@Eric_Moser Know that I love you, support you any way I can, and want to see you succeed, because I just went back to Goodreads for the first time in nearly ten years…all for you. [chokes back tears]
oh jesus christ, the amount of deadpool avatars are killing me i say this as someone who had a deadpool avatar the entire time i was on this site
Little background
Goodreads was actually my main social networking site from 2008-2010, and my best friend and I actually managed one of the most popular amateur writers group with over 5000 members in the heyday (which still isn’t bad considering the numbers I’m seeing right now). [/horn toot] So when I say I knew Goodreads…yeah, just trust me.
But around 2010, active participants had dwindled to but a handful of people who had forged ridiculously strong connections, and who had refused to migrate to either Facebook or tumblr, When I finally left, the only groups that remained active and fertile were roleplaying groups (which are still dominating the group list, I see) and groups for continuing book series (Hunger Games), and smaller groups like book clubs, hobby groups, etc.
It seems that it hasn’t actually changed much since the grand exodus.
Book clubs and roleplaying groups are still the most active, except now I don’t even see series-themed groups. When I left, the Harry Potter group was still an absolute beast, and the Hunger Games and Twilight groups took the second and third highest positions for number of members and activity.
I’m also checking the activity of forums members of the biggest groups (enter the group, click on members. they’re listed in descending order by the time they were last online) and a large handful of members don’t even have a single comment.
Despite the seemingly recent activity of most of the threads and topics, it seems like there’s only a handful of replies every day—even the largest group seems to only get a fraction of the traffic that this forum gets.
It seems that the Doom still rules in Valyria…
With that in mind, I’d say Goodreads is only worth it to have an author profile, but at this stage, even that doesn’t seem worth a daily effort.