Kate's Reviews (New: If It Please the Court)

Professor of Magical Studies

By Stephen Granade

:star::star::star::star::star:☆☆☆☆☆ (5/10)

Ngl, I kinda feel bad about giving Professor of Magical Studies a thumbs down. Like, it’s not a bad work by any means. It has its flaws, sure, but it’s generally well-liked and well-written. But the author has a clear vision, and sadly, I didn’t vibe with it. At all. You see, I was hoping for a “light academia” aesthetic, where I play as a professor, romance a coworker, and tutor the young, bright minds of tomorrow. I got that—somewhat. However, Stephen Granade veers more into the dark academia aesthetic.

To be quite frank, Professor of Magical Studies annoyed and frustrated me. The game focuses less on teaching and more on juggling the different stressors of a junior faculty member—one with magic. You will have to study pattern magic (very cool!), groom your apprenticeship, find love, deal with gentrification, focus on research, participate in service, spend funds, sabotage (or help) your coworker/rival, jostle for tenure, and save the universe. As you might imagine, that is A Lot™️ . I found juggling three areas, max, difficult enough, and it did pain me when I failed in other areas. I felt like taffy getting pulled in every direction. Your stress will also increase because of conniving and/or inept coworkers who insist on being nuisances. All in all, Professor of Magical Studies is a rather grim, dark work that wasn’t exactly fun for me. YMMV. Still, I am forever grateful to the staff for giving me a free copy.

Pros:
:white_check_mark: Magic system. Granade’s magic system is incredibly fascinating and unique. It’s all about patterns. You can have your own method of pattern magic: are you more logical and need patterns as diagrams on flashcards? Or do you use memorized poems to help you focus? These patterns can do anything, even shape the world. To be honest, I didn’t quite understand it all, but I know it was cool and a welcome departure from Harry Potter spells.

:white_check_mark: Good use of flashbacks. Flashbacks are always hard to pull off, but Granade pulls them off well. They’re a good way to establish lore and characters without awkward time skips. They worked well because, as a player, I still had choices that affected the present. Plus, they showed off his worldbuilding too!

:white_check_mark: Clear choices. I don’t know why I noticed this, but Granade has some of the clearest, signposted choices. He uses the stat keywords in each choice, so there’s no confusion. Much appreciated. His prose is readable, too, with lots of detail.

:white_check_mark: The Lodger is fucking hilarious. Did I think it was fanservice (especially the poly romance)? Yes. Did I roll with it? Also yes.

Cons:
:red_square: Tone. I truly don’t know how to make this constructive: everyone is annoying. Is this on purpose, to give conflict and stakes? Absolutely. Did it go overboard imo? Sorta, yes. A group of characters will make your life miserable. They will belittle, taunt, and even attack you, and you cannot do much except verbally snap back. The payoff comes at the end, but it’s too far and too few for me. I hate you Wilcox, Blankenship, and Darcy. Truly, I’m the biggest hater, I hate the way that you walk, the way that you talk, I hate the way that you dress, I hate the way that you sneak diss etc. etc.

:red_square: Ending. Again, this is such a personal quibble, but I wasn’t a fan of the Vastness subplot. I tend to roll my eyes at world-ending threats—not because the stakes are low, but because they feel too high to be personal. When everything is on the line, the danger becomes abstract, and the outcome feels foregone. Billions will die? Damn, that sucks. The big bad is scary? Nothing I’ve heard before. In general, I already know the world won’t end; the franchise exists, the sequel is loading, the save file is safe. So for me, the last couple of characters dragged on because I wasn’t interested in the Vastness.

:red_square: ROs. For some reason, I was not interested in the ROs. I’m a pretty simple reader: give me a pretty face and honeyed words, and I’m a sucker. However, I was irritated, or “meh,” by the ROs. I think for at least three of them, their introduction or impression was rooted in conflict. Darcy is … well, Darcy. (More on them below.) I wasn’t a fan of how the narrative reintroduced Manisha. They are missing, possibly dead, and the reunion is rather stilted and oddly confrontational. For example, when they found out the MC was a professor, I think I recall them becoming withdrawn because they believed the college was harmful to the town. I do remember at least two scenes talking about magical gentrification, which … I get? But to me, it seemed rather heavy-handed and oddly modern. Similarly, Hayley’s only personality trait was being a blue-collar worker who also did not like us uppity college elites. What happened to hello? How are you? My name is?

:red_square: Darcy. I’m sorry, my only notes for this character are “FUCK YOU, DARCY.” I think the author was going for an enemies-to-lovers route, but it was more like they treat you like garbage, and you take it. I’m serious when they have little to no redeeming qualities. At every moment, they make your life worse with sneak disses, rudeness, and an unapologetic attitude. I’m still not over how they betrayed you. For me, they also refused to help with the end-of-the-world stuff. Which, whatever. I’m not even going to waste my time.

:red_square: The art. I was also not a fan of the character portraits. It looked like Artbreeder generated it, though you can turn it off!

18 Likes