Thank you very much for taking the time to type all that out! I’m really happy that William would be able to become Earl Of Arundel. At least, I think that would be one of his titles. Please correct me if I’m wrong. I don’t think Richard would be too happy about either that or him marrying Catherine. And it is very interesting to me that Bigod is related to Margaret, which I’m assuming would mean he is her grandson. I like to imagine he makes amends with William and even marries Cecilia, becoming his brother-in-law. As for the books you recommended, I can’t wait to check them out. I’ll also be looking for your works as well! Many thanks for letting me post my guide. Here it is. I hope someone can make use of it.
Guide Notes
1.This is only for the route where the Squire becomes a Knight Of The Garter/Rescues Cecilia/ Romances Catherine
2.I have tried to make this guide as detailed as possible, but I still might have made some mistakes.
3.I had to guess at some of the stat checks, such as William putting his hand on his sword in the Norfolk Tent. I am sure that most of them are correct, though.
4.I may have failed during a stat check, such as the Hill Of Glass, but it someone has a high enough skill they will pass.
5.Although the Lord Of Aconite, does not appear under the “Relationships & Allies” section, certain actions can gain or lose favor with him.
6.Rescuing Cecilia stops certain stat checks in Chapter Ten. An example would be William not being able to sneak into Castle Naward due to her protests.
Chapter One
(Choice #1)
A [+Hunting] {x}
B [+Combat]
C [+Archery]
D [+Music]
(Choice #2)
A [+Humility,-Pride] {x}
B [+Caution,-Courage]
C [+Superstition,-Rationality]
(Choice #3)
A [+Caution,-Courage]
B [+Courage,-Caution] {x}
C [+Pride,-Humility]
(Choice #4)
A [Character Customization] {x}
B [Character Customization]
C [Character Customization]
(Choice #5)
A [+Superstition,-Rationality]
B [+Rationality,-Superstition] {x}
C [Story Enhancement]
(Choice #6)
A [+Humility,-Pride]
B [+Courage,-Caution] {x}
C [+Pride,-Humility]
(Choice #7)
A [Story Enhancement]
B [Story Enhancement]
C [Story Enhancement] {x}
(Choice #8)
A [Horse Customization]{x}
B [Horse Customization]
C [Horse Customization]
D [Horse Customization]
E [Horse Customization]
(Choice #9)
A [+Caution,-Courage]
B [+Courage,-Caution] {x}
C [+Pride,-Humility]
(Choice #10)
A [Story Enhancement] {x}
B [Story Enhancement]
C [Story Enhancement]
(Choice #11)
A [+Chivalry,-Money] {x}
B [+Riding]
C [+Falconry]
(Choice #12)
A [+Rationality,-Superstition]
B [+Courage,-Caution] {x}
C [+Superstition,-Rationality]
(Choice #13)
A [Story Enhancement]
B [Story Enhancement]
C [Story Enhancement] {x}
(Choice #14)
A [+Riding}
B [+Chivalry]
C [+Archery]
D [+Hunting] {x}
(Choice #15)
A [+Pride,-Humility] {x}
B [+Caution,-Courage]
C [+Humility,-Pride]
(Choice #16)
A [Leads To Other Important Choices]
B [Leads To Other Important Choices]
C [Leads To Other Important Choices] {x}
(Choice #17)
A [+Catherine,-Money]
B [+Catherine,-Money] {x}
C [-Money And Kidnapping Clue]
(Choice #18)
A [+Caution,-Courage]
B [+Courage,-Caution] {x}
C [+Pride,-Humility]
D [+Humility,-Pride]
(Choice #19)
A [Character Customization]
B [Character Customization] {x}
C [Character Customization]
D [Character Customization]
E [Character Customization]
F [Character Customization]
G [Character Customization]
(Choice #20)
A [Character Customization] {x}
B [Character Customization]
(Choice #21)
A [+Courage,-Caution] {x}
B [+Caution,-Courage]
C [+Rationality,-Superstition]
(Choice #21)
A [+Rationality,-Superstition]
B [+Courage,-Caution] {x}
C [+Superstition,-Rationality]
(Choice #22)
A [+Combat]
B [+Riding]
C [+Chivalry] {x}
(Choice #23)
A [+Honor]
B [Cecilia Clue]
C [+Loyalty] {x}
D [+Catherine]
(Choice #24)
A [+Rationality And Honor,-Superstition]
B [+Superstition,-Rationality]
C [Leads To Other Important Choices] {x}
(Choice #25)
A [Leads To Other Important Choices]
B [Leads To Other Important Choices] {x}
C [Leads To Other Important Choices]
(Choice #26)
A [Leads To Other Important Choices]
B [Leads To Other Important Choices]
C [Leads To Other Important Choices] {x}
(Choice #27)
A [+Combat]
B [+Hunting,+Catherine] {x}
C [+Archery,-Catherine]
(Choice #28)
A [+Falconry,-Money]
B [Saves Money] {x}
C [+Falconry,-Money]
(Choice #29)
A [+Humility,-Pride] {x}
B [+Caution,-Courage]
C [+Pride,-Humility]
(Choice #30)
A [+Rationality,-Superstition]
B [+Courage,-Caution] {x}
C [+Superstition,-Rationality]
(Choice #31)
A [+Riding]
B [+Hunting] {x}
C [+Falconry]
(Choice #32)
A [+Rationality And Courage,-Supersition And Caution] {x}
B [+Superstition,-Rationality]
C [+Caution,-Courage]
(Choice #33)
A [+Caution, -Courage]
B [+Pride,-Humility] {x}
C [+Superstition,-Rationality]
(Choice #34)
A [Story Enhancement]
B [Story Enhancement] {x}
C [Story Enhancement]
(Choice #35)
A [+Rationality,-Superstition] {x}
B [Story Enhancement]
C [+Superstition,-Rationality]
(Choice #36)
A [+Humility,-Pride] {x}
B [+Caution,-Courage]
C [+Pride,-Humility]
(Choice #37)
A [+Pride,-Humility]
B [+Courage,-Caution] {x}
C [+Superstition,-Rationality]
D [Family Secret Clue]
(Choice #38)
A [Story Enhancement] {x}
B [Story Enhancement]
C [Story Enhancement]
(Choice #39)
A [+Combat]
B [+Archery]
C [+Music]
D [+Chivalry] {x}
Chapter Two
(Choice #1)
A [+Caution,-Courage]
B [+Humility,-Pride] {x}
C [+Pride,-Humility]
(Choice #2)
A [+Catherine,-Honor] {x}
B [+Loyalty,-Catherine]
C [+Honor,-Catherine]
(Choice #3)
A [Story Enhancement] {x}
B [Story Enhancement]
C [Story Enhancement]
(Choice #4)
A [+Superstition,-Rationality And Money]
B [+Caution,-Courage]
C [+Rationality,-Superstition] {x}
(Choice # 5)
A [Leads To Other Important Choices] {x}
B [Leads To Other Important Choices]
C [Leads To Other Important Choices]
D [Leads To Other Important Choices]
(Choice #6)
A [Story Enhancement] {x}
B [Story Enhancement]
C [Story Enhancement]
(Choice #7)
A [Leads To Other Important Choices] {x}
B [Leads To Other Important Choices]
C [+Rationality,-Superstiton)
(Choice #8)
A [-Money,+Sibyl] {x}
B [-Money And Stat Check (Pride)]
C [-Money And Stat Check (Humility)]
(Choice #9)
A [+Catherine]
B [+Honor] {x}
C [Cecilia Clue]
D [+Loyalty]
E [Family Secret Clue]
(Choice #10)
A [Story Enhancement] {x}
B [Story Enhancement]
C [Story Enhancement]
(Choice #11)
A [-Money And Tie To Cockaigne]
B [-Honor And Tie To Cockaigne]
C [-Loyalty And Tie To Cockaigne]
D [+Pride,-Humility, And Avoid Tie To Cockaigne] {x}
(Choice #12)
A [Leads To Other Important Choices]
B [Leads To Other Important Choices] {x}
C [Leads To Other Important Choices]
D [Leads To Other Important Choices]
(Choice 13)
A [+Courage,-Caution]
B [+Humility,-Pride] {x}
C [+Caution,-Courage]
(Choice #14)
A [+Pride,-Humility]
B [+Humility,-Pride]
C [+Courage,-Caution] {x}
(Choice #15)
A [+Pyers,-Money] {x}
B [Stat Check (Music)]
C [Stat Check (Pride)]
(Choice #16)
A [-Loyalty]
B [-Catherine]
C [+Honor And Music] {x}
(Choice #17)
A [+Pride,-Humility]
B [+Humility,-Pride]
C [+Courage-Caution] {x}
Chapter Three
(Choice #1)
A [Story Enhancement] {x}
B [Story Enhancement]
C [Story Enhancement]
(Choice #2)
A [+Pride,-Humility] {x}
B [+Humilty,-Pride]
C [+Caution,-Courage]
(Choice #3)
A [Stat Check (Music) And +Humility,-Pride]
B [Stat Check (Chivalry) And +Courage And Catherine,-Caution] {x}
C [Stat Check (Hunting) And +Caution And Catherine,-Courage]
(Choice #4)
A [Story Enhancement] {x}
B [Story Enhancement]
C [Story Enhancement]
(Choice #5)
A [Stat Check (Combat)]
B [Stat Check (Music)]
C [Stat Check (Archery)]
D [Stat Check (Rationality)] {x}
(Choice #6)
A [+Caution,-Courage]
B [+Courage,-Caution] {x}
C [+Superstition,-Rationality]
(Choice #7)
A [Leads To Other Important Choices]
B [Leads To Other Important Choices]
C [Leads To Other Important Choices] {x}
(Choice #8)
A [Stat Check (Rationality)]
B [Stat Check (Pride)]
C [Stat Check (Courage)] {x}
(Choice #9)
A [+Loyalty And Honor] {x}
B [+Loyalty]
C [+Loyalty And Baron Strange,-Catherine]
Chapter Four
(Choice #1)
A [+Superstition,-Rationality]
B [+Pride,-Humility]
C [+Rationality,-Superstition] {x}
(Choice #2)
A [Story Enhancement]
B [Story Enhancement] {x}
C [Story Enhancement]
(Choice #3)
A [Stat Check (Combat)]
B [Stat Check (Hunting)]
C [Stat Check (Hunting) And +Catherine] {x}
(Choice #4)
A [Leads To Other Important Choices]
B [Leads To Other Important Choices] {x}
C [Leads To Other Important Choices]
D [Leads To Other Important Choices]
(Choice #5)
A [+Pyers]
B [Stat Check (Music)]
C [+Courage,-Caution] {x}
(Choice #6)
A [Stat Check (Combat)]
B [Stat Check (Archery)]
C [Stat Check (Hunting)] {x}
(Choice #7)
A [+Caution,-Courage]
B [+Courage,-Caution] {x}
C [+Baron Strange,-Catherine]
(Choice #8)
A [Leads To Other Important Choices] {x}
B [Leads To Other Important Choices]
C [Leads To Other Important Choices]
D [Leads To Other Important Choices]
(Choice #9)
A [+Sibyl]
B [+Sibyl] {x}
C [Stat Check (Superstition)]
D [Family Secret Clue]
(Choice #10)
A [Stat Check (Combat) And +Catherine]
B [Stat Check (Archery) And +Catherine]
C [Stat Check (Hunting) And +Honor And Catherine] {x}
D [Stat Check (Riding) And +Catherine]
(Choice #11)
A [Story Enhancement]
B [Story Enhancement] {x}
C [Story Enhancement]
(Choice #12)
A [Story Enhancement]
B [Story Enhancement] {x}
C [Story Enhancement]
(Choice #13)
A [+Combat]
B [+Riding]
C [+Archery]
D [+Hunting] {x}
E [+Music]
(Choice #14)
A [+Catherine]
B [+Loyalty] {x}
C [+Honor]
Chapter Five
(Choice #1)
A [Story Enhancement]
B [Story Enhancement]
C [Story Enhancement] {x}
(Choice #2)
A [+Pride and Honor,-Humility and Money]
B [+Humility,-Pride] {x}
C [+Pride,-Humility]
(Choice #3)
A [Contest Choice]
B [Contest Choice]
C [Contest Choice] {x}
D [Contest Choice]
E [Contest Choice]
(Choice #4)
A [Story Enhancement]
B [Story Enhancement] {x}
C [Story Enhancement]
(Choice #5)
A [Favor Gain] {x}
B [Favor Gain]
C [Favor Gain]
(Choice #6)
A [Hunt With Bow]
B [Hunt With Spear]
C [Hunt With Boar Spear] {x}
(Choice #7)
A [+Honor] {x}
B [Story Enhancement]
C [-Honor]
(Choice #8)
A [Stat Check (Courage)] {x}
B [Stat Check (Caution)]
C [Story Enhancement]
(Choice #9)
A [Stat Check (Unknown)] {x}
B [Stat Check (Unknown)]
C [Stat Check (Unkown)]
(Choice #10)
A [Leads To Other Important Choices]
B [Leads To Other Important Choices]
C [+Loyalty] {x}
(Choice #11)
A [Stat Check (Courage) And Contest Win +Money] {x}
B [Stat Check (Rationaity) And Contest Win+Money]
C [Stat Check (Superstition) And Conest Win+Money]
(Choice #12)
A [Romance Success And +Catherine]
B [Romance Fail And +Catherine]
Chapter Six
(Choice #1)
A [Leads To Other Important Choices]
B [Leads To Other Important Choices] {x}
C [Leads To Other Important Choices]
(Choice #2)
A [Stat Check (Archery)]
B [Stat Check (Hunting)] {x}
C [Stat Check (Combat)]
(Choice #3)
A [Stat Check (Combat)] {x}
B [Stat Check (Archery)]
C [Stat Check (Rationality)]
D [Stat Check (Humility)]
(Choice #4)
A [Story Enhancement] {x}
B [+Caution,-Courage]
C [+Superstition,-Rationality)
(Choice #5)
A [Stat Check (Hunting)] {x}
B [Stat Check (Courage)]
C [Stat Check (Hunting),-Money]
(Choice #6)
A [Stat Check (Hunting)] {x}
B [Stat Check (Archery)]
C [Stat Check (Combat)]
(Choice #7)
A [Stat Check (Combat)]
B [Stat Check (Hunting)] {x}
C [Stat Check (Archery)]
D [Stat Check (Courage)]
(Choice #8)
A [+Abbey,-Money]
B [+Abbey As Ally,-Money] {x}
C [+Superstition,-Rationality And Abbey]
D [-Abbey]
Chapter Seven
(Choice #1)
A [+Pride,-Humility]
B [+Courage,-Caution] {x}
C [+Caution,-Courage]
D [+Humility,-Pride]
(Choice #2)
A [Story Enhancement]
B [Story Enhancement] {x}
C [Story Enhancement]
(Choice #3)
A [Stat Check (Pride)]
B [Stat Check (Courage)] {x}
C [Stat Check (Rationality)]
(Choice #4)
A [Stat Check (Honor)] {x}
B [Sat Check (Rationality)]
C [Stat Check (Pride) And +Pride,-Humility]
(Choice #5)
A [Stat Check (Rationality)]
B [Stat Check (Honor)] {x}
C [Stat Check (Humility)]
(Choice #6)
A [Cecilia Clue]
B [+Honor] {x}
C [+Loyalty]
(Choice #7)
A [Stat Chack (Combat) And -Catherine[
B [Stat Check (Music) And -Catherine]
C [Stat Check (Honor)] {x}
(Choice #8)
A [+Combat]
B [+Music]{x}
C [+Archery]
D [+Riding]
(Choice #9)
A [Story Enhancement]
B [Story Enhancement] {x}
C [Story Enhancement]
(Choice #10)
A [+Courage,-Caution] {x}
B [+Caution,-Courage]
C [+Caution and Pride,-Courage And Humility
(Choice #11)
A [Stat Check (Loyalty) And +Catherine]
B [Stat Check (Courage) And +Catherine] {x}
C [Stat Check (Pride)]
(Choice #12)
A [Story Enhancement]
B [Romantic Scene] {x}
C [Story Enhancement]
(Choice #13)
A [+Fair,-Abbey]
B [-Abbey]
C [+Abbey and Fair] {x}
Chapter Eight
(Choice #1)
A [Story Enhancement] {x}
B [Story Enhancement]
C [Story Enhancement]
(Choice #2)
A [Story Enhancement] {x}
B [Story Enhancement]
C [Story Enhancement]
(Choice #3)
A [+Catherine] {x}
B [+Honor]
C [+Loyalty]
(Choice #4)
A [Story Enhancement]
B [+Rationality,-Superstition] {x}
C [+Superstition, -Rationality]
(Choice #5)
A [Story Enhancement] {x}
B [Story Enhancement]
C [Story Enhancement]
(Choice #6)
A [Story Enhancement] {x}
B [Story Enhancement]
C [Story Enhancement]
(Choice #7)
A [+Courage,-Caution] {x}
B [+Caution,-Courage]
C [+Superstiton,-Rationality]
(Choice #8)
A [Leads To Other Important Choices] {x}
B [Leads To Other Important Choices]
C [Leads To Other Important Choices]
(Choice #9)
A [Stat Check (Riding) And -Honor]
B [Stat Check (Hunting)] {x}
C [-Honor]
(Choice #10)
A [Stat Check (Music) And Cecilia Clue]
B [Stat Check (Hunting) And Cecilia Clue {x}
C [Stat Check (Chivalry) And Cecilia Clue]
(Choice #11)
A [Stat Check (Caution) And -Money]
B [Stat Check (Archery) And -Money]
C [Stat Check (Riding) And -Money] {x}
(Choice #12)
A [Sat Check (Rationality)] {x}
B [Stat Check (Pride)]
C [Stat Check (Caution)]
(Choice #13)
A [Stat Check (Courage)] {x}
B [Stat Check (Humility)]
C [Stat Check (Faith)]
(Choice #14)
A [Story Enhancement] {x}
B [Story Enhancement]
C [Story Enhancement]
Chapter Nine
(Choice #1)
A [Leads To Other Important Choices]
B [Leads To Other Important Choices] {x}
C [Leads To Other Important Choices]
(Choice #2)
A [Leads To Other Important Choices] {x}
B [Leads To Other Important Choices]
C [Leads To Other Important Choices]
(Choice #3)
A [Stat Check (Hunting)] {x}
B [Stat Check (Archery)]
C [Stat Check (Hunting)]
(Choice #4)
A [+Aconite]
B [-Aconite] {x}
C [-Pyers]
(Choice #5)
A [+Loyalty]
B [Leads To Other Important Choices]
C [Leads To Other Important Choices] {x}
(Choice #6)
A [Stat Check (Courage) And Cecilia Clue] {x}
B [Stat Check (Rationality) And Cecilia Clue]
C [Stat Check (Humility) And Cecilia Clue]
(Choice #7)
A [-Aconite] {x}
B [+Aconite,-Honor]
C [Unknown]
(Choice #8)
A [Stat Check (Humility)]
B [Stat Check (Rationality)] {x}
C [Stat Check (Superstition)]
(Choice #9)
A [Stat Check (Honor)]
B [Stat Check (Loyalty)]
C [Stat Check (Catherine)] {x}
D [Stat Check (Pyers)]
(Choice #10)
A [Stat Check (Combat)]
B [Stat Check (Archery)]
C [Stat Check (Hunting)] {x}
(Choice #11)
A [Stat Check (Pride)]
B [Stat Check (Courage)] {x}
C [Stat Check (Faith)]
D [+Tie To Cockaigne]
Chapter Ten
(Choice #1)
A [Story Enhancement] {x}
B [Story Enhancement]
C [Story Enhancement]
(Choice #2)
A [Story Enhancement]
B [Story Enhancement]
C [Story Enhancement] {x}
(Choice #3)
A [Story Enhancement]
B [Story Enhancement] {x}
C [Story Enhancement]
(Choice #4)
A [Story Enhancement]
B [Story Enhancement] {x}
C [Story Enhancment]
(Choice #5)
A [Story Enhancement]
B [Story Enhancement]
C [Story Enhancement] {x}
(Choice #6)
A [Choose Baron Strange As An Ally]
B [Choose Crook’s Field Fair As An Ally]
C [Choose The Abbey As An Ally] {x}
D [Choose No Ally}
(Choice #7)
A [-Loyalty]
B [-Honor]
C [-Catherine] {x}
D [-Pyers]
(Choice #8)
A [Story Enhancement]
B [Story Enhancement]
C [Story Enhancement] {x}
D [Story Enhancement]
(Choice #9)
A [Stat Check (Unknown)]
B [Stat Check (Hunting)] {x}
C [Stat Check (Unknown)]
D [Wait For Ally]
(Choice #10)
A [Stat Check (Superstition)]
B [Stat Check (Courage)] {x}
C [Stat Check (Caution)]
(Choice #11)
A [Stat Check (Humility,Loyalty, And Honor)] {x}
B [Stat Check (Faith)]
C [Stat Check (Caution And Pride)]
(Choice #12)
A [Stat Check (Hunting) {x}
B [Stat Check (Combat)]
C [Stat Check (Archery)]
(Choice #13)
A [Stat Check (Kidnapping Clues)]
B [Stat Check (Cecilia Rescue)] {x}
C [Stat Check (Combat)]
D [Stat Check (Loyalty)]
(Choice #14)
A [Stat Check (Rationality)] {x}
B [Stat Check (Honor)]
C [Stat Check (Loyalty)]
(Choice #15)
A [Stat Check (Humility)]
B [Stat Check (Caution)]
C [Stat Check (Rationality)] {x}