@Sneaks as I said, I’ve played countless times and it did neverhappend. I also don’t remember anyone here posting of an attack on the band after the theurge sighted them. I therefore think the chance is either 0 or, if there’s a random generator here, still neglectably small.
It wouldn’t be a problem if this scene served to define some (invisible) stats expressing the style of leadership (for example cautious vs. risk-loving, rules-follower vs. situational or dictatorical vs. collegial), but apparently it doesn’t and therefore the whole scene has no real consequences. That’s what I consider a case of LIM
The text suggests that waiting until dawn and end of the rain is the reaction everyone prefers, and my knowledge from multille playthroughs also tells me there’s no reason to strike camp but doing the opposite is the default first choice, I always have to change this, and that’s annoying.
@WinterHawk I think the feeling can be as well transmitted with a plain text without this confusing choice, or if the choice is kept, either an attack could happen or not (randomly) if the band doesn’t steike camp or some hidden stats should be affected, or both. And I’d prefer the latter.