Infamous if (band wip) chap 3 (457k wrds) released (9/08/2024)

Really criticism?!

I mean I haven’t been following this thread that closely because it’s gotten so big and the author doesn’t say anything on it but I thought everyone was loving it. :face_with_raised_eyebrow:

I will avoid saying more. Lots of it throughout the pages.

It gets updates here. Links are bit above these posts. Chap 5?!

I actually have no clue

I’ve been following since the beginning, and there really hasn’t been much negativity. There has been some constructive criticism, but none of it was rude from what I could tell.

I’ll also say that Amy has never been super active on here. Usually just popping up when there’s an update. Though she hasn’t even done that in a few updates

14 Likes

She didn’t update Chapter 4 here either. I think she just is on other platforms now.

1 Like

I don’t know if that has anything to do with it but there were a lot of ’ MC is a loser ’ talks early on and I believe it was even put in FAQ by Amy.

I always liked the MC, even though they need to learn how to say ’ no ’ to people. It may be a ’ weakness ’ but it an interesting one to read.

10 Likes

Oh, that’s true. I never understood that criticism

2 Likes

One day we will look at our messages here with wistful nostalgia and think how innocent our predictions have had been. Is that the proper usage of past perfect tense, btw?

3 Likes

Well tbh, I don’t remember what a past participle is. But I can say that we wouldn’t say “have had,” as those words have the same meaning in this context, just different tenses.

Have= present tense

Had= past tense

3 Likes

It that context I’d usually just say, “were.” But if you want to use the past perfect it would be “have been.”

4 Likes

Anyone knows what in Chapter 5 determines if you can follow G and Allegra here?

1 Like

You can. You need to have not told G that you want to stay away and I believe have a generally high relationship. Maybe not laugh at G’s sister a few choices ago too.

2 Likes

I did all that and it was still locked… Bumping up the romance points to 5 did the trick though, mystery solved!

2 Likes

Thanks. This actually helped me to win the second week

Also what is the most you can get in the loved stat rn?

First time diligently (?) following a WIP. Do we really have to restart from the beginning every update or I just have to save before the latest chapter?

1 Like

It depends on the update. Usually the website won’t even let you use saves if the author changed anything that was in the demo. But if the author just adds a new chapter, then the saves will work just fine

1 Like