Tudor Intrigue
By James Young
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
☆☆☆ (7/10)
Published February 2019, ~175,000 words
Tudor Intrigue is a very strange game to review because I simultaneously think its scope is really fucking cool, and that the actual experience of playing it can be frustratingly thin. This is an alternate-history Tudor game where you can fuck with the course of history as you please: reform England’s laws, marry into the royal family, decide whether England becomes Protestant or Catholic, manipulate the line of succession, and apparently go so far off the rails that you can end up with the Thirteen Colonies centuries ahead of schedule. The branching is insane.
However, I struggle to justify an 8/10 review. I had a lot of fun poking at the game’s alternate histories, but the surrounding elements feel underdeveloped. The characters are blank slates, the “romance” is barely there, and the endings often feel more like abrupt stopping points than conclusions. Still, it is a cool historical sandbox.
Pros:
Choices and replayability. Man, I love how Young treated time passing. At each moment, you’ll have a set number of events, but you can only choose a couple. The game explicitly presents this as something like “1 out of 3 events” completed, and I really like that framing; it makes the passage of time feel tangible. You’ll also have a little subsection called “rumors at court,” which brings a bit of gossip: Martin Luther, the King’s wandering eye, some war, and so on. The events you choose also branch into more choices, and even the little things matter, like playing tennis instead of going to church to play. And that’s why I kept replaying it—three times! I finished my first playthrough in under an hour and immediately thought, “Okay, but what happens if I do this?” One playthrough had me involved in religious reform; another had me focused on court politics and expanding my land and wealth. And then one had me beheaded. The game offers so many possible historical outcomes that it has an almost absurd amount of replayability for its short length.
The writing and historical atmosphere are good. Tudor Intrigue is definitely more of an “interactive history book” than a character-driven historical drama, but I still liked the writing. The prose has a restrained, formal, slightly melancholy quality, and the numerous historical details give the game a strong sense of place. I also appreciated the presentation of the text itself: character names and major events are bolded, which made it easier to follow along. (And there’s a ton of familiar names and events. Super cool.)
Mixed:
Truth be told, it’s more history book than story. I mean, I like it, but there’s relatively little dialogue and not much traditional character development. You mostly watch historical events unfold and decide how to influence them, rather than spending much time getting to know the people involved. The narrative is very “you do X, which results in Y” or “A happens, and B reacts like so.”
Cons:
The characters are extremely thin. This is the most “objective” con. There are many major historical figures and potential relationships, but there isn’t much opportunity to develop them. At most, the characters get a few lines and light characterization. Romance, in particular, is almost nonexistent. Even if you marry the King, you get a few lines about courtship, marriage, and your happiness (or lack thereof), then you’re basically shuttled to the next event. There’s a lot of missed potential here for court drama, deeper rivalries, more gossip, or complicated marriages!
Some of the endings are hilariously abrupt. I had one ending where I #girlbossed too hard: rising above my station, marrying the King, brokering peace between England and France, building up an estate, and so on. Then the game basically went: “Your enemies are plotting against you; the King is disappointed you gave him a daughter. Do you resist your enemies or bow out?” Now, my mom raised a complainer, but not a quitter, so of course I went with “Resist your enemies.” And then, one page later: “Your head is chopped off.”
BRUH.
Come on, now, man. I don’t necessarily need every ending to be happy, but for such a tragic ending, a player needs time to actually experience the … experience. How did I go from defiant to having my head on the chopping block in one second? What happened to my family: my older brother, who was at court with me, and my newborn daughter? If the King didn’t give a damn about me—fine!—but how and when did that happen?
This abruptness was also extended to a “good” ending. My Charisma and Intelligence was high enough to put my preferred candidate—Prince Edward—on the throne. I successfully brokered a marriage between Princess Mary—another claimant to the throne—and my younger brother. So now, the future should be mine for the taking; I have a royal marriage, and I am a Kingmaker. But then—boom. The “Play Again” text.
Listen, I get it. Endings are hard, especially with so many moving parts. But endings need to feel complete. In this case, I think the endings needed to be more expansive and a little more explicit about their consequences. This doesn’t necessarily mean giving every ending a neat epilogue or spelling out exactly what happens for the next fifty years. But give me a few paragraphs of vague historical musing at least. Perhaps Edward’s reign will be stable, perhaps Mary’s marriage will prevent another succession crisis, perhaps my family’s influence will continue to grow. But it’s important to give the player a glimpse of the future they’ve created because, ya know, it goes back to the whole point of playing text-based games: to show that my decisions actually mattered.
Next review will be The People’s House!
