There isn’t really two sides to this request. This wasn’t me demanding readers give feedback it wasn’t me saying readers owe authors anything.
It is merely a request for readers who enjoy the story to leave a comment or a like. So newer authors get that little push they need to continue.
An author should write for the love of their story. But don’t forget a lot of authors here are young and new to this so it is hard for them not to worry.
And “am I doing this right? Does this make sense? Is my writing style okay?” are all perfectly valid questions for someone to want an answer to, where it is other people’s opinions that actually matter.
I would have stopped writing so many times if it wasn’t for little things like that. I don’t actually need to write for being able to quietly enjoy my own story in my head, after all.
If someone wanted to right just for themselves, they wouldn’t publish it in the first place. We who are seeking to publish want our story read, shared, and improved. We want to improve as writers.