Kate's Reviews (New: If It Please the Court)

The People’s House

By R. F. Kramer

:star::star::star::star::star::star::star::star:☆☆ (8/10)

Published March 2025, ~400,000 words

The People’s House is an impressive political simulation where you become President of the United States. You begin at birth and make choices throughout childhood, adolescence, education, career, and eventually political life, with those decisions gradually shaping the person who ends up in the White House. And then, once you actually get there, the game throws basically everything at you.

And when I say “everything,” I mean everything. In my playthrough, I become the first woman president—the first openly gay woman president. I built my own political agenda, dealt with Israel and Palestine, Russia, China, the Taliban, corruption, labor disputes, hurricanes, cyberattacks, midterms, foreign policy crises, marriage problems, an impeachment threat, and approximately fourteen million other things. I felt less like a president and more like I was strapped into a chair, blindfolded, spun around three times, while the entire geopolitical situation of the planet was repeatedly chucked at my head.

Overall, my biggest issues with The People’s House are less about the substance and more about how difficult the game makes it to understand what is actually happening beneath the surface. The game is ambitious and dense, but I think it could benefit from slowing down, signposting its systems more clearly, and giving players a little more room to understand the people and events it throws at them.

Pros:

:white_check_mark: Your choices matter. A lot. This is probably why I’m giving the game an 8 instead of 7. Decisions you make early in your life can follow you for years. The game’s early choices are incredibly important and have a trickle-down effect five chapters later. For example, you chose your state, your economic background, your school and field of study, your profession, whether you married for love, money, or political connections, and how many kids you have and their ages. So, I’m repping California all the way, baby, making me a solid Democrat. I chose to be upper class, giving me some sweet $$$ for my PAC. I studied law (true!) at Stanford (not true, sadly) and decided to work at a civil rights firm, then rose to Attorney General, which drew a lot of comments. Marrying for love gave me a sweet, supportive spouse who was a bit naive about politics and couldn’t quite cope with the attention of being First Lady. And so on.

:white_check_mark: The game takes the presidency surprisingly seriously. You aren’t choosing between “good” and “bad” options and watching the game politely congratulate you for being a good president. Sometimes the thing you think is obviously the morally right decision comes back to bite you spectacularly. So, you can try to do the right thing and still piss someone off. You can compromise and get accused of selling out. You can make a decision that seems reasonable at the time and discover later that you accidentally created an entirely new problem. Basically: everyone hates you, even when you’re trying your best.

:right_arrow: The People’s House is a very earnest game about public service. It doesn’t seem particularly interested in telling you that politics is inherently meaningless—far from it—or that every politician is secretly terrible. Instead, it puts you in the position of someone who wants to make things better and then asks what happens when good intentions collide with competing interests. I came to the slightly unnerving conclusion that being sincere, competent, and well-intentioned is not enough to govern successfully.

:white_check_mark: You can create your own political agenda. What’s the point of being President if you can’t shape the nation the way you want? So you can propose a progressive, moderate, or conservative agenda and decide what issues to focus on. For example, I chose to play as a moderate, “work across the aisle” Democrat and focused on education, climate change, and rural farmers—which got me a tad bit of praise.

:white_check_mark: The family stuff is surprisingly sweet. Some of the domestic scenes are quite cute, especially because they provide a much-needed reminder that there’s a person underneath the status. I particularly liked that the game lets your political career strain your marriage, with options to reconcile or have a sham marriage.

Mixed:

:yellow_square: There is a lot of reading, and not everything is interactive. Thanks, Captain Obvious! No, seriously, though. Plenty of sections have you reading through ten straight scenes of dialogue and description rather than making decisions. I didn’t necessarily mind this, but the game could have cut down on these non-interactive parts, particularly during some of the larger international sequences. Sometimes you travel halfway around the world, shake hands, smile for photo ops, receive several paragraphs of political context … and then you get one choice.

Cons:

:red_square: The game can be opaque about why you succeed or fail. The People’s House clearly has many systems operating beneath the surface, but it doesn’t tell you which ones are being used. I’ll make a decision, continue playing, and eventually something catastrophic happens. Okay. Why? Was it my approval rating? My relationship with Congress? A hidden stat? A decision I made three chapters ago? Something I said during a foreign-policy meeting? If I’m heading toward an undesirable ending, I’d prefer to know sooner rather than later. Don’t make me spend another twenty minutes discovering that I apparently doomed my presidency several decisions ago!

:red_square: Needs an editing pass. I found several issues: pronoun changes, missing vocative commas, tense shifts between past and imperfect constructions, and typos.

:red_square: The number of characters. A lot of people are thrown at you. Senators, governors, cabinet members, foreign leaders, campaign staff, spouses, ambassadors, activists, party officials, just to name a few. And while I don’t necessarily mind the relatively thin characterization (I think it works reasonably well), it does mean many of these people eventually blur together. Literally, who the hell are these people?

The next review will be An Unexpectedly Green Journey!

34 Likes