# Kate's Reviews (New: I, The Forgotten One)

**URL:** <https://forum.choiceofgames.com/t/kates-reviews-new-i-the-forgotten-one/174532>\
**Category:** General\
**Created:** [November 16, 2025, 4:16am UTC](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/t/kates-reviews-new-i-the-forgotten-one/174532 "2025-11-16T04:16:31Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 20\
**Page:** 43

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Jacic](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/choiceofgames/user_avatar/forum.choiceofgames.com/jacic/32/7061_2.png) [@Jacic](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/u/Jacic)\
**Post date:** [November 18, 2026, 3:32am UTC](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/t/kates-reviews-new-i-the-forgotten-one/174532/846 "2026-11-18T03:32:07Z")

</div>

> [@plupersholicorn](#):
>
> I’m curious as to what you consider a 1/10!

Something like this? [Uninteractive Fiction - Details](https://ifdb.org/viewgame?id=37653cvcj7tymctg)

Or is it a masterpiece in disguise. Reviews are divided 😄

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Kate27](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/choiceofgames/user_avatar/forum.choiceofgames.com/kate27/32/122409_2.png) [@Kate27](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/u/Kate27)\
**Post date:** [November 18, 2026, 4:19am UTC](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/t/kates-reviews-new-i-the-forgotten-one/174532/847 "2026-11-18T04:19:10Z")

</div>

> [@plupersholicorn](#):
>
> Eloquent and articulate, as always.

Thank you, my friend!

> [@plupersholicorn](#):
>
> I’m curious as to what you consider a 1/10!

Damn, I dunno what would force me to give a 1/10! I know I wouldn’t give a 0; I think the act of writing and publishing _something_ gets some credit. And I would probably add a point if the prose was readable—not even good. The only IF I straight up _disliked_ was _[Love at Elevation](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/t/kates-reviews-new-i-the-forgotten-one/174532/75)_ for its insistence on being a bit “woo-woo,” new-age, alternative medicine, and odd, judgemental tone, and that was still a 3/10. I’m hoping to read the company’s whole catalog one day. We’ll find something that’s just … _bad_ all around, I’m sure!

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Jacic](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/choiceofgames/user_avatar/forum.choiceofgames.com/jacic/32/7061_2.png) [@Jacic](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/u/Jacic)\
**Post date:** [November 18, 2026, 5:01am UTC](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/t/kates-reviews-new-i-the-forgotten-one/174532/848 "2026-11-18T05:01:00Z")

</div>

Yeah… the odd judgy tone of Love at Elevation got me as well. DNF.

It was actually a contracted game that seemed to get shunted to HG on completion, so I guess you’re not alone in being concerned about the content reception.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Kate27](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/choiceofgames/user_avatar/forum.choiceofgames.com/kate27/32/122409_2.png) [@Kate27](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/u/Kate27)\
**Post date:** [November 18, 2026, 5:33am UTC](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/t/kates-reviews-new-i-the-forgotten-one/174532/849 "2026-11-18T05:33:40Z")

</div>

> [@Jacic](#):
>
> Yeah… the odd judgy tone of Love at Elevation got me as well. DNF.

I did not know you read it, too! And now I feel vindicated in my haterism hehe.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![malinryden](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/choiceofgames/user_avatar/forum.choiceofgames.com/malinryden/32/272913_2.png) [@malinryden](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/u/malinryden)\
**Post date:** [November 18, 2026, 7:07am UTC](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/t/kates-reviews-new-i-the-forgotten-one/174532/850 "2026-11-18T07:07:26Z")

</div>

> [@Kate27](#):
>
> Yoooooo, why is it that when I write a negative review as a #hater, all the authors come out of the woodwork to reply??? No one cares about the positive reviews! Do y’all secretly like rants that dissect every aspect of a work???

It’s the dissection! I always said that I learn more from a long negative review than a positive one, because people seldom gets as eloquent as when they try to articulate what they **don’t** like with a game. And, unlike positive reviews, you can be fairly sure they come from the heart, and not from niceness or some money incentive. I have bought games in the past based on the negative reviews…

Like this one. I do love ITFO (it is one of my favorite IF’s (look, I need my pain, and I like my wars)) but I can’t really say you’re wrong in your review. It’s just that some of the things you don’t care for are some of the things I do, and some things that didn’t land for you did for me. If I hadn’t played this game and read the review I would go “oh, I need to check out the demo I think, to see how things land for me”. Same when I read some of your positive reviews and decide that game really is not for me.

You’re very good at articulating things in a way that, even if you don’t like them, you will be fair and clear enough that people who do like these things will be able to see from your negative review that it might be for them.

And when it’s about your own game? That’s a learning experience!

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![dorquemada](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/choiceofgames/user_avatar/forum.choiceofgames.com/dorquemada/32/256858_2.png) [@dorquemada](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/u/dorquemada)\
**Post date:** [November 18, 2026, 7:53am UTC](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/t/kates-reviews-new-i-the-forgotten-one/174532/851 "2026-11-18T07:53:37Z")

</div>

Yeah, what MR said up there. Fantastic review. I not as much disagree, but like a lot of things in it for the same reason you hate them, but if I were a writer I’d be giddy with such a review. 🙂

As an aside, there is no notion more idiotically wrong than “If you can’t say anything nice, don’t say anything at all”, case in point. Like, there is just very limited number of ways you can gush like “OMG this or that RO is soooo cute, squee! 😍”, (and it’s fucking boring to read) but impressive number of ways to go “This didn’t work for me, here’s an extensive list why” (and it might stimulate your brain to come up with counter-arguments!) .

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![GeneralEnigma](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/g/839c29/32.png) [@GeneralEnigma](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/u/GeneralEnigma)\
**Post date:** [November 18, 2026, 8:12am UTC](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/t/kates-reviews-new-i-the-forgotten-one/174532/852 "2026-11-18T08:12:11Z")

</div>

I unfortunately don’t have the time to write a more detailed reply, but I am _fascinated_ by the fact that the same things that drew you away from ItFO (dry prose, uninteresting characters, constant “woe is me”, etc.) are a mixture of what prevents me from liking the Sea of Infinity and Fallen Hero series, while at the same time, I’d give ItFO a 9/10 or something! 😂😂😂

There’s probably some deep insight in there on the intricate ways a piece of art succeeds or fails in resonating with a given person 😝

Great review as always! I’m extremely excited (and nervous!) to see what you think of _Challenger of Tomorrow_

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![malinryden](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/choiceofgames/user_avatar/forum.choiceofgames.com/malinryden/32/272913_2.png) [@malinryden](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/u/malinryden)\
**Post date:** [November 18, 2026, 8:19am UTC](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/t/kates-reviews-new-i-the-forgotten-one/174532/853 "2026-11-18T08:19:11Z")

</div>

> [@GeneralEnigma](#):
>
> There’s probably some deep insight in there on the intricate ways a piece of art succeeds or fails in resonating with a given person

Reading is a team sport!

Honestly, it’s a constant dialogue between author - prose - reader, with each adding a massive chunk to the end result. Sometimes there’s just a mismatch, like I always say, not all books are for all people, there is nothing wrong with that.

There are some legitimately beloved and good IF’s out there that I just… can’t.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![GeneralEnigma](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/g/839c29/32.png) [@GeneralEnigma](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/u/GeneralEnigma)\
**Post date:** [November 18, 2026, 8:36am UTC](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/t/kates-reviews-new-i-the-forgotten-one/174532/854 "2026-11-18T08:36:24Z")

</div>

> [@malinryden](#):
>
> Reading is a team sport!

Absolutely!

For instance, I played ItFO in a moment in my life of professional and romantic disappointment, so the game was very cathartic and the sort of experience I needed. Had I played it at some other time, perhaps my opinion of it would be different.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Writing\_Fever](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/choiceofgames/user_avatar/forum.choiceofgames.com/writing_fever/32/269728_2.png) [@Writing\_Fever](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/u/Writing_Fever)\
**Post date:** [November 18, 2026, 2:19pm UTC](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/t/kates-reviews-new-i-the-forgotten-one/174532/855 "2026-11-18T14:19:51Z")

</div>

> [@Kate27](#):
>
> Do y’all secretly like rants that dissect every aspect of a work???

I’m not saying I’d beg for a similar review from you for my own works…

…but I’m not _not_ saying it, either!

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Hamartia](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/choiceofgames/user_avatar/forum.choiceofgames.com/hamartia/32/264056_2.png) [@Hamartia](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/u/Hamartia)\
**Post date:** [November 18, 2026, 3:11pm UTC](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/t/kates-reviews-new-i-the-forgotten-one/174532/856 "2026-11-18T15:11:54Z")

</div>

> [@Kate27](#):
>
> **The Marshal’s characterization**

I had a real feeling you’d bounce off the Marshal hard, given your experience with FH1, hence my earlier meme haha.

I actually think JL is a great writer, I really really like Whiskey-Four (an excellently paced, structured and executed story imo) and ITFO has some great moments later on, but the Marshal made it a tough read for me too.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![MeltingPenguins](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/choiceofgames/user_avatar/forum.choiceofgames.com/meltingpenguins/32/255855_2.png) [@MeltingPenguins](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/u/MeltingPenguins)\
**Post date:** [November 18, 2026, 5:18pm UTC](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/t/kates-reviews-new-i-the-forgotten-one/174532/857 "2026-11-18T17:18:04Z")

</div>

I tried thinking of a single game in the library that would actually fulfil the possible requirements for an absolute semi-objective stinker, and came up blank.  
Because, a genuine 1/10 would, I’d argue, have to be (in no specific order):

- Not just lacking actual interactivity, but pretending that there is some.
- All while the author outright mocks, scolds, belittles and even punishes the reader for ‘playing wrong’ aka picking choices the author did not envision for _their_ story (includes disagreeing with the author’s view on things should that come up)
- the choices that are _not_ part of the authors vision also would have to be very clearly been adding in begrudgingly. Not a iota of care, if anything even happens in them at all. All while the text tells you how terrible a person you are for not picking the clearly superior option.
- Not having much a story at all. Bonus minus points if the author goes on long tangents about irrelevant unrelated things that they expect you to 100% agree with.
- Non-existent world- and character building. Or a parade of negative stereotypes. Maybe both.
- Verbosity for the sake of the wordcount.

That’d be what I’d say would make a genuine, irredeemable stinker. But as said, I can’t think of any game that’d tick of all these boxes, so I’d say you’re safe?

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![fsix](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/f/c2a13f/32.png) [@fsix](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/u/fsix)\
**Post date:** [November 18, 2026, 11:11pm UTC](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/t/kates-reviews-new-i-the-forgotten-one/174532/858 "2026-11-18T23:11:08Z")

</div>

> [@dorquemada](#):
>
> As an aside, there is no notion more idiotically wrong than “If you can’t say anything nice, don’t say anything at all”, case in point.

I don’t know if this review is really much of a case in this particular point, tbh. I mean, yes, it is articulate about what aspects the reviewer didn’t like, but… at the same point, hearing “i didn’t like A, B and C” when A, B and C are all the basic blocks of how the story in question is built, that’s kind of useless for the author in the sense these complaints can’t really be addressed without writing a different story in different style.

Of course, this is all useful as a review for potential readers who might share the dislike(s) for such particular blocks/approach and so they can appreciate the heads up. But from viewpoint of the author (and that’s usually the context where “if you can’t say anything nice…” comes up) it’s not really any different than the gushing about a cute RO and similarly, not inherently interesting.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![La\_Cucaracha1](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/choiceofgames/user_avatar/forum.choiceofgames.com/la_cucaracha1/32/257213_2.png) [@La\_Cucaracha1](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/u/La_Cucaracha1)\
**Post date:** [November 18, 2026, 11:46pm UTC](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/t/kates-reviews-new-i-the-forgotten-one/174532/859 "2026-11-18T23:46:31Z")

</div>

Well well well, i know that recommending a work solely so it can be called a stinker bad taste, but maybe Kate could find a work that passes every single one of those “preerequisites” in “EXODUS: Climate Activis”? I can’t remember a single game in recent memory who got torn apart as hard as it was both on the subreddit and in the google play/steam reviews, and playing it myself, i can say that, for me, every single one of the complaints are true.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Kate27](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/choiceofgames/user_avatar/forum.choiceofgames.com/kate27/32/122409_2.png) [@Kate27](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/u/Kate27)\
**Post date:** [November 19, 2026, 2:47am UTC](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/t/kates-reviews-new-i-the-forgotten-one/174532/860 "2026-11-19T02:47:31Z")

</div>

> [@malinryden](#):
>
> I always said that I learn more from a long negative review than a positive one, because people seldom gets as eloquent as when they try to articulate what they **don’t** like with a game.

Yes, for me, when I write negative reviews, I always end up adding more justifications and examples to make my point. Almost as if I’m preemptively responding to criticism … from whom? An imaginary audience, as this community has been perfectly lovely!

> [@malinryden](#):
>
> I do love ITFO (it is one of my favorite IF’s (look, I need my pain, and I like my wars)) but I can’t really say you’re wrong in your review. It’s just that some of the things you don’t care for are some of the things I do, and some things that didn’t land for you did for me.

Omgggggg I literally thought of you while reading this review. You mentioned once that we have very different tastes in games, and that really tickled me, for some reason! You mentioned not vibing with _Jolly Good_ and _Crème de la Crème_ (the happiest, most uplifting games); I loved those ones. I also remember you liking even the later books of _Samurai of Hyuga_ 😂😂😂 Me? It’s not even a matter of _liking_ depressing themes; I just don’t have the patience for it! Come on, we gotta move through the hero’s journey soon; we only have so many words left!

> [@malinryden](#):
>
> Same when I read some of your positive reviews and decide that game really is not for me.

… I gotta admit, I didn’t even think this would be an outcome of my reviews. Oops, sorry to all those authors out there who now have one less potential sale 🙏

> [@malinryden](#):
>
> You’re very good at articulating things in a way that, even if you don’t like them, you will be fair and clear enough that people who do like these things will be able to see from your negative review that it might be for them.

Thanks very much for this comment, Malin! I try to cut my analysis in half, like King Solomon, into two parts: what objectively happened, and what I subjectively feel about it.

> [@dorquemada](#):
>
> Like, there is just very limited number of ways you can gush like “OMG this or that RO is soooo cute, squee! 😍”, (and it’s fucking boring to read) but impressive number of ways to go “This didn’t work for me, here’s an extensive list why” (and it might stimulate your brain to come up with counter-arguments!) .

Ngl, sometimes I feel this way with some 7/10s. I _like_ X or Y, but it’s much easier sometimes to write about what I _didn’t_ like. Plus, I feel like there’s a part of any audience that feels a bit of schadenfreude at negative reviews 😅

> [@GeneralEnigma](#):
>
> I am _fascinated_ by the fact that the same things that drew you away from ItFO (dry prose, uninteresting characters, constant “woe is me”, etc.) are a mixture of what prevents me from liking the Sea of Infinity and Fallen Hero series, while at the same time, I’d give ItFO a 9/10 or something! 😂😂😂

This is crazy to me!!! The “woe is me” factor is multiplied by a thousand in ITFO compared to the _Infinity_ and FH series! Which is probably why I didn’t mind it too much in the first _Fallen Hero_. When Sidestep was doing their thing, I could just … look away, pretend I do not see it, etc. 😛

> [@GeneralEnigma](#):
>
> I’m extremely excited (and nervous!) to see what you think of _Challenger of Tomorrow_

I am literally only 35 minutes in so far, but it’s great. I know that whatever else may happen, William Brown can fucking _write_ a sentence. Any sentence.

> [@Hamartia](#):
>
> I really really like Whiskey-Four (an excellently paced, structured and executed story imo)

I still have Whiskey-Four on my wishlist! But it’s slowly sinking down in my priority …

> [@fsix](#):
>
> hearing “i didn’t like A, B and C” when A, B and C are all the basic blocks of how the story in question is built, that’s kind of useless for the author in the sense these complaints can’t really be addressed without writing a different story in different style.
> 
> Of course, this is all useful as a review for potential readers who might share the dislike(s) for such particular blocks/approach and so they can appreciate the heads up.

Yep, some of my feedback (in this review and in general) is for sure not actionable, BUT it’s there for whoever wants to read it: authors, fans, potential readers, etc.

> [@La\_Cucaracha1](#):
>
> EXODUS: Climate Activis

Yaaaaa, I remember reading the feedback about this one on the subreddit. And after skimming through the first chapter just now, it would come pretty damn close to a one or two out of ten. It would be one of those that just go in my Ignore pile, tbh!

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![malinryden](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/choiceofgames/user_avatar/forum.choiceofgames.com/malinryden/32/272913_2.png) [@malinryden](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/u/malinryden)\
**Post date:** [November 19, 2026, 6:29am UTC](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/t/kates-reviews-new-i-the-forgotten-one/174532/861 "2026-11-19T06:29:15Z")

</div>

> [@Kate27](#):
>
> You mentioned not vibing with _Jolly Good_ and Crème de la Crème (the happiest, most uplifting games)

I know they are by any metric really good games! But they give me such massive social anxiety I’ve never made it past the demo… I guess I need my particular pit of dank depression to feel comfortable 😅

So I would never judge anyone for bouncing off my games because they can’t get into Sidestep’s headspace…

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![HarrisPS](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/choiceofgames/user_avatar/forum.choiceofgames.com/harrisps/32/240120_2.png) [@HarrisPS](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/u/HarrisPS)\
**Post date:** [November 19, 2026, 7:45am UTC](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/t/kates-reviews-new-i-the-forgotten-one/174532/862 "2026-11-19T07:45:16Z")

</div>

I always find it funny when people call Creme de la Creme cosy/chill, I’m like “…the game where the characters are stressed out all the time?” haha! (I have lots of cosy fuzzy feelings about The Terror Pathologic 2 so who even knows where I fall on liking depressing vs cheerful stuff anyway)

But yeah I have a lot of fun reading Kate’s reviews, of my things and others, and always enjoy the detail you go into!

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![dorquemada](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/choiceofgames/user_avatar/forum.choiceofgames.com/dorquemada/32/256858_2.png) [@dorquemada](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/u/dorquemada)\
**Post date:** [November 19, 2026, 11:49am UTC](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/t/kates-reviews-new-i-the-forgotten-one/174532/863 "2026-11-19T11:49:05Z")

</div>

> [@fsix](#):
>
> hearing “i didn’t like A, B and C” when A, B and C are all the basic blocks of how the story in question is built, that’s kind of useless for the author in the sense these complaints can’t really be addressed without writing a different story in different style.

I don’t think it’s all that useless. Author might go “Huh? What? Where did they read that, _how_ did they read that? I didn’t write that!”. It’s also a different point of view to your story, I think it’s at least interesting to see those.

> [@HarrisPS](#):
>
> people call Creme de la Creme cosy/chill, I’m like “…the game where the characters are stressed out all the time?

Yeah, but they’re stressed about school stuff like grades and extracurriculars and what colour frills to wear to the next posh twa…people ball. That’s _adorable_.

Also, maybe it’s just me, but the thing that contributes quite a bit to warm and fuzzy atmosphere of your stories is that nobody\[1\] gets murdered even when it makes sense. Like, disappear people into the mines and they come back to bite you in the arse, disappear them into the bottom of the lake with concrete shoes and they don’t.  
 ![Big Brain Meme: Man Taps Forehead](https://static.klipy.com/ii/d6b0ce929193df3c242ac34b5654d2ce/bb/7e/hmEPdqgT.webp)

> [@HarrisPS](#):
>
> cosy fuzzy feelings about The Terror Pathologic 2

Is the Terror, as in TV series The Terror? This one is fuzzy and cosy, I agree. Fluffy-bearded dudes in warm coats, fuzzy polar animals, chill soundtrack, chill environment, all around lovely and rewatchable. 🙂 Patho 2, well, is cosy if you mod draconic time limits down a little and have time to soak up the atmosphere instead of frantically running from meal to meal, which is one of reasons I prefer Pathologic 1.

* * *

1. Except for that one brown-noser RO from Noblesse Oblige, but even then I have my doubts. We didn’t get to see the body after all

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Dragonlord943](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/d/a4c791/32.png) [@Dragonlord943](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/u/Dragonlord943)\
**Post date:** [November 19, 2026, 8:02pm UTC](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/t/kates-reviews-new-i-the-forgotten-one/174532/864 "2026-11-19T20:02:44Z")

</div>

> [@dorquemada](#):
>
> Yeah, but they’re stressed about school stuff like grades and extracurriculars and what colour frills to wear to the next posh twa…people ball. That’s _adorable_.

Compared to what a lot of the characters in other IFs are going through, I’d take school drama in a heartbeat.

 ![image](https://global.discourse-cdn.com/choiceofgames/original/4X/8/3/2/8323133015fcacff01f185563316357906d29d63.jpeg)

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![HarrisPS](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/choiceofgames/user_avatar/forum.choiceofgames.com/harrisps/32/240120_2.png) [@HarrisPS](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/u/HarrisPS)\
**Post date:** [November 19, 2026, 8:49pm UTC](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/t/kates-reviews-new-i-the-forgotten-one/174532/865 "2026-11-19T20:49:16Z")

</div>

@dorquemada fair points all round, haha!

Lots more death possibilities for PCs and NPCs in The Earth Has Teeth 😈

[Previous page](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/t/kates-reviews-new-i-the-forgotten-one/174532.md?page=42)

[Next page](https://forum.choiceofgames.com/t/kates-reviews-new-i-the-forgotten-one/174532.md?page=44)
