88

LMAO fantastic job my friend

90

The problem is that the author has no subtlety doing it, we could have something like:
“I don’t know if I want to be a boy or a girl”
Choice:“We will work something out”
" This doesn’t change anything"
“I’m seven how the hell should I answer?”
That would have been slightly better.
But here?
“We’ll it’s fine. Did I mention SEVERAL 5 YEARS OLD CHILDREN were feeling the same way? It’s TOTALLY, ABSOLUTELY FINE. Oh I’m so proud my sibling is so confident. But I still don’t understand. Doesn’t mean it isn’t fine of course.”
I mean, the MC goes from “no problem” to “I don’t understand”, to “I’m so proud of you” in something like 10 minutes.
This is not subtle at all because it’s poorly written. Some games are bringing that fact by mentioning it briefly. There it’s basically all of the character.

14 Likes
91

I am going to make a note on my vote in the polls. The title and the description just didn’t catch my interest to try the demo.

In the little time I have to do my recreational reading, I would rather reread Enchantment by Orson Scott Card if I wanted an adaptation of Rus folklore.

1 Like
92

I myself felt like the whole non binary thing just hurt the story when you’re basically forced to love them doing that. I myself couldn’t play past that since it just felt so forced upon me, just like it did in Mass Effect Andromeda. There’s no good way they introduce it, it’s basically I’m x thing, it’s so great, that’s not good writing, it’s just cringe worthy and just hurts non binary people and the story more than it does anything good.

That said, I don’t mind it when implemented in a good way but the way so many do it is just flat out bad

7 Likes
93

I saw this scene rather differently:

Your sibling tells you that they dont want to be girl. You are not sure exactly what they are aiming to say exactly, so you respond carefully with further inquiring (not that you dont understand what does it mean not wanting to be a girl, but not undersanding exactly yet what your sibling want to say in the end)
So your sibling tels you that they dont want to be neither boy nor girl. Then you nod thats ok, you dont understand the feeling yourself, as you havent had that feeling, but game narrates that there were some children who did similar declaration in the past, so the fact of declaration is not new.
Then you reasure your sibling, bringing the fact that others sometimes feel just like them.
Then you feel proud of yourself that your sibling trusted you first with that, and proud for such young child to be confident with their emotions.

I dont see ““no problem” to “I don’t understand”, to “I’m so proud of you” in something like 10 minutes.” Your character is established what they know from the beggining. They do not see the problem with being non-binary, they dont completely understand the feeling, since they havent had it themselves, and they are proud of themsleves and the sibling for confidence.

You get a page of story that is an exposition how in this village/society being non-binary is perfectly fine with everyone.
You didnt get an option to choose the response for that, because that part is the established part of this game world, the same as many other things in game that are established and you dont get an option to choose.

Because that’s apparently significant part of their identity decided for that game. And why not? There is really only a little about our sibling and that fact ties to the exposition of the village and gender norms in game’s world, so the game focuses on that. And it’s not even like your sibling mentions it in every toher sentence they are non-binary.

So you prefer when a game only mentions briefly LGBTQ characteristic and then let you forget that those people exist? :stuck_out_tongue:

You dont like when it’s “forced” upon you that you are ok with non-binary people and making no big deal of it? You can’t just believe that your character could just treat it like a normal thing, and you need whole long detailed explanation why would you be ok with that?

How does it hurt the story, if your character is “forced” to just not be a bigot?

5 Likes
97

Let’s remember to respect each other in this thread. We are all members of the same community so just keep that in mind when discussing this topic.

13 Likes