Bad writing is bad But none of the parameters put in the original post has nothing to do with Bad or good writing, They only address what the OP likes as a genre.
The fact X don’t like escapism and want all the stories to have to be about thoughtful dramatically designed social reality with all Ro coming out the closet … That can make good games or Propaganda de game only focused on SOCIAL INJUSTICE and none in the game it is supposed to be.
Due to that definition, Terry Pratchet books are bad writing. The life of Brian is a bad movie. Or Gower Midnight summer game or Tally oh. When all of that are masterpieces.
Being Dramatic doesn’t make something automatically good