview to get me to take the job.
Youâre also looking at this with some hindsight of what the situation turned out to be and how disagreeable it is to our notion of Free Will. Frankly, Iâm glad Iâm not being dropped off for sport hunting. Iâm not silly enough to think that my Earthly career goals matter to these people any more than they matter to my current boss.
As to the rebels⌠Iâm old enough to remember when all the rebels in the middle east were âgoodâ because they were against governments that we didnât like. Yeah, now theyâre the Taliban and ISIS. Just because we have so many stories about the nobility of scrappy rebels fighting against oppressive regimes doesnât mean that rebels = good. Also, with the benefit of hindsight, how many revolutions turned out better for the people? Russia? China? Cuba? The list goes on.
So, no. My first abductors are clearly the establishment after I see the military base and specialized use of their infrastructure. It would be pure emotionality for me to assume that anyone else who doesnât like them is good. Maybe the rebels are rebelling so they can have the right to marry their 10yo sisters. I donât know. Then, as for their intentions for me, I have no reason to trust the word of either side. What I can intuit from behavior is that my living is currently valuable to the establishment. Might not the opposite be true for the establishmentâs enemies? I very well may be more valuable dead to the rebels, or they may find a purpose in malicious treatment of me, they very well may intend to use and manipulate me just as much for their side of political spectrum. I very much doubt theyâre going to set me off at a cozy beach house to live out my days in peace.
The only observable fact that we have is that weâve been in the custody of our first abductors for days and are still alive. Anything else is a craps shoot.
But, thatâs why itâs a Choice game. 
As I usually do, Iâll eventually play a belligerent character that goes against the flow however impractical it seems. lol