Vampire: The Masquerade — Sins of the Sires
By Natalia Theodoridou
![]()
![]()
☆☆☆☆☆☆☆ (3/10)
Okayyyyyyy, then. Yeah, yeah, I see why Vampire: The Masquerade — Sins of the Sires (“SofS”) has such a controversial rating in the fandom. Because it’s frankly, uh, not good. Incredibly rushed and disappointing. I finished the game in one hour. One. And while I am a fast reader, most CoG/HG titles are twice that length. I literally checked the word count on the Steam page after finishing the game because I thought no way, is the game over already. While Theodoridou’s writing is as lovely and philosophical as ever, it’s not enough to hide how flat, nonsensical, and lacking SofS is, both as a narrative and as a Vampire: The Masquerade game. Thank you to the staff for the free copy!
Pros:
Writing/atmosphere. I’ve quite enjoyed Theodoridou’s previous games: Rent-a-Vice and The Odyssey. I’ve pointed out his flaws as a writer in the past—the narrowing linearity of some choices and abrupt endings—but I’ve always liked the philosophical glimmers present in a usually dark setting. While oddly choppy at the beginning, SofS’s prose is beautiful and hammers home how grim the VtM setting can be. There are also a lot of Greek myths and allusions I haven’t quite caught.
Cons:
Rushed pacing and numerous dropped plot threads. *Sigh*. Man, I don’t even know what to say or where to begin. Listen, the criticisms were right. I finished one playthrough and thought a draft of the game was uploaded by accident. There are maybe three good chapters of build-up, but at the climax, everything just jerks forward and collapses under its own weight. First, characters who seem significant—with their own custom portraits, even!—are mentioned once or twice, then never reappear. And here, I’m not fond of the “branching” excuse. Chekhov’s gun and all that. Important characters should show up and pay off no matter which route you take. Second, some events are hinted at, then disappear from the narrative. I had an encounter with a mortal policewoman who saw me feeding (isn’t that a big no-no?) and wished to team up to hunt worse vampires. Never saw her again. The player being the childe of Markos has literally no emotional impact and is barely considered. The alliance between him and Sophia is also incredibly random. There’s also a strange focus on protecting your friend, Alex, but I didn’t even meet them??? WHO is this person. You get to pick between having a lover, sibling, or parent you loved, but in my case (the lover), you yearn, see them once, leave them with a promise to come back, and never see them again. RIP to all these ideas.
Not to beat a dead horse, but I take issue with the climax and endings. I seriously had no idea what the hell happened—and! I replayed through the endings a couple of times. So, the main climax, I think, is that you get to choose between three claimants to be Prince of the city. The problem is that I did not gaf about any of them and their motivations. All I know is that one woman is trying to manipulate me, so she’s a girlboss? And that the Prince hates women, which is the most low-hanging fruit ever, and he has a mysterious number two who is trying to backstab him. The best (worst?) thing is that I had a successful rebellion path, a successful loyalty path, and a failed loyalty path. All three, besides some flavor text, were virtually the same. Win or lose, I was in the same spot in each branch. The conflict itself feels so out of place and shoehorned in. Also, what the hell was up with Aristovoros? Dude gets a one-liner about oh, he was just made up by Sophia???
The endings were also in the same rushed, disjointed style. One I remember is sparing the vampire at the end of the game, which allows you to brood mysteriously. I also got an ending where I took on an apprentice, lived with him and his parents, then them staking me and leaving me for dead for centuries. When you wake up, the world is gone: no animals or humans or nature. Huh??? Now where did this come from.
Because of the above, the characters across the board have no real story to tell. Sure, the characters could be interesting, but you’re given no time to get to know them or any chance to talk to them. I didn’t really understand why Sophia wanted to rebel, and I didn’t care about Marko’s whole … shtick. I didn’t find anyone particularly likable, either. There’s also … no relationship stats? Which throws me off quite a bit.
Not a good VtM game. All previous WoD games, flaws and all, have excellent gameplay. So first, I’m going to take points off for not having a Storyteller mode, which makes the already scant choices even more frustrating. I also didn’t think there were as many choices as expected. There’s virtually no resource management, your powers are underused, and there are no “trade-off” scenarios like in other games, where you have to choose between investigating X or Y. SofS plays more like a visual novel, almost. You’re quite the passive observer, watching time pass.
Awkward handling of pronouns. Not going to harp on it too much, but asking for the player’s pronouns came off as quite contrived. You meet an intimidating man who says:
“What are your pronouns?”
“First you try to threaten and intimidate me, then you ask for my pronouns?”
He shrugs. “I’m a civilized monster, what can I say?”
I suspect the game is trying to lampshade the awkwardness for comedic effect, but the exchange felt too self-aware, and acknowledging how unnatural the question is doesn’t make it feel any less contrived. Just … have someone refer to you by the pronoun? Or do the cliché “I look in the mirror to find …”
Next review will be Vampire: The Masquerade — Parliament of Knives, which surely, SURELY I will enjoy more!
