Yikes, I see the error that could let you choose to have your lover die. That could cause some bad errors elsewhere. I’ll tidy that up. That explains why another person saw that person later in the game.
@poison_mara, I don’t see the error. Theo is the one who spent a year in Brightwater and met you when you arrived after a year of exile with Gill. Theo is mentioned all through the prison break setup and all though the text you just quoted.