The Bread Must Rise
By James Beamon and Stewart C. Baker
![]()
![]()
![]()
☆☆☆☆☆☆ (4/10)
Published September 2023, ~450,000 words
I wonder what’s worse for an author: a player requesting a refund or a player leaving a negative review. Probably the latter, I think. Hearing why someone disliked something you wrote—and by extension, you—would probably suck way more than indifferent silence. Well, I do feel sympathy for Beamon and Baker. I probably should have gotten a refund, but I wanna finish every game in the catalog, damn it! Now, while I try to stay polite as a baseline, I couldn’t help but feel a bit irked while reading The Bread Must Rise (“Bread”), and so I’m writing this review. I’m rereading what I wrote again, and this got a bit scathing, ngl. But I’m sorry, Beamon and Baker. I’m just a #hater.
Now, I’m a hater with nuance and complexity in my heart. So, I always mention the good first. The baking itself is quite fun! I enjoyed navigating the intricate resource-management system: deciding which ingredients to buy, balancing quality against cost, and figuring out how to approach each competition. You can focus on actually winning, investigate what is going on around you, persuade people, or sabotage your competition. The whole thing has a nice little light-RPG element, and I liked having multiple ways to approach a problem.
The baking descriptions are also impressive—decadent and delicious! The game clearly knows how to write about food, with plenty of clever jokes and metaphors throughout. My problem is that I don’t think the game is nearly as good at writing scenes as it is at writing jokes. The story has almost relentless momentum; plot threads pile on top of each other faster than I can resolve them, and eventually I struggle to remember what I’m supposed to care about.
Pros:
Gameplay. I didn’t expect an eldritch, comedic baking simulator to have a fresh twist on choices that matter! To begin with, you have a limited amount of lucre (money) to spend on ingredients, with several options varying in price and quality, so there’s some actual resource management involved. Like, take a cake, for example. You’ll have to buy eggs, flour, … uh. What else is in a cake? Sugar. Baking powder, I think. Anyway, for each ingredient, there are four to six options ranging in quality and price. You can’t just splurge to achieve the highest score—nope, there are five rounds to the Great Godstone Bakeoff! So, do you buy the shitty eggs now and save your lucre for better flour later? Do you go all-in this round and risk having less money for the next? Or do you accept a mediocre score now because you’re planning to crush the competition in the next round? I actually found myself thinking about these choices instead of just automatically clicking the most expensive option.
And when it comes time to compete, you have multiple ways to approach things: you can focus on baking the best possible dish, investigate, persuade people, or sabotage your competition. But you also have to keep an eye on the clock, because every action takes time—some take 15 minutes, others 30 minutes or more. So you can’t just investigate every lead, chat up every person, and meticulously prepare the perfect bake. You have to decide what’s actually worth your limited time. Do you spend 30 minutes investigating your competition, or use that time to improve your own bake? Do you have enough time to pull off one more scheme before the round ends? Bread makes the choices feel meaningful without being overly complicated.
Mouthwatering food writing. Man, I wish I’d taken better notes, because the only thing I jotted down was “yum.” But from what I remember, the authors are terrific at describing food. Ingredients, textures, flavors, presentation—pretty much everything gets described, and it felt like a feast for the eyes. Even when I made something that was an absolute disaster, the game committed to the bit. My poor product was described as wilting, ugly, and basically dogshit. It was honestly kind of heartbreaking. I had never been more emotionally invested in a cake I had just completely fucked up. It also has plenty of clever little jokes and metaphors woven into the descriptions!
Cons:
Not my type of humor. Listen, humor as a genre is hard. I’ve only enjoyed, like, one comedic work (Gower’s Jolly Good series), and it wasn’t even “just” comedy. But I digress. It’s not that the game is unfunny; it just has a very particular kind of humor that doesn’t work for me. There’s a lot of slapstick, lowbrow humor, absurdity, and snark, and the game is almost always trying to make me laugh. A couple of examples I jotted down:
-
Some contestant dies, meaning the baking contest is canceled. Of course, you can’t have that! So you try to get the Queen to bring him back using necromancy (long story). She does! Except, he’s not all there. He’s a zombie. Oops. Well, surprise surprise, the content was never going to be canceled, you silly goose! We were just going to give him a funeral for drama; now you get to deal with a zombie contestant.
-
The main character felt like a punching bag. Play through the first chapter of the demo, and you’ll be forced to keep filling out forms, with the “humor” coming from the repetition and the situation’s self-aware absurdity.
-
Your zombie (?) minion, Dragur, will keep misunderstanding your orders. This is another example where I think the game expects the repetition itself to become funny, but eventually I just wanted him to understand what the hell I was saying. Idk. When bad things happen to the player, I don’t find humor in that. I instead feel frustrated and punished.
-
It’s hard to take stupid stuff seriously, like carrying around a corpse. Everyone else is just like, “Yep, totally normal human being.” Uh, no??? I feel like someone would notice that I’m carrying a dead body around.
-
Slight spoilers, but to save the Queen from being burned at the stake, you sweet-talk the crowd. Your brilliant words are: “Instead of burning witches, let’s burn marshmallows. And chocolate. Instead of a Witch Killing Festival, let’s have a S’mores Making Festival!”

-
This random line out of context that I have no recollection of??? “Three clowns going to the arena with a trombone, trumpet, and a spray bottle.”
So, where am I going with this? I think these examples have a couple of issues. First, the narrator comes off as direct and in-your-face, like they’re a character themselves. But I’ve just started the game! I haven’t gotten acclimated to this teasing narrator, which can come off as taunting or even desperate. I guess I prefer my comedy a bit more “highbrow,” where the characters take a silly situation seriously, yet the audience finds it hilarious. I don’t like the fourth-wall breaking; I don’t like it when the narration goes, “See! See! Isn’t this so funny! Aren’t you laughing?”
Second, the absurdity is constant in Bread. It’s hard to remember the emotional or grounded scenes when the game is constantly ADHD-ing its way into the next joke, disaster, or bizarre situation. And, I think, you need that breathing room, even in a comedy. Not every scene has to be funny. You need moments where the characters can be sincere, the world can feel grounded, and the player can actually invest in what’s happening. That’s where the emotional moments come in, but it’s also where the contrast comes from. If everything is absurd, then absurdity becomes the baseline. You need the quiet moments for the ridiculous ones to actually feel ridiculous. How can I take the stakes of losing, or the world ending, seriously when the game itself doesn’t?
Breakneck pacing. Okay, bear with me, because I might just be yapping here. But in Bread, like most works, there are many subplots to keep the reader’s attention: the Queen Undying, the baking contest, Carb Freeon cult, magic, necromancy, the City Council, large cast, an eldritch monster, and whatever tf happened to your parents’ death.
Individually, none of these things are necessarily a problem. But the story has started to feel like I’m trying to spin an increasingly ridiculous number of plates at once. At the beginning, I can handle four plates: A, B, C, and D. I make a choice, pick up A, and expect A to be what I’m dealing with for a while. Instead, A turns into A1, A2, and A3. Okay. Fine. I’m still holding them. Then I move on to B, and suddenly B becomes B1, B2, and B3 too. Now I’m trying to keep A1, A2, A3, B1, B2, B3, C, and D all spinning at once.
And the problem is that the plates don’t really go away. I don’t get to finish with A and put those plates down before moving on to B. I don’t get to resolve B and clear some space before C demands my attention. They just keep accumulating. Every time I think I’ve gotten one thread under control, the game seems to put another plate on top of it. And then another. And then another.
Eventually I’m not even thinking about which storyline I’m most interested in anymore. I’m thinking about which plate is about to fall. I’m trying to remember what I was supposed to care about, which character I haven’t checked in on, which thread I left hanging, and which of the increasingly large pile of things I’m supposed to be paying attention to is going to come crashing down if I don’t pick it up again. Idk. I think I might have anxiety.
Weak character writing. I thought the ROs were a bit weak (not my Queen tho), but I won’t linger on that too long. I instead have a couple of pet peeves. The no-carb faction remained a constant pain in my side, and I was forced to interact with them. I’ve found out I absolutely despise the trope of “Oh, I have something SUPER important to tell you, but I can’t right now!” *cue very convenient interruption.* I also find it extremely contrived when, like, three ROs just magically come to see you at the same time, and the choice is blatantly “Who do you want to romance?”
Anyway … next review will be Hunter: The Reckoning — Day For Night! This will come as no surprise to anyone, but I have a Lot of Thoughts!™️
